Top epidemiologist resigns from Ontario's COVID-19 science table, alleges withholding of 'grim' projections
Doctor says fall modelling not being shared in 'transparent manner with the public'
One of Ontario's most vocal epidemiologists has resigned from the province's COVID-19 Science Advisory Table, alleging the group has delayed publication of its pandemic projections for the fall due to political interference — a charge the table has denied.
Dr. David Fisman, a professor of epidemiology at the University of Toronto's Dalla Lana School of Public Health, announced on Twitter on Monday morning that he would step down from the table, posting a letter of resignation he sent to table co-chair Dr. Adalsteinn Brown.
Fisman said that while he had "mixed emotions" about resigning, he had been "repeatedly dissenting publicly from table guidance," adding that Ontario "needs a public health system that is arm's length from politics."
"I find myself increasingly uncomfortable with the degree to which political considerations appear to be driving outputs from the tables, or at least the degree to which these outputs are shared in a transparent manner with the public," he wrote.
It is with mixed emotions that I have decided to resign from Ontario’s science and modeling tables. I wish every success to the colleagues who remain on these tables. Ontario needs a public health system that is arm’s length from politics. <a href="https://t.co/Yq20W1Omog">pic.twitter.com/Yq20W1Omog</a>—@DFisman
"I do not wish to remain in this uncomfortable position, where I must choose between placid relations with colleagues on the one hand, and the necessity of speaking the truth during a public health crisis on the other."
The letter did not include any specifics about the alleged political considerations.
Called for earlier release of modelling
Fisman has already been removed from the table's list of members on its website.
His resignation comes two days after he tweeted that the science table had "important modelling work that projects a grim fall" and implied its publication had been intentionally delayed.
"I don't understand why they're not releasing that. It's important for people to understand what lies ahead, and what the stakes are," he wrote.
If <a href="https://twitter.com/COVIDSciOntario?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@COVIDSciOntario</a> is arm’s length from the government it should release its modeling.<br><br>If it’s not arm’s length from the government we should have that conversation. <a href="https://t.co/eRHEnYu8iz">https://t.co/eRHEnYu8iz</a>—@DFisman
The table has strongly refuted that it is purposefully withholding projections for the fall. In a series of tweets from its official account, it said, "There appear to be some rumours that the Science Advisory Table is withholding a consensus model of COVID-19 in the fall. To be absolutely clear, that is not true."
The table's statement went on to say that it was currently "working to understand how COVID-19 may affect Ontario in coming months," which involves integrating and reviewing "many models done by many teams" until there is a "reasonable, scientific consensus."
There appear to be some rumours that the Science Advisory Table is withholding a consensus model of COVID-19 in the Fall. To be absolutely clear, that is not true. Pls read thread 1/4—@COVIDSciOntario
"Anything less is not rigorous science, and risks either underestimating or overestimating the real dangers we may face. A lot of mathematical and scientific work goes into generating a modelling consensus that Ontarians can count on; we move quickly, but not prematurely."
Data delay due to summer break, director says
Dr. Peter Juni, the table's scientific director, echoed this statement.
"I've been with this table now in my role as scientific director for 14 months, and I haven't always been as diplomatic as others in the province. And I've never experienced any political pressure myself, never during these 14 months. We do not hold back any modelling here for any political considerations."
Juni said the delay in issuing the latest round of modelling was due to table members being on a summer break after "18 months of intense work."
"What you will see relatively closely in the future is the regular projections, as we have seen them in the past," he told CBC's As It Happens.
While Juni would not say exactly when the modelling would be released, he said it would be "very soon."
However, he said this would "absolutely not" contain anything that would impact the province's back-to-school plan.
"Our exponential growth is less intense than only a week ago, which is at least going in the right direction," he said. "Remember, it's a volunteer table, and they can only do so much."
Juni said he isn't aware of anyone else on the table who shares Fisman's concerns.
Horwath: 'We're in a very bad spot'
In the hours following Fisman's announcement, NDP Leader Andrea Horwath spoke publicly about his departure from the table, saying that "any failure here is squarely on [Premier] Doug Ford."
"He hasn't listened, as we all know, to the science table," she said. "He has not acted on their advice, and there have been times when he has even misrepresented what the science table was advising. We're in a very bad spot right now, as everybody knows. It's two weeks before school comes back, and parents are pretty upset and pretty worried."
Horwath said parents deserve the "transparency and straightforward information" that updated COVID-19 modelling could provide.
"There's no doubt that the modelling is important, but if you have a government that ignores it anyway, then its value is diminished."
She said physicians working on the science table do so on a voluntary basis, while maintaining their day jobs, and were putting in "tireless amounts of work."
"They're working day and night to try and help us out, and they don't have a leader in their premier — quite the opposite."
Green Party of Ontario Leader Mike Schreiner also released a statement, calling for Ford to "immediately address" Fisman's allegations.
"The science table has been a crucial partner in navigating the COVID-19 public health crisis. So when a member seemingly resigns in protest, it is a cause for concern. And it needs to be clarified for the people of Ontario," he said.
Prior data released in June
The last modelling data from the COVID-19 Science Advisory Table was released to the public on June 10. The projections indicated that a fourth wave caused by the delta variant was unlikely, as Ontario's positive COVID-19 cases continued to fall "sharply."
Brown, the science table's co-chair, said at the time that it appeared the province had "turned a corner" in its progress against the pandemic and that Ontarians could look forward to "a much better summer."
However, the modelling's key findings did outline that the delta variant was likely to be the dominant form of virus over the summer and "may be more dangerous" than variants that drove previous waves of the pandemic.
Fisman has been a vocal critic of the Ford government and many of its senior public health officials, and he was an early advocate of the hypothesis that the virus is airborne and primarily transmitted through aerosols.
In response to questions from CBC on Fisman's allegations, and what the government was doing to prepare for fall, provincial spokesperson Alexandra Hilkene said that "vaccines are our ticket out of the pandemic."
As well as focusing on inoculating the public, Hilkene said the province had taken "every measure necessary to enable the province to quickly identify, prevent, and respond to surges and waves of the virus."
"Our government has never hesitated to take action to protect the health and safety of Ontarians and in consultation with the Chief Medical Officer of Health we will continue to monitor key public health indicators and be prepared to respond to any scenario."
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?