Toronto·Analysis

Doug Ford's PCs conclude that voters don't want deficit-slashing above all else

Ontario Premier Doug Ford and his Progressive Conservatives have done their political math and reached some conclusions about the voters who gave them a majority government.

What really matters is whether Ontarians see cuts in key services and feel the effects of austerity

Finance Minister Vic Fedeli gets the thumbs-up from Premier Doug Ford after presenting the 2019 budget at the Ontario Legislature in Toronto on Thursday, April 11, 2019. (Frank Gunn/The Canadian Press)

Ontario Premier Doug Ford and his Progressive Conservatives have done their political math and reached some conclusions about the voters who gave them a majority government. 

The PCs have realized Ontarians don't want them to slash the deficit at all costs. 

Still, there's no doubt the budget tabled Thursday by Finance Minister Vic Fedeli will bring some significant pain to various parts of the public sector along the budget's five-year path back to balance.

The budget sketches out a plan to significantly ratchet back the growth in spending in the two biggest ministries, health and education.

  • Health spending would increase by an annual average of just 1.6 per cent until 2021-22. In the previous three years, health spending rose an average of 4.2 per cent a year. 
  • Education spending would increase by an annual average of just 1.2 per cent until 2021-22. In the previous three years, it rose 3.8 per cent a year, on average. 
The PC budget indicates that growing enrolment will eat up the bulk of the forecast 1.2 per cent annual spending increase in education. (Iam Anupong/Shutterstock)

The PCs are freezing or cutting spending in just about every other ministry. Across government, total program spending would go up an average of 0.8 per cent annually in the next three years. Factor in inflation and population growth, and that means real per capita spending will be cut.

Those are the top-line numbers, giving an overall message that says "austerity." What will really matter — both politically for Ford and practically for people — is whether Ontarians feel the effects of that austerity. Will it bring perceptible cuts to public services?

The fact that we don't yet know the answer to that question is one of the clever political moves in Fedeli's budget. It's hard for anyone to figure out by reading the entire 343-page budget exactly what specific services will be cut. When someone says, "The growth in health care spending is slowing," there is no big public outcry. If someone can say, "This hospital is going to close!" the outcry begins.   

We do know that legal aid funding is dropping, primarily hurting refugee claimants (who don't vote). Colleges and universities will lose some funding if they don't meet unspecified "performance indicators," eventually. The budget says the government "has already reduced the size of the Ontario Public Service by 3.5 per cent through voluntary attrition alone."

There will be an impact, but that impact won't be immediately apparent.

The federal Liberals spent time Friday attacking the Ontario PC government's first budget. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is seen meeting with parents of students at a Toronto school. (Chris Young/The Canadian Press)

This matters for federal politics, in this election year. The cuts won't likely be felt quickly enough to help Justin Trudeau and his Liberals. They were hoping the Ford budget would be a wrecking ball, so this fall they could use it to warn voters in Ontario and across the country: "See what happens when you elect Conservatives?" They tried this tactic on Friday.

Before budget day, pollsters told me that most Ontarians, including many who voted for Ford, don't actually care much about the deficit right now. Their polling suggests that people want key public services preserved far more than they want a "cut-the-deficit-above-all-else" approach.

Ford's political advisers have seen this polling, too. They tell me that PC supporters want to see the government on track to a balanced budget, but don't mind whether it happens before the next election or after. They want to see bureaucratic waste eliminated, but don't want schools closed or patients on stretchers in hospital hallways. 

Yet a huge question remains: Is there any way the PCs can meet their targets for restraining spending without affecting public services?  

With Ontario's hospitals getting less than half the increase they told the government they needed, and with the population growing and aging, it's hard to see how the health system will be able to keep up with the demands on it. 

Health spending in Ontario has risen at an annual average of 4.2 per cent over the past three years. Ford's PCs want to ratchet that back to just 1.6 per cent.

The budget projects saving more than $1 billion annually in health by 2021-22, "with no impact on patient care." The PCs say they can achieve this by saving: 

  • $350 million by creating the Ontario Health super-agency
  • $250 million by "optimizing health-care workforce productivity," such as reducing overtime and improving scheduling
  • $200 million by cutting the number of public health units 
  • $140 million by changing how the government pays pharmacy fees
  • $100 million by reducing administration costs

Let's check back in a couple of years to see if they actually managed to do this.

The budget indicates that growing enrolment will eat up the bulk of the forecast 1.2 per cent annual spending increase in education. That means the PCs are banking on getting all the teachers' unions in Ontario (whose contracts all expire this summer) to accept wage freezes, or have them imposed. Don't expect that to happen without a peep. 

The budget is finally disproving Ford's repeated promises on the campaign trail that "no one will lose their job" under his government. It emerged Friday that 52 people lost their jobs in the closure of the offices of the children's advocate and French-language watchdog. It's hard to see how the PCs' austerity plan won't ultimately bring more public-sector job losses. 

About the Author

Mike Crawley

Provincial Affairs Reporter

Mike Crawley is provincial affairs reporter in Ontario for CBC News. He has won awards for his reporting on the eHealth spending scandal and flaws in Ontario's welfare-payment computer system. Before joining the CBC in 2005, Mike filed stories from 19 countries in Africa as a freelance journalist and worked as a newspaper reporter in B.C.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.