Toronto

Ontario to fund more private clinic surgeries, send patients to temporary LTCs to ease health-care pressures

Ontario Health Minister Sylvia Jones's plan to stabilize the health-care system includes increasing surgeries performed at private clinics but covered by OHIP, covering the exam and registration fees for internationally trained nurses, and sending patients waiting for a long-term care bed to a home not of their choosing.

Province's 5-point plan aims to reduce hospitalizations, surgical wait lists

Private clinic surgeries, temporary LTCs part of Ontario’s health system plan

4 months ago
Duration 2:58
The Ontario government has laid out a plan to take pressure off its health-care system that involves increasing the number of publicly covered surgeries offered at private clinics, while also moving patients waiting for long-term care beds to temporary homes to create more hospital capacity. But critics say it moves the province toward a two-tiered health-care system.

Ontario is hoping to ease health-care pressures by increasing publicly covered surgeries at private clinics, waiving the exam and registration fees for internationally trained nurses, and sending patients waiting for a long-term care bed to a home not of their choosing.

On Thursday, Health Minister Sylvia Jones announced a plan that aims to hire more health professionals, free up hospital beds and reduce surgical wait lists. The plan comes as nursing staff shortages have seen emergency departments across the province close throughout the summer for hours or days at a time.

On long-term care, the government plans to introduce legislation today that will allow patients awaiting a bed to be transferred to a "temporary" home while they await space in their preferred home. It's also taking 300 beds that had been used for COVID-19 isolation and making them available for people on wait lists, and says there is a potential to do that with 1,000 more beds within six months.

The Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care confirmed to CBC Toronto that 200 people who have been in hospital for six months waiting for LTC beds will be moved within the next three months, with a total of 1,300 moved by March 2023. 

WATCH | Ontario health minister outlines 5-point plan to improve care:

Ontario health minister outlines 5-point plan to improve care

4 months ago
Duration 2:05
Health Minister Sylvia Jones says Ontario's new plan to improve health care will add workers, improve innovation and expand the number of available hospital beds.

However, Long-Term Care Minister Paul Calandra said the legislation would not force anybody who doesn't want to leave the hospital to go, nor would it make "any changes to the priority waiting list." 

"The changes do allow us to continue that conversation to explain to somebody who is in a hospital why their needs can be met in a long-term care home," said Calandra.

The province's plan also mentions "mandatory guidelines used by placement coordinators to ensure patients continue to stay close to a partner, spouse, loved ones or friends." 

Changes won't solve core problem, critics say

But NDP health critic France Gélinas said the province would be better off bolstering the home-care system with more full-time personal support workers. 

"Now, hospitals will have the right to put a ton of pressure on you and on your family to move you to the first bed available, not the bed of your choice," she said.

"This is disrespectful, this is not the way health care should be."

Gélinas suggested the first available beds would likely be "in a private, for-profit home," some of which were the subject of a scathing military report in 2020 after suffering some of the worst COVID-19 outbreaks in the province.

In a statement, Lisa Levin, the CEO of AdvantAge, an association of not-for-profit senior care organizations, says they're concerned about closing isolation beds at this time. According to Public Health Ontario, there are 181 long-term care homes in active COVID-19 outbreaks as of Aug. 13.

"We must ensure sufficient safeguards exist to protect those residents against COVID-19," said Levin.

The province also announced plans to invest up to $57.6 million over three years to increase the number of nurse practitioners working in long-term care homes.

While the new investments provide important resources and funding to the sector, Donna Duncan, the CEO of the Ontario Long Term Care Association, says it's not enough to address the day-to-day staffing challenges facing all homes, and particularly those in rural and remote communities.

"To support safe admissions from hospital, we need to ensure that our homes have the health human and other workforce resources, especially as we move into the anticipated fall flu/COVID season," wrote Duncan.

According to the Ontario Long Term Care Association, homes facilitate over 37,000 transitions from hospitals to long-term care a year, ensuring appropriate flow through 2,200 acute care beds. (CBC)

The association says it represents nearly 70 per cent of Ontario's 630 long-term care homes, in a mix of private, not-for-profit, charitable, and municipal settings. Duncan says the association faces an LTC wait list of nearly 40,000 people, with seniors "needing quality care close to loved onces and their communities."

"All health sectors are facing severe workforce shortages and we are all looking to hire from the same pool of available health professionals," said Duncan.

Greater role for privately delivered services

The province's plan outlines more of a role for privately delivered but publicly covered services, with the government saying it will invest more to increase surgeries in pediatric hospitals and existing private clinics covered by OHIP. It is also considering options for further increasing surgical capacity by increasing the number of those procedures performed at "independent health facilities."

Jones said Ontario needs to be "bold, innovative and creative" when looking for ways to improve the health system.

"There are some who will fight for the status quo no matter what," she said at a news conference announcing the plan. "They're ideologically opposed to change or improvements. We won't accept that. We can't accept that. People want better health care."

Jones did not directly answer a question about whether she would consider allowing more private clinics in Ontario.

"Health care will continue to be provided to the people of Ontario through the use of your OHIP card," she said.

Nurses' association opposes more privatization 

Cathryn Hoy, president of the Ontario Nurses' Association, slammed the plan to increase services in private clinics.

"This is a blatant move that will line the pockets of investors, nothing more," she said in a statement.

"The evidence is clear: health-care privatization provides worse health outcomes to our patients and has much higher overhead costs which will be paid by taxpayers. Ontario is deep-diving into privatization that will only benefit shareholders."

WATCH | OMA president Dr. Rose Zacharias comments on provincial health-care plan: 

Ontario outlines 5-point plan to ease health-care pressures

4 months ago
Duration 5:53
Dr. Rose Zacharias, President of the Ontario Medical Association joins The Rundown to discuss Ontario's 5-point plan that aims to ease the strain on the province's health-care system.

Hoy called it "puzzling" that the plan also outlines steps to support emergency department doctors, but not nurses.

"The government missed a huge opportunity here to bolster nurse compensation as a key to retention and recruitment to curb additional closures," she said.

Ontario is extending and introducing a range of programs aimed at bolstering hospital staff in northern and rural communities, such as getting ER physicians to support and coach those in rural ERs, and linking physician residents with those in northern and rural ERs.

In a statement, Liberal health critic Dr. Adil Shamji called the plan "a series of empty promises" that showed the government "did not learn any lessons from the pandemic."

"Rather than ignoring her responsibility to strengthen our publicly funded healthcare system by asking the for-profit sector to solve the problems," the MPP said the health minister "must provide real solutions that address the root causes of the extreme pressure facing our healthcare system."

Viable solutions include creating "a robust nursing workforce by repealing Bill 124," Shamji said, along with increased funding for community and primary care operations that would reduce ER visits. Until then, he said, "this crisis will continue to spiral out of control." 

Ontario to cover fees for some nurses

Meanwhile, the province will temporarily cover exam, application and registration fees for internationally trained and retired nurses, saving them up to $1,500.

Jones said she is expecting a plan today from both the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario, as well as the College of Nurses of Ontario, on how they intend to expedite the applications of those professionals still waiting to be accredited and licensed in Ontario. 

The nursing college's plan involves temporarily registering thousands of internationally-trained nurses.

The province's plan also includes modifying a program that can deploy nurses full-time across multiple hospitals in a region, and expanding a program for mid-to-late career or retired nurses to mentor newer nurses.

"There are many pieces that are part of this plan and they aren't done," Jones told reporters.

With files from CBC News

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now