Toronto murder suspect arrested in Aruba may be extradited to Canada, 3 other suspects also in custody

The Toronto man police accused of killing another man outside a Queen Street bar in early April may be extradited back to Canada, after a dramatic arrest in Aruba on May 3.

Michael Teddy Gibson, wanted for murder in Toronto and Aruba, was arrested May 3 on the island

Michael Teddy Gibson was arrested in a dramatic takedown in Aruba on May 3, as seen in this photo taken by local news media. (24ORA.COM)

The Toronto man police accuse of killing another man outside a Queen Street bar may be extradited back to Canada, after a dramatic arrest in Aruba on May 3.

Michael Teddy Gibson became the subject of a Canada-wide manhunt after the shooting death of Julian Weekes on April 2, 2016, outside Fuse Bar near Queen and Parliament. The 27-year-old was attending a memorial that night for his friend Ceyon Carrington, who himself had been shot and killed a month earlier in Leslieville.

Michael Teddy Gibson is wanted for murder in Aruba and in Canada. He's seen here after being arrested by Aruban police. (24ORA.COM)

According to a local news station in Aruba,, Gibson was arrested in a dramatic takedown after a car accident that followed a police chase.

The prosecutor's office on the small island said Gibson falsely identified himself to officers when he was arrested.

Canadian authorities have asked Aruban officials to extradite Michael Teddy Gibson, suspected of the murder of Julian Weekes in Toronto. Gibson is also now suspected of the murder of a Toronto man in Aruba. (Toronto Police Service)

Since then, "Aruba received a petition for his extradition in connection with a criminal case against him in Canada," said Ann Angela, a spokesperson for the prosecutor.

However, the Aruban investigation will "go before any procedure started up by Canadian authorities," said Angela. She said there is a 60-day period to formalize the extradition. 

A spokesperson for the Department of Justice Canada would not confirm that an extradition process had been initiated, only that "extradition requests are confidential state-to-state communications" and they "cannot comment on the potential existence" of a request.

Gisbon stands accused in the killing of a 25-year-old Toronto man in Aruba, Thuy Hoang Nguyen Quach. Both Quach and Gibson come from Regent Park in Toronto and the pair knew one another, a source in the community told CBC Toronto, although the nature of their relationship is unclear.

Thuy Hoang Nguyen Quach was killed in Aruba. His family has set up a GoFundMe page, where they say their "last wish is for everyone to be able to say their last 'goodbyes' here with us in Canada." (GoFundMe)

3 more Canadians arrested

Three more Canadian men were also arrested and are currently in custody, according to Angela.

They were to be "led before the judge of instruction" on Thursday and have been remanded in custody until May 18 — their next court appearance. It is unclear where in Canada they are from or what they are charged with.

A previous version of this story stated that four more people were in Aruban custody, in addition to Michael Teddy Gibson. The prosecutor's office has since clarified that they have four people in custody, including Gibson.

From Toronto to Aruba

Last month, homicide investigators reiterated their plea for information leading to Gibson's arrest, saying there was a good chance he'd fled the country.

But how Gibson managed to leave Canada and enter Aruba while the subject of a warrant by the RCMP is not clear.

Julian Weekes was killed on April 2, 2016 outside Fuse Bar, near Queen and Parliament. Police allege Michael Teddy Gibson is the shooter. (Toronto Police Service)

"When an individual is leaving Canada by air, the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) does not play a role in their exit," the agency told CBC Toronto.

That's unlike when someone leaves by land — Canada and the United States exchange information on "third country" nationals (non U.S. or Canadian citizens), Canadian permanent residents who aren't U.S. citizens, and U.S. permanent residents who aren't Canadian citizens.

No information is shared on Canadian citizens, the CBSA said. But that could soon change.

Last June, Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale tabled Bill C-21, proposing legislation that would allow Canada to know when and where someone both enters and leaves the country. 

With files from Shanifa Nasser