Toronto

Province not doing enough to prevent urban flooding, Ontario auditor general finds

Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk says Ontario is not doing enough to prevent urban flooding, a problem expected to worsen in the coming years.

Percentage of urban land considered 'green' declined by 94% over last 20 years, audit shows

A woman wading through floodwaters during a storm in Toronto in 2013. The auditor general says the province must do more to prevent urban flooding. (Frank Gunn/The Canadian Press)

Ontario is not doing enough to prevent urban flooding, a problem that is expected to worsen in the coming years, the province's auditor general says.

The findings are part of the 2022 Auditor General's Report, which points to the province's failure to clarify its commitments to manage urban flooding and a failure to adequately support municipalities and homeowners to effectively tackle the problem.

Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk says it isn't just a problem for the three per cent of Ontarians who live near rivers. 

"All Ontarians who live in cities, towns and smaller communities may be at risk of flooding," said Lysyk, who added that not addressing the problem will be costly.

Lysyk's report recommends updating the building code, improving urban flood risk mapping and better protecting green and natural spaces such as wetlands.

Understanding floodplain mapping

Lysyk says there are gaps in provincial flood mapping to identify risk areas and allow communities to prepare. 

Understanding floodplains is important in large communities like Toronto and the risks of not doing so would surprise many, says Cynthia Wilkey, co-chair of the West Don Lands Committee.

Until about a decade ago, much of Toronto's downtown was at risk of flooding from the Don River, she says. But groups  advocated for the creation of a flood protection landform on the river's west bank.

Cynthia Wilkey, co-chair of the West Don Lands Committee, says the consequences of failing to prevent urban flooding could be tragic. (Submitted by Cynthia Wilkey)

"It was a struggle to get that through people's heads that you have to do this," Wilkey told CBC Toronto. 

"It cost money to do it, but it has now protected billions of dollars in real estate and not to mention human lives," she added.

"If you don't plan in advance, there can be terrible, tragic consequences."

Doing so can also lead to opportunities for development, she says. Measures being taken on the east side of the Don River to divert the river and engage in grade raising have actually unlocked land for development in the Portlands that previously would have been in a floodplain, Wilkey says.

The Don River, seen here alongside a stretch of Toronto's Don Valley Parkway, winds from the Oak Ridges Moraine all the way south to Lake Ontario. (Lauren Pelley/CBC News)

A spokesperson for the Ministry of Environment, Conservation and Parks said in a written statement Friday that while a significant share of the responsibility for flood management falls to municipalities, the provincial government is prepared to help.

The ministry says it's contributing $25 million toward stormwater infrastructure, and conducting a provincewide climate change impact assessment.

Premier Doug Ford said in a news conference Friday that he would not be building on floodplains in sections of the Greenbelt opened up by his government's sweeping new housing legislation. 

But the report says municipalities large and small need more financial and centralized support to ensure flood planning is done well.

Mark Winfield, a professor of environmental and urban change at Toronto's York University, says the province will now face a new challenge ensuring flood planning is thorough, because the controversial new housing bill weakens the powers and tools available to conservation authorities.

"The conservation authorities are kind of our secret weapon in this. And they already put Ontario ahead of the game," said Winfield.

He says he's disappointed the auditor did not speak more about the impact that lessening the powers of conservation authorities could have on flood mitigation. 

"We need to make sure that they have the tools and the resources to be able to respond to this challenge." 

Better protection for wetlands

The audit found that over the past 20 years, the percentage of urban land considered "green" declined by 94 per cent in Ontario's medium and large urban centres. 

It also found no provincial strategy exists to conserve wetlands, in particular, as previous targets were nixed by the Ford government in 2018, even though southern Ontario has been losing an average of 1,825 hectares of wetlands a year already.

The 2022 Auditor General's Report recommends more protection for wetlands to prevent flooding. (Ash Abraham/CBC )

Winfield says maintaining lands like wetlands and other permeable surfaces is essential in flood mitigation because it means water has somewhere to go when levels rise.

Updating the building code

The report says many new homeowners are not protected from sewer backups due to vague requirements in Ontario's building code for backwater valves. 

Lysyk says that just doesn't make sense.

"A backwater valve costs about $250 to install during construction of a new home, while renovating to add one costs thousands," she wrote.

"And damage to a flooded home can cost more than $40,000 to repair." 

Lysyk is recommending a change to the building code to require all newly built homes to have backwater valves. 

Floodwaters are shown here on Toronto Island. Damage from flooding can cost homeowners thousands of dollars. (Submitted photo: Linda Rosebaum)

Winfield says insurers are already talking about flooding as the next big threat.

"It's far cheaper to be ahead of the curve and to be identifying these kinds of threats, and taking the measures now to prevent them," he said.

Those who have experienced recent urban floods know what that's like first hand.

When Linda Rosenbaum's home on Toronto Island flooded a few years ago, the damages cost more than $10,000. 

"Every household has had their insurance go up because of where we are located and [it's] gone up tremendously," she said.

Conservation authorities did a lot to help during the crisis for the community, but Rosenbaum says she'd like to see more work done to prevent floods. 

"Watching the water rise, not knowing when it's going to stop, it's incredibly anxiety-making." 

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Clara Pasieka is a CBC journalist in Toronto. She has also worked in CBC's national bureau and as a reporter in the Northwest Territories, Ontario and New Brunswick. Her investigative work following the Nova Scotia Mass Shooting was a finalist for a CAJ Award. She holds a Masters degree in Public Policy, Law and Public Administration from York University.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now