Toronto

Province cut some injection sites because area residents 'upset,' Ford says

Premier Doug Ford pointed to "upset" Cabbagetown residents, when asked why he was eliminating several provincially-funded supervised injection sites.

People will die if sites shut down, says Toronto's medical officer of health

Doug Ford's government announced changes Friday to its overdose prevention strategy, which included abruptly stopping support for some sites that were already operating. (CBC)

People will die if Doug Ford's government doesn't reverse its decision to stop funding some safe injection sites, said Toronto's Medical Officer of Health on Monday, but the premier said he also has to listen to residents who don't want the sites in their "backyard."

"These are life-saving services," said Dr. Eileen de Villa on CBC's Metro Morning. "So when you take them away, I fully anticipate that more people will die."

Meanwhile, Premier Doug Ford pointed to "upset" Cabbagetown residents when asked why his government is limiting the number of overdose prevention sites in Ontario.

The government shocked service providers on Friday, announcing that some sites in Toronto would no longer get funding and had to close a couple days later.

"It's all right for people to say, 'Yes help 'em, help 'em," Ford said in Etobicoke Monday morning, referring to people who use drugs and the supervised sites set up to prevent them from overdosing. 

"But with all due respect ... if I put one beside your house, you'd be going ballistic," the premier said at a news conference about his government's move to scrap the province's Drive Clean program.

'Funded through bake sales'

The two defunded Toronto sites were given a last-minute federal exemption to stay open another month, but will no longer receive provincial money, said Coun. Joe Cressy.

The Works, a large city-run site site by Yonge-Dundas Square, is on hold because it's still under review.

This means "we have life-saving healthcare programs that will be funded through bake sales," said Cressy, chair of Toronto's board of health, at a news conference Monday. 

Toronto's mayor, councillors and the city's medical officer of health have condemned the decision, but Ford suggested to reporters on Monday that some downtown residents support the changes. 

Dr. Eileen de Villa says the opioid crisis is the 'defining' health crisis of our time. (CBC)

When asked why he was eliminating sites, Ford talked about a "great conversation with the Cabbagetown association" on Sunday where people expressed concern about several sites in the same neighbourhood.

"They told me last night on the phone ... there's four safe injection sites within a kilometre," Ford said, who did not clarify whether he was talking about the Cabbagetown Residents Association or the local BIA.

"They don't want 'em down there."

Ford said he believes in listening to neighbourhoods, and "they're upset."

Sites have saved hundreds of lives

More than 1,200 people died from opioid-related overdoses in Ontario in 2017, according to Public Health Ontario. More than 600 people died from overdoses in the first half of 2018, the most recent data available shows. 

Overdose prevention sites have already saved hundreds of lives. The Works had more than 40,000 visits since August 2017, de Villa said. During that time, they've reversed around 750 overdoses.

The opioid crisis is the "defining health crisis of our time," Dr. de Villa repeated. "Now is not the time to be withdrawing services."

Supervised injection sites have already saved hundreds of lives, says Toronto's medical officer of health. (Darryl Dyck/Canadian Press)

'Not in my backyard'

Ford said he's "passionate" about helping people with addictions and wants to prevent opioid-related deaths. He called the number of deaths "unacceptable" and said his priority was getting people into treatment.

But, he said, "there's really no reason to have four sites within a kilometre of one neighbourhood."

'It's ok, help em, but 'not in my backyard,'" Ford said. "That's the reality of things."

A spokeswoman for Health Minister Christine Elliott said proximity to other treatment sites was just one of the criteria used in reviewing the sites.

The province also looked at commitment to community outreach, compliance with accessibility laws and whether they offered "integrated, wrap-around health and social services," said Hayley Chazan.

The province said it had approved 15 sites across Ontario and "will continue to accept applications from interested organizations."

The aim of the newly approved facilities, to be called "consumption and treatment services" sites, is to ensure those struggling with drug addiction can get supports that include rehabilitation as well as a safe place to use their drugs, it said.

Closing one site with 60% women

St. Stephen's Community House in Kensington Market and Street Health's Overdose Prevention Site by Dundas and Sherbourne both lost provincial funding.

Kapri Rubin, executive director of Street Health, said the site is in a high-need community that has the second-most paramedic calls in the city.

In addition, Rubin said, 60 per cent of their clients are women.

Kapri Rubin, executive director of Street Health, says their defunded overdose prevention site at Dundas and Sherbourne is in a high-need neighbourhood with a large proportion of clients who are women. (CBC)

Operators of Ontario's overdose prevention sites issued an open letter to Elliott on Monday, condemning the decision not to fund all of the previously approved sites and calling on the government to reverse its position or at least support a "three-month transition phase."

"Without any transition plan in place, the 15 sites that were approved to continue operating do not have the immediate capacity and/or geographic proximity to the closed sites to take on the influx of clients that will no longer be able to access harm reduction services," the letter reads.

With files from Metro Morning, The Canadian Press

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.