Toronto

30 Ontario inspectors laid off despite Doug Ford promise no one will lose jobs

More than 30 inspectors who enforce credentials in the skilled trades have received layoff notices as a result of the Ford government's decision to scrap the Ontario College of Trades.

Ministry of Labour taking over College of Trades enforcement duties, but not hiring existing staff

Terry Dorgan is one of more than 30 provincial inspectors working for the Ontario College of Trades who just received layoff notices, stemming from the move by Premier Doug Ford's government to dissolve the agency that enforces licensing in the skilled trades. (Submitted)

More than 30 inspectors who enforce credentials in the skilled trades have received layoff notices as a result of a decision by Premier Doug Ford's government, CBC News has learned.

The layoff notices went out last week to inspectors in the compliance and enforcement section of the Ontario College of Trades (OCOT), the agency that licenses tradespeople such as electricians, plumbers, auto mechanics and hairstylists. 

The Ford government is dissolving the agency, but all its duties continue. Its inspection role is being shifted to the Ministry of Labour and its work related to apprenticeships goes to a new body called Skilled Trades Ontario.

Despite the continuation of their duties — and even though most OCOT managers and staff get to stay on the provincial payroll with Skilled Trades Ontario — the 30-plus inspectors face being out of work come February.

"Doug Ford said no one would lose their jobs," said Terry Dorgan, an inspector who has been in the job since 2013. "We trusted him." 

During the 2018 election campaign, Ontario PC Leader Doug Ford frequently promised no layoffs of provincial public sector workers. 'Under our government, I'm going to reinforce this, not one single person will lose their job,' said Ford during the televised leader's debate. (Frank Gunn/Canadian Press)

Ford stated frequently during the 2018 election campaign, including during one of televised leaders debates, that no public sector workers would be laid off under his government. 

Then in 2019, Ford and his ministers started shifting their tune, instead saying that no "front-line workers" would lose their jobs.  

Dorgan said he feels "gutted, betrayed and lied to" as a result of the layoff notice. 

"We were promised we wouldn't lose our jobs in 2018, when [Ford] said he was winding down the college and replacing it with something better," Dorgan said in an interview from his home near Peterborough, Ont. 

He doesn't understand why he and the other inspectors weren't simply transferred to become employees in the Ministry of Labour, since the ministry is taking over the enforcement of credentials in Ontario's 23 licensed trades.

Instead, the ministry recently went on a hiring spree of new inspectors that excluded "the people that have the knowledge and skills that have been doing this function for 10 years," said Dorgan.     

"We believe 100 per cent that this is an unfair labour practice. You can't take people's jobs and sell them to someone else," he said. 

The laid-off inspectors are responsible for monitoring that workers have the proper credentials in Ontario's 23 licensed trades, including auto mechanics, hairstylists, plumbers, crane operators and refrigeration technicians. (Talia Ricci / CBC News)

A spokesperson for Monte McNaughton, the minister of Labour, Training and Skills Development, said ministry inspectors must have the skills and knowledge to enforce a wider range of workplace legislation than the OCOT inspectors handled, such as employment standards and occupational health and safety. 

"Our ministry hires the best candidates for the positions we have available," said McNaughton's press secretary Harry Godfrey in a statement that also described the College of Trades as a failure. 

"Instead of being a fair and balanced regulator, they used their power to cater to special interests, which is why our government stepped in to improve the system for everyone," said Godfrey.  

Dorgan said he never heard any complaints about the quality of the inspectors' work during his time at OCOT.

At age 61, he is close to retirement but says other colleagues facing layoff have young families and are in what he called "gut-wrenching" situations.

Monte McNaughton, minister of Labour, Training and Skills Development speaks at the lectern as the government gives an update on the COVID-19 situation in the province at Queen's Park in a June 24, 2020, file photo. (Richard Lautens/Pool-The Canadian Press)

Another inspector provided CBC News with a copy of his layoff notice but asked not to be identified for fear of repercussions. That inspector is also calling on Ford to keep his promise that no one would lose their jobs. 

"Why would he go back on his word? Is that what he wants to be remembered for, as a liar?" said the inspector. "I can't have faith in this government." 

McNaughton told CBC News last summer that enforcement of certification in the skilled trades would continue once OCOT was dissolved. The government's Building Opportunities in the Skilled Trades Act, passed in June, sets in motion the transfer of the inspectors' duties to the Ministry of Labour.  

In a memo obtained by CBC News, McNaughton's deputy minister makes it clear the inspectors are not getting jobs at the Ministry of Labour.

"The ministry has determined that it has the capacity to conduct the compliance and enforcement functions ... from within its current staff complement of 507 inspectors," says the memo dated Aug. 31, addressed to the chief executive and board chairman of OCOT.

"I trust this update will allow your organization to make critical organizational decisions."

Electricians and electrical apprentices must be registered with the Ontario College of Trades to carry out work in the province. The agency is being dissolved effective Jan. 1 and its enforcement role is being taken over by the Ministry of Labour. (Submitted by Andrea Davidson)

OCOT's layoff notices to the inspectors went out on Nov. 17 and the agency explicitly linked the layoffs to government policy. 

"We regret to inform you that you will be laid off from your employment effective close of business on Feb. 17, 2022," says the letter to the inspector who asked not to be identified. 

"We anticipate that this layoff will be permanent as a result of government decisions related to the Compliance and Enforcement function." 

"It just feels like we're being robbed," said the inspector. 

The Ontario Public Service Employees Union (OPSEU) represents the workers being laid off.

The inspectors who spoke to CBC News believe they ought to have successor rights to jobs at the Ministry of Labour since their duties are not being transferred there. They allege this is a violation of labour law and want their union to challenge the layoffs. 

"There have been no forced job losses so far, so I am quite confident that we can work with the government to find them jobs,"  OPSEU president Smokey Thomas said in a phone interview. 

The Ford government has merged or dissolved other provincial agencies since taking power, most notably in the health sector, where agencies such as Cancer Care Ontario were absorbed into the new Ontario Health.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Mike Crawley

Provincial Affairs Reporter

Mike Crawley is provincial affairs reporter in Ontario for CBC News. He has won awards for his reporting on the eHealth spending scandal and flaws in Ontario's welfare-payment computer system. Before joining the CBC in 2005, Mike filed stories from 19 countries in Africa as a freelance journalist and worked as a newspaper reporter in B.C.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now