Toronto·Analysis

Kathleen Wynne and the L word at Queen's Park

What did Monte McNaughton mean when he said "especially Kathleen Wynne"?

The row over sex ed has taken a personal tone in the Legislature

Kathleen Wynne addressed sex-ed opponents inside and outside Queen's Park. (Paul Borkwood/CBC)

A little over two years ago, Kathleen Wynne found herself mostly alone on a stage at Toronto’s Mattamy Centre — the former Maple Leaf Gardens — doing a mic check for what would be, the following the day, the most important speech of her political life.

It was the Liberal leadership race, a race whose back story was all about whether an openly gay woman could become party leader and premier and, at some point, win a general election.

Wynne was determined to address what many called "the elephant in the room." But even some of her staunchest supporters wanted her to steer clear of it.

Sensing the tension in her campaign on that Friday afternoon, Wynne began her practice speech reciting some Shakespeare: "Romeo, Romeo," said Wynne, then paused without finishing the line. "Juliet, Juliet," she said instead, "wherefore art thou?" Laughter filled the almost empty arena.

It helped her campaign workers and underscored Wynne’s belief that the worst thing she could do in her speech was not to be herself.

So she wrote her speech and the following day delivered it, directly addressing the so-called issue of her sexual orientation. 

Her speech electrified the convention. Wynne went on to win — "the easy part" as she would say later, with the big test still to come.

'The issue' was unimportant to voters

It did, in June, 2014, and the Liberals, a party headed for third place, ended in first with a majority. What some referred to as "the issue" of her orientation was unimportant to voters.

Now, fast-forward to the ongoing discussion over the government’s new sex-education curriculum. Suddenly, "the elephant in the room" has returned — printed on homemade picket signs carried outside the Legislature and in coded phrases inside the building.

Conservative leadership candidate Monte McNaughton has led the charge against the new curriculum.

"It’s not the premier of Ontario’s job — especially Kathleen Wynne — to tell parents what is age appropriate [in sex education] for their children," McNaughton told reporters after the introduction of the new curriculum.

But what did he mean by "especially Kathleen Wynne"?

The premier believes she knows, and she was determined to address "the issue" directly, just as she has in the past.

In the Legislature, facing McNaughton’s questions about the OPP investigation into the bribery allegations in the Sudbury byelection, Wynne asked, "What is it exactly that the member [McNaughton] thinks disqualifies me from doing the job that I’m doing?"

Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne fires back at PC leadership hopeful Monte McNaughton over his remarks about the sex ed curriculum. 0:47

But the premier didn’t stop there, and, as even fellow Tory MPPs acknowledge, McNaughton sat uneasily in his Legislature seat.

"Is it that I’m a woman? A mother? Have a master’s of education? Was a school council chair? Was minister of education?" thundered Wynne, staring directly at the PC MPP.

As Wynne spoke, those in the House at the time say, Liberal MPPs heckled McNaughton that Wynne’s personal and professional resume was not "the real reason" he is complaining about the curriculum.

"Ridiculous" was the word McNaughton used to reporters, in strenuously denying Liberal suggestions that homophobia was behind his "especially Kathleen Wynne" comment. 

McNaughton says Wynne is not qualified, in his view, to take on a new sex-education curriculum because she faces "so many scandals" being investigated by the OPP. McNaughton believes schools should be able to opt out of the new curriculum.

But Education Minister Liz Sandals stepped into the debate, making it clear she doesn’t buy the McNaughton explanation.

'Quite homophobic'

"Quite homophobic," said Sandals, adding fuel to the political fire already raging in the House.

"I would assume if he was premier, you could vote to opt out of teaching about evolution too," Sandals told the House,  to the delight and clearly the amusement of Liberal MPPs.

A day later, also in the House, deputy premier Deb Matthews wanted to turn the political screws a little tighter, saying she wanted to congratulate the PC caucus for being the cover story in the latest edition of National Geographic magazine: The War on Science.

But Matthews then added that she thought for the Tories, Evolution Never Happened would be the cover story.

"Climate change does not exist," said Matthews, would be "a wonderful synopsis" of the Ontario PC Party.

Away from the rhetoric, coded phrases and cheap shots, this debate will rage on inside and outside the Legislature as the Liberals move to put the new sex-education curriculum in place.

Put it in place they will, with Kathleen Wynne determined to make it happen no matter how nasty or how personal it gets.

About the Author

Robert Fisher

Provincial Affairs Specialist

A commentator with decades of experience covering Queen's Park, Robert Fisher writes about politics for CBC.ca. He is an award-winning broadcast journalist with more than 30 years of experience in public and private radio and television.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.