Toronto·Analysis

Why Doug Ford is playing nice with Justin Trudeau

The smiles from Ontario Premier Doug Ford and his friendly bantering with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau as the pair met on Parliament Hill were in no way just an act for the cameras.

To keep his key promises before facing re-election, Ontario's premier needs the PM's help

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Ontario Premier Doug Ford share a laugh at the start of their meeting in Ottawa last Friday. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

The smiles from Ontario Premier Doug Ford and his friendly bantering with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau as the pair met on Parliament Hill last week were in no way just an act for the cameras.

It was a sharp change for Canada's two most powerful politicians, who spent much of the past 18 months as each other's political targets. Trudeau invoked Ford's name on the campaign trail so often that jokes were made about who he was actually running against. Last year, Ford was openly calling for Trudeau's defeat. 

The prime minister and the premier have now seemingly buried the hatchet and moved on. Each has motivations for wanting a more harmonious relationship now. Here's what's in it for Ford.

Federal favours

Ontario next goes to the polls in June 2022, and much of Ford's re-election hopes will hinge on showing progress toward solving the Toronto area's transit problem.

He cannot build his grand vision for new subway lines without the federal government on board. During the campaign, Trudeau promised federal funding for the projects. Attacking Trudeau would not encourage the money to flow.  

Ford could also do with some federal help to keep another of his key campaign pledges: ending what has been called the hallway health-care problem. He named health as one of the main topics of his meeting with Trudeau last Friday.

Until their Parliament Hill meeting last Friday, the only time Ford and Trudeau met in 2019 was at the Toronto Raptors championship parade in June. (Chris Young/The Canadian Press)

"I think the premier genuinely believes a lot of his remaining priorities in this mandate rely on his ability to work with the prime minister," says Ginny Roth, a senior executive with government relations firm Crestview Strategy and a longtime Progressive Conservative insider. 

Rehabilitating his image

Ford spent his first year in power in adversarial combat mode, seeming to emphasize campaigning over governing. It helped create a perception that he's more a brawler than a premier, and that didn't go so well for his polling numbers. 

To change that perception, Ford needs to prove he's a politician who gets things done. Working well with Trudeau can help him accomplish that rehab of his reputation. 

Ford is seizing on a vein of public opinion that suggests "what Ontario voters want to see right now is somebody willing to work positively, rather than just to have wars of words over and over again," says Kate Harrison, another PC party insider and a vice-president of Summa Strategies, a government relations firm. 

The people now around Ford have helped the premier realize that portraying an aura of competence in governing is infinitely better than giving off an aura of chaos. It's no coincidence this shift began with the departure of Ford's original chief of staff — the combative and controversial Dean French — and the arrival of his replacement, James Wallace, by all accounts a more even-keeled manager.   

Ford needs Trudeau voters

The results of the federal election in Ontario showed clearly that voters have not turned against Trudeau. Ontario sent 79 Liberal MPs to Ottawa last month: many of those federal Liberal voters helped send 76 Progressive Conservative MPPs to Queen's Park just last year. Ford needs those people to stick with him in the next election, especially in the crucial 905 battleground, if he's to hang on to his majority. 

Last December's meeting between Trudeau and Ford, at the conference of first ministers in Montreal, was decidedly icy. (Paul Chiasson/The Canadian Press)

"Doug Ford is the ultimate pragmatist," says Harrison. "He wants to be where public opinion is and where it's going, and if that means working across parties to do it, then so be it."  

There's simply no political upside right now for Ford to bash Trudeau and his newly re-elected Liberal government. That's unlike his Alberta and Saskatchewan counterparts, Jason Kenney and Scott Moe, whose populations wholeheartedly rejected the Liberals. 

National stature

Trudeau does not have many friends among the premiers. Ford has an opportunity to be his premier bestie right now. As someone who has a political affinity for Kenney and Moe, and gets along with Quebec Premier François Legault, Ford can act as a go-between for the PM and the fractious premiers, and score points for playing a peacemaker role. 

Ford will have a chance to show that kind of national stature on Monday when he hosts the premiers in Mississauga for a post-election meeting of the Council of the Federation. 

"He clearly is trying to position himself as a peace broker between some of the really angry western premiers and the prime minister and I think he has a real opportunity to do that," says Roth. 

Ford's first meeting with Trudeau took place at the Ontario Legislature in July 2018, shortly after Ford took office. (Chris Young/The Canadian Press)

Still, it means rising above the mud that Trudeau slung at him during the campaign, and taking the high road. It's not an easy thing for the politically combative Ford to do, but he has proved he can. 

"The prime minister was pretty aggressive in his remarks about the premier right up until election day and the premier never took the bait," says Roth. 

Trolling Andrew Scheer

The people around Andrew Scheer wanted Ford out of sight during the election campaign over fears the premier's unpopularity would drag down the federal Conservative leader in Ontario. Ford kept his part of the bargain, and the Conservatives got badly beaten in this province anyway. Scheer's team is still blaming their loss on Ford, so it's to be expected Ford might be looking for a little payback. 

For Ford, being chummy with Scheer's chief opponent is a subtle yet rather sharp jab at the Conservative leader. You could understand why he might get a little satisfaction from using his new relationship with the PM to troll Scheer.

Ford and Scheer have not met face to face in a year. It's a safe bet you'll see far fewer smiles and handshakes shared between these two Conservatives in the foreseeable future than you'll see between Ford and Trudeau, the newest and probably most unexpected BFFs in Canadian politics. 

About the Author

Mike Crawley

Provincial Affairs Reporter

Mike Crawley is provincial affairs reporter in Ontario for CBC News. He has won awards for his reporting on the eHealth spending scandal and flaws in Ontario's welfare-payment computer system. Before joining the CBC in 2005, Mike filed stories from 19 countries in Africa as a freelance journalist and worked as a newspaper reporter in B.C.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.