Toronto

Council voted to buy, move controversial Mimico concrete plant a year ago — but deal's still not done

Nearly a year ago, council voted to buy and potentially relocate a controversial Mimico concrete plant — but the deal still isn't finalized, vexing both residents and the plant's owners.

Residents wanting plant relocated have raised concerns about mess, truck traffic for years

Residents near the concrete plant have complained about truck traffic and excessive noise for more than a decade. (CBC)

Nearly a year ago, council voted to buy and potentially relocate a controversial Mimico concrete plant — but the deal still isn't finalized, vexing both residents and the plant's owners.

For more than a decade, community members near the ML Ready Mix plant at 29 Judson St. have raised concerns about truck traffic, excessive noise, and messy conditions around the site.

Council voted to use $5 million in city funds to buy the property in July 2018, with the goal of moving the operations to the Port Lands.

At the time, the area's councillor, Mark Grimes, told CBC Toronto he was hoping to "relocate ML out of our community as soon as possible" by getting the necessary approvals in place.

But there still hasn't been a sale.

"We don't see any hope of this [company] moving," lamented Dan Irwin, a community member who has been leading the charge to have ML Ready Mix shut down.

'It should never have been there'

A wall around the site is currently collapsing and dirty water is seeping out into the residential neighbourhood, he said.

Neighbours have previously complained about high levels of truck traffic as well, counting close to 400 trucks coming and going each day.

In 2016, the company was also fined $160,000 by the province for various Environmental Protection Act violations and "discharging a contaminant."

Heather Marshall, campaigns director for the Toronto Environmental Alliance, said these types of sites often lead to air quality and water pollution concerns.

She agreed moving the Judson Street site elsewhere is the right call. "I don't think they should be close to residential areas at all," she said.

"This place is incompatible," Irwin echoed. "It should never have been there."

Residents have been complaining about a Mimico concrete plant for years, including concerns over dirty water flowing into the surrounding neighbourhood. (Supplied by Dan Irwin)

Speaking by phone to CBC Toronto, a spokesperson for the plant's family-owned parent company said the operation is "not aware" of any present-day concerns from the community.

"We are compliant with all the legislation," said Rene Silva, operations manager for ML Group.

The company is also trying to expedite the council-backed sale, he said, with negotiations still ongoing.

"We are actively, as we always have been, looking for alternative sites, and we are exercising all of our efforts to come to a fair agreement between ourselves and the city," Silva continued.

Company wants sale finalized 'sooner than later'

"I wish it was sooner than later ... unfortunately, I'm at the mercy of the system itself; the bureaucracy."

Grimes did not respond to CBC Toronto's request for comment.

City spokesperson Bruce Hawkins, however, said the city is working diligently to finalize the transaction in the "near future" and move the plant's operations to 545 Commissioners St. in the Port Lands.

It's been a "long and complex" negotiation process, he added, and the city now hopes buying the site will allow 29 Judson St. to be repurposed down the line and reduce the current issues faced by community members.

The area's MPP, Christine Hogarth, said her office has only heard one or two concerns from residents about the plant and its trucks.

"However, this is an important issue for the community that needs to be solved — the sooner, the better," she said in a statement, adding she fully supports the city moving the plant to a non-residential area.

But with the months ticking by, Irwin said it's concerning that council voted to spend millions to purchase the site with no results to show for it yet.

"We've been trying to get this site moved since 2007," he said.

About the Author

Lauren Pelley

City Hall reporter

Lauren Pelley is a CBC reporter in Toronto covering city hall and municipal affairs. Contact her at: lauren.pelley@cbc.ca

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.