Toronto·SAFER STREETS

Bike lanes alongside train tracks could beef up city's cycling network, architects say

Using the extra space around existing railway corridors to build lanes for cyclists could help the city create a new, conflict-free cycling network, two architects say. But Metrolinx says it's not that simple.

Proposal could add 100 km of lanes, team says, but Metrolinx says it's not that simple

A pair of Toronto architects says using the extra space around existing railway corridors to build lanes for cyclists could help the city create a new, conflict-free cycling network, as shown in this design. But Metrolinx says it's not that simple. (Supplied by Smart Density)

Want more bike lanes? Look to Toronto's train tracks.

That's the crux of a new proposal from a local pair of architects, who say using the extra space around existing railway corridors to build lanes for cyclists could help the city create a new, conflict-free cycling network.

"With this idea, we get over 100 kilometres of bike lanes across the city," says architect and urban designer Naama Blonder from the firm Smart Density, who developed the plan with her colleague Misha Bereznyak.

"We can serve not only downtown and the core of the city, but areas that don't enjoy this infrastructure."

The proposal is one of the seven 2019 projects selected for the first-ever SHIFT Infrastructure/Architecture Challenge from the Ontario Association of Architects.

The gist? Many rail corridors have extra space running alongside them. Blonder says those areas could provide room for low-cost, separated bike lanes — or cycling "highways" — stretching beyond the city's core and away from traffic.

In a video promoting the idea, her team notes the "generous width" alongside rail tracks currently used by provincial transportation agency Metrolinx.

Dubbing the concept "GO Bikes," Blonder believes it's something the agency could actually explore.

"Once you eliminate conflict, you get not only a very safe bike lane, but a fast one," she says.

'Numerous safety concerns,' Metrolinx says

But Metrolinx says it's easier said than done.

According to a statement from spokesperson Matt Llewellyn, the proposal "seems to present numerous safety concerns."

The agency also only owns 80 per cent of the rail network, he continued. "On the corridors we do own and control, it's important we set aside land throughout the Greater Golden Horseshoe, for the needs of our GO Expansion project."

Architect and urban designer Naama Blonder developed the 'GO Bikes' proposal, which outlines the potential benefits of building bike lanes beside Toronto train tracks. (Derek Hooper/CBC News)

'Key arterials' missing in the city

Still, cycling advocates say this kind of innovation needs to be embraced — with some pointing to the success of the West Toronto Railpath, a two-kilometre stretch of pedestrian and cyclist-friendly trails adjacent to a north-south line where GO and UP Express trains are running.

Nancy Smith Lea, a road safety advocate and director of the Centre for Active Transportation, says both that project and the High Line in New York City — a public park built on an elevated freight line — are instances where community-driven ideas eventually became reality.

"If we just shut these ideas down from the beginning, we're never going to achieve them," she says.

Coun. Joe Cressy, an outspoken advocate of bike lanes, agrees but says when it comes to innovation, beefing up the city's core network needs to be a higher priority.

"Do we need more bike lanes? Hell, yes. Where should they be built? They should be built as part of a grid," he says.

Commuters travelling from home to work to errands and back again need a road-like system to get around the city, Cressy explains.

And so far, even that's lacking, with only six per cent of the network in the city's 10-year cycling plan built over the first three years. "Key arterials" are missing, Cressy says, including extending the Bloor Street bike lanes west and filling in cycling gaps on the Danforth.

"You can't have bike lanes to nowhere," he adds.

Even so, Blonder says her team's concept could round out the system — if there was ever a willingness to explore it.

"It's extremely practical ... and it's so simple," Blonder says.

This story is part of CBC Toronto's new road safety series, Safer Streets. Whether you drive, bike, or walk, we want to hear your stories about sharing the road. What areas concern you? How do you want to make our streets safer? Send us an email: SaferStreetsToronto@cbc.ca

About the Author

Lauren Pelley

City Hall reporter

Lauren Pelley is a CBC reporter in Toronto covering city hall and municipal affairs. Contact her at: lauren.pelley@cbc.ca

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.