Toronto·CBC Investigates

2 artists say former Toronto gallery owner sold their paintings and never paid them

Two artists, one from Toronto and another from Montreal, say a former gallery owner sold their paintings without telling them, and never paid them their cut of the sale.

Engine Gallery owner says painting sales are 'old news and old business'

David Goldberg's painting The Bather, left, was sold by Steven Schwartz who the artist says never paid him. Sebastien Worsnip says the same thing happened to him with one of his paintings, right. (David Goldberg/Sebastien Worsnip)

A Toronto artist is hoping to recover one of a pair of paintings he gave to a former gallery owner on consignment after he says the gallerist sold the other one without telling him, and never paid him his cut.

David Goldberg met Steven Schwartz more than a decade ago, when he says Schwartz's Engine Gallery was "fairly recognized" in the city's art scene "on the Queen Street strip," a central Toronto corridor of cultural institutions and shops.

"He seemed like a reasonable person," Goldberg told CBC News. "He was involved in the arts community. He was selling art through his gallery."

"I hadn't heard anything from other artists complaining — until my own situation."

A couple of months ago the 50-year-old painter discovered that Schwartz sold his painting The Bather for $7,250 in late 2017 — several years after he gave the gallery owner the work and another painting, Danielle, on consignment.

Goldberg says Schwartz has made no effort to pay him his share of the sale and said he has no idea what happened to his other painting.

The former gallery owner told CBC News he "went bankrupt," but records show that proceeding started four years before Schwartz allegedly sold Goldberg's painting.

"Artists just leave things with me to take care of, I try contacting them, they don't pick things up," said Schwartz.

Schwartz moved his art gallery from Toronto to Port Hope, Ont., without telling artists like Goldberg and Worsnip, whose work he was showing. (Ted Amsden/Port Hope Now)

Goldberg said, "I couldn't get in contact with him. I emailed him, I phoned him, I couldn't get a message" about his efforts to contact Schwartz over the years. "I sort of gave up a bit, that was sort of silly, but I'm busy."

By the time Goldberg tracked Schwartz down the Engine Gallery had moved twice. First to Toronto's Distillery District, an arts and culture hub on the edge of downtown, and then about 100 kilometres east of the city to Port Hope, Ont. — where a fan of Goldberg's work told him they'd seen The Bather on sale for $10,000.

Eventually Goldberg went to see for himself, but Schwartz's gallery had closed. Another gallery owner in town remembered Goldberg's painting, though. Robert Polutnik had shown the work, along with the art of about half a dozen other artists Schwartz had at his own gallery in the summer of 2017.  

"We said, 'Sure, we'll display them as long as it's OK with your artists,'" said Polutnik, former owner of the Art Emporium By the River, which has since closed as well.

Other artists look for their paintings

But then Polutnik says he "ran into issues" when artists came looking for work they said Schwartz had.

As a result, within a couple months Polutnik says he told Schwartz to come get all the artwork because he was "tired of being the middleman," between Schwartz and his artists.

"I had no idea he wasn't paying people," Polutnik told CBC News.

Then in November 2017 a client came back to the Art Emporium By the River looking to buy Goldberg's painting, after seeing it on display that summer.

Goldberg has no idea what happened to his painting Danielle, since he says he's been unable to get in contact with Schwartz for years. (David Goldberg)

Polutnik contacted Schwartz to arrange the sale, but says when Schwartz brought in the painting the buyer noticed it was damaged. As a result, Polutnik says Schwartz agreed to reduce the price to $7,250. Polutnik got a $1,250 finder's fee and says he paid Schwartz $6,000 in cash.

"We paid the person that we got the painting from, who was representing the artist," said Polutnik. "What happened from that point, we had no control."

What [Schwartz's] done is just like the worst thing you can do to artists.— David Goldberg, painter

Goldberg says he hasn't heard from Schwartz since he sold his painting, and "what he's done is just like the worst thing you can do to artists."

The painter knows he's "out the money," especially since he only had a verbal consignment agreement with Schwartz and didn't have a contract for the 50 per cent or $3,000 he says he's owed.

"I've done tons of shows where I've never signed," said Goldberg. "I have the sense that most people are fairly honourable and I guess now I don't think that anymore."

Goldberg says Schwartz has made no effort to pay him his share of the sale for The Bather and he has no idea what happened to his other painting. (Chris Glover/CBC)

But Goldberg doesn't believe a consignment contract would have made a difference in his dealings with Schwartz — because another painter who had a contract with the former gallery owner is out a couple thousand dollars as well.

Montreal artist says he's out $2,000

Sebastien Worsnip gave Schwartz two of his paintings under a consignment contract in January 2010, when Schwartz's gallery was in the Distillery District. And like Goldberg, he's had trouble getting in touch with Schwartz since then.

Worsnip gave Schwartz two of his paintings under a consignment contract in January 2010, when Schwartz's gallery was in Toronto's Distillery District. (Sebastien Worsnip)

"I think he recognized my phone number and wouldn't call me," the Montreal artist told CBC News. "How I did end up reaching him is that my daughter lives in Toronto and she called him from a Toronto number and then he picked up right away."

After a lot of back-and-forth, his daughter drove to Port Hope to get her dad's paintings from Schwartz, only to find one of them had been sold. The other she brought home to Toronto.

Worsnip says Schwartz promised to send an e-transfer for the sold painting, but the $2,000 he says he was owed never came.

Worsnip got back one of the two paintings he gave Schwartz, but he doesn't know when Schwartz sold the other one. (CBC)

"I kind of describe it as being robbed very slowly," said Worsnip. "It's not like being mugged where it's immediate and you feel something. It's just kind of like this really creepy thing that somebody's done and you can't do much about it."   

'I went bankrupt,' says Schwartz

In a brief phone call last week, Schwartz said he "closed the business a long time ago and I went bankrupt."

CBC News found a bankruptcy record matching the former gallery owner's name and birth date.

The proceeding started in November 2013, just under a year before a "Coming soon" sign appeared in the window of Schwartz's gallery in Port Hope, and four years before Schwartz allegedly sold Goldberg's painting.

"This is old news and old business," said Schwartz.

"You know, there's a lot of things that go on, but I'll speak to them directly."

So far, neither artist has heard from Schwartz.

About the Author

Nicole Brockbank

Reporter, CBC Toronto

Nicole Brockbank is a reporter for CBC Toronto's Enterprise Unit. Fuelled by coffee, she digs up, researches and writes original investigative and feature stories. nicole.brockbank@cbc.ca

With files from Chris Glover

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.