Lawyers for disqualified pot shop applicants say Ontario's process was unfair
Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario said group missed a deadline, but group says that's not the case
A legal battle over Ontario's licensing system for retail cannabis stores focused Wednesday on the steps taken by the province to contact a number of applicants who were later disqualified for failing to file documents by a certain date.
The group of 11 applicants is challenging the rejection and disputing the fairness of the procedures involved in the lottery that has been used to grant all of Ontario's pot shop licences.
At a hearing in Toronto, the group's lawyers argued Wednesday that under the rules set out by the provincial agency overseeing the process, those who win the chance to apply must submit certain documents within five business days once they are notified of their selection.
They said an email alerting their clients of the lottery's outcome and the application timeline did not go through, and as such, the deadline should have been re-calculated based on when the message was actually delivered.
The Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario "just determined that the attempt-to-notify was sufficient" to trigger the countdown, which is unfair and unreasonable, lawyer Michael Lacy told a three-judge panel.
As a result, he argued, the commission was not entitled to disqualify the 11 applicants or to select a new slate of applicants to replace them.
Lawyers representing the commission, however, said the eliminated applicants were to blame for the email bouncing back since they provided the address and chose that method of communication.
What's more, Judie Im argued, the commission then followed up with telephone calls, posted the list of lottery winners online and eventually sent letters by courier. Many of the calls failed to reach the applicants and three never picked up the packages, she said.
When they did receive a letter notifying them of their selection, the applicants should have seen that it was dated Aug. 21 and laid out a deadline of Aug. 28, she added.
"The fault lies with them and not the registrar," Im said, noting none of the applicants sought to clarify the deadline or obtain an extension.
The dispute largely revolves over what it means to be notified, and whether delivery or receipt of the message is required, Ontario Superior Court Justice David Corbett said.
Earlier this month, Corbett paused the licensing process for the latest round of cannabis stores until the case is resolved.
Lawyers representing the commission had contested the stay, saying it would interfere with the integrity of the lottery system. There was also opposition from lawyers representing the applicants selected to replace those eliminated.
So far, there have been two rounds of the government lottery to determine who can apply to open cannabis stores. The first involved 25 spots and the second, 42.
Lottery winners have five business days to turn in their application, along with a $6,000 non-refundable fee and a $50,000 letter of credit.
The legal challenge may affect the government's timeline to increase the number of legal pot shops in the province.