Toronto

Ontario NDP and PCs position themselves as labour friendly, each net new endorsements

The Ontario Progressive Conservatives gained the endorsement of another construction workers' union on the campaign trail, while the more traditionally union-friendly NDP secured the backing of the Ontario Public Service Employees Union, which represents 180,000 workers.

Public sector workers throw support behind Horwath after construction union endorses Ford

Progressive Conservative Leader Doug Ford and NDP Leader Andrea Horwath spar during a debate in North Bay, Ont. (Erik White/CBC )

Doug Ford touted his union ties and tried to position his Progressive Conservatives as the labour-friendly option for
voters on Tuesday, as his political rivals accused him of simply paying lip service to workers.

The Tories gained the endorsement of another construction union on the campaign trail, while the more traditionally worker-friendly NDP secured the backing of the Ontario Public Service Employees Union, which represents 180,000 workers.

Ford downplayed his tiffs with public sector workers, whose ire he's drawn over a bill that capped wage increases at one per cent for three years, as he highlighted the endorsement from the International Union of Painters and Allied Trades.

"These are the people that are going to build Ontario, build Toronto, build the whole province. They're out there slugging it out, day in and day out, no matter what type of weather it is. And we couldn't run the province without 'em," Ford said at a morning press conference. "I'll always have their backs, always."

He was speaking at IUPAT's headquarters in Toronto's north end, where he used a stencil and sprayer to paint his campaign slogan "Get It Done" on a blue wall.

Ford, who's seeking re-election in next month's vote, kiboshed attempts to compare his Tories to a previous PC government in Ontario.

In the seven years former premier Mike Harris led the province, he earned a reputation for being anti-union.

Ford said that's not his position, nor was it the position of his late father, who served as a Progressive Conservative MPP under Harris for several years.

"I'm not gonna judge any other party. I'll tell you, our families, be it my dad or my brother Rob or [nephew] Michael, we've supported the hard working women and men in this province, the union members," Ford said. "We always have. I love 'em."

Ford has had conflict with some unions over wage bill

But Ford hasn't always had a friendly relationship with unions.

NDP Leader Andrea Horwath noted Ford has been at loggerheads with OPSEU and other labour groups over legislation passed in 2019 that caps pay raises in the public sector at one per cent or less.

Ford declined Tuesday to commit to repealing Bill 124 — something several unions have been requesting since the legislation passed — saying instead that he'd "treat them fairly" when the three-year raise freeze is over.

Ford has also feuded with teachers' unions, first during lengthy contract negotiations and later over his policies for reopening schools during the pandemic.

Horwath, whose New Democrats have historically been the party most closely aligned with unions, said workers should pay attention to the changes in Ford's tune.

"I don't change my mind about my support for unions and working people," Horwath said at a campaign stop on Tuesday. "We've seen Mr. Ford attack unions, we've seen him attack working people, many, many times. The Conservatives always do that.

"I know who I stand with before elections, during elections and after elections."

Horwath campaigned alongside members of Toronto Education Workers local 4400 in Scarborough on Tuesday. (Chris Young/The Canadian Press)

Later in the day, OPSEU came out in support of Horwath.

"We want a government that builds, not breaks, our public services. On June 2nd, vote to stop privatization," the union
tweeted, along with an image containing a "Vote NDP" logo.

Paid sick days also an issue

The NDP and Liberals have both committed to repealing Bill 124 and introducing 10 paid personal emergency leave days.

As it stands, Ontarians have three paid sick days during the COVID-19 pandemic, but Ford has not committed to extending the policy once the public health crisis has passed.

And while the Tories are spotlighting their labour ties, the NDP have an endorsement from the granddaddy of all unions.

The Ontario Federation of Labour, which acts as an umbrella group for unions in Ontario, released an ad last week throwing its support behind the New Democrats.

Joseph Rose, a professor emeritus at the DeGroote School of Business, said that all fits into broader scripts around labour issues.

For many years, unions were most likely to endorse the NDP, Rose said, though he noted that in the 2000s industrial and public sector unions tended to endorse voting strategically "to ensure the PCs didn't get in power."

"Has organized labour decided to throw all of its weight or the key unions behind the NDP and go away from strategic voting? If so, it probably reflects the belief that if any party can unseat the Tories, it's more likely to be the opposition NDP."

As for the construction unions throwing their weight behind Ford, that's not unheard of either, he said.

"History has been, in most parts of Canada, the construction unions are the more conservative element within the labour
movement," Rose said. "So they're far more conservative than, let's say, a union like Unifor or most of the public sector unions, including OPSEU and teachers."

The union representing high school teachers, at least, has stuck to the strategic voting method. The Ontario Secondary School Teachers' Federation has thus far endorsed individual candidates — some NDP, some Liberal.

Liberal Leader Steven Del Duca positioned himself on Tuesday as a more labour-friendly alternative to Ford.

"The government, in the last few months of a four year mandate, decided to make a series of announcements and put out a series of press releases," he said at a campaign stop. "Press releases don't equal progress. Words are empty if they're not backed up with real action."

Ontario's election is set for June 2.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now