Toronto

Fake honey still pouring into Canada, and local beekeepers are feeling the sting

Fake honey cut with corn syrup, rice, beet and other sugars is still pouring into Canada and onto grocery store shelves. Local producers have been abuzz about the food fraud for years. 

Canadian Food Inspection Agency found loads of fake honey cut with cheap syrup imported as 'pure honey'

In an effort to crack down on food fraud, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency zeroed in on honey imports and found about 22 per cent of samples were 'adulterated' with cheaper sugars like rice and sugar cane syrup. (Justin Newsom/CBC)

Fake honey cut with corn syrup, rice, beet and other sugars is still pouring into Canada and onto grocery store shelves. 

The producers, who pride themselves on turning out the real thing, have been abuzz about the food fraud for years. They say they are feeling the sting and consumers should be aware.

Since June 2018, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) has been zeroing in on fake honey, using "targeted surveillance." 

The federal agency collected 240 samples across Canada from honey importers, brokers, distributors, blenders, processing facilities and grocery aisles. 

The CFIA found 78 per cent of the 240 samples collected from across the country were authentic honey, including 100 per cent of Canadian honey sampled. The remaining samples, about 22 per cent, had added sugars present. (Justin Newsom/CBC)

While all the domestic samples proved to be authentic, more than a fifth of imported honey from a number of countries — including Greece, China, India, Pakistan and Vietnam — failed tests at the CFIA lab in Ottawa. 

"Twenty-two per cent [of the samples] were found to contain foreign sugars such as corn syrup, rice syrup and cane sugar syrup," Jodi White, a national manager in CFIA's consumer protection and market fairness division, told CBC Toronto.  

The only variant that should be present in pure honey is the flower source from which the bees collect their nectar. (James Morrison-Collalto/CBC)

The CFIA has been testing for adulterated honey for more than two decades, but this year's inspection targeted some suppliers that had been flagged in other jurisdictions for issues such as unusual trading patterns. 

"It's based on targeted sampling," White said. "It's not necessarily indicative of the overall market." 

The inspection has stopped 12,800 kilograms of adulterated honey, valued at around $77,000, from entering the Canadian market. 

Beekeepers can't compete

Chris Hiemstra, a third-generation beekeeper, is among honey producers who say they're feeling the sting from cheaper, adulterated imports.

He knew he had to expand the family business if he wanted to keep his honey farm in Aylmer, Ont. 

"We're trying to support the family and selling honey wholesale by the barrel on the world market was really difficult and unsustainable," he said. "It was for survival." 

Chris Hiemstra, owner of Clovermead Honey Farm in Aylmer, Ont., says honey fraud is devastating for businesses like his as it undercuts the price at which legitimate producers sell their honey. (James Morrison-Collalto/CBC)

Hiemstra has spent 20 years building his farm, Clovermead, into a larger, agri-tourism adventure farm where locals and visitors pay to tour the property. Patrons take wagon rides, visit farm animals and learn about, taste and buy honey produced by the farm's 24 million bees. 

The business is doing well thanks to the tourism, as well as revenue from honey sales online, but Hiemstra worries about fellow honey wholesalers across Canada trying to make ends meet.

"They're big producers and they need a fair price for their honey. Otherwise, they cannot pay their employees and support their families. Those are the people that are impacted. 

"Someone can sell sugar for 20 cents a pound and say it's honey against someone that needs $2 a pound to make a living. That [price] gap is huge and there's no way you can compete against that." 

Looking for real honey? Look local (and for bee stings)

Beekeepers at Clovermead say these days the only way consumers can be absolutely sure the honey they buy is 100 per cent pure is going straight to the source and shopping locally. (James Morrison-Collalto/CBC)

Honey tends to change hands a lot on its way to store shelves, and it can be hard to know at what point the product gets diluted.

"It is a very complex supply chain, and this is something we're looking at," White said, speaking inside the CFIA lab.

"[We're looking at] where the vulnerabilities are in the supply chain and where is adulteration or other misrepresentation being introduced." 

Beekeeper Peter Awram demonstrates an easy way to tell which honey products are more diluted when you're at the store. 0:48

Hiemstra said you can be sure it's not the beekeeper. 

"At the beginning, the beekeeper works with bees, spinning the honey out of the frames, putting it into either jars or into a barrel," he said in Clovermead's honey shop. 

"Someone after that is taking it and putting it in big vats, and blending it and mixing it. That's not the beekeeper; it's something further down the line," he said, suggesting some unprofessional "professional" food handlers may be to blame.  

Hiemstra has some advice for consumers who want to be sure they're getting the real stuff. 

First, "when it's really cheap, you're probably getting what you're paying for," he said.

"I would say they should try to find somebody that's got their name on a bottle." 

As for vetting beekeepers?

"Look at them. See if they've got dirt on their hands and they've got swollen cheeks from bee stings." 

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.