Thunder Bay

How a Thunder Bay cellphone drive launched a movement to make digital access a human right

What started off as a cellphone drive for people living on low incomes in Thunder Bay, Ont., has quickly grown into a provincial coalition that is calling on the federal and provincial governments to recognize digital access as a human right.

The coalition is concerned about the growing digital divide in Canada

A growing coalition of agencies in Ontario are calling on all levels of government to recognize digital access as a basic human right. (Martin Mejia/The Associated Press)

What started off as a cellphone drive for people with limited income in Thunder Bay, Ont., has quickly grown into a provincial coalition that is calling on the federal and provincial governments to recognize digital access as a human right.

When the pandemic first took hold in Canada, restrictions meant businesses, social service agencies and public places were forced to close.

Most of society moved forward, with people working virtually from home and doctor's appointments taking place over the phone or video chat. 

But a group of agencies in Thunder Bay, Ont., stayed focused on the people being left behind as they saw the digital divide grew; People living on low incomes, in precarious housing or homeless who lost their ability to connect when facilities like libraries and resource centres with free internet and computer access were forced to shut their doors.

Tracey MacKinnon, an anti-poverty activist in Thunder Bay, Ont., says a cellphone can be a lifeline for many at-risk populations. (Submitted by: Tracey MacKinnon)

Tracey MacKinnon, an anti-poverty activist with experience living homeless and without regular digital access, described that connection as "a lifeline."

"For someone who is homeless, or someone who's trying to get their life back together, getting out of rehab ... that access to technology to be able to access information, that's vital. That's survival," MacKinnon said.

Angie Lynch, the lead coordinator for the newly-formed Championing Access to Technology for Individuals Living in Poverty coalition, said access to technology became essential during the pandemic.

"If they needed to access food security, if they needed to access a doctor, mental health appointments, harm reduction ... for all that, you needed a phone. And if you didn't have a phone, you were out of luck."

Cellphone drive takes shape

Recognizing the immediate need to get vulnerable populations access to technology, the Breaking Down Barriers Working Group with the NorWest Community Health Centres jumped into action with a goal of getting 500 phones in peoples' hands. 

Agencies asked the public to donate old cellphones, it partnered up with regional telecommunications provider TbayTel to pay for voice and data plans until June, and more than 100 phones were distributed within a few days to people in need.

It was a start, but not enough.

With some free time on her hands due to the pandemic, Lynch reached out to her network across the province about the issue of digital access.

Angie Lynch, of the Kinna-aweya Legal Clinic, is the lead coordinator of the Championing Access to Technology for Individuals Living in Poverty coalition. (Amy Hadley/CBC)

When the Centre for Mental Health and Addiction published a profile of the coalition's initiative, Lynch said she had agencies from all over Ontario contacting her to talk about how they could support people in their own cities and regions.

On May 31, the coalition sent a letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Ontario Premier Doug Ford and a number of other federal and provincial cabinet ministers.

The letter, signed by almost 100 agencies working with vulnerable populations from all over Ontario, outlined how the ability of the agencies to provide services had changed because of the pandemic, making digital access "an absolute requirement for the people we serve."

Coalition not waiting for government to act

According to Lynch, neither level of government has responded — yet, but the lack of response hasn't stopped the coalition's members from pushing forward however they can.

The Thunder Bay District Social Services Administrative Board (TBDSSAB) has picked up the tab to pay for the phone plans already distributed in the city until the end of September.

Bill Bradica, chief administrative officer of the TBDSSAB, said his board also submitted a proposal for a delegation at the upcoming virtual Association of Municipalities of Ontario conference in August to "advocate to the province to look at setting up a program to assist vulnerable individuals with accessing a program that would provide devices and low-cost plans that they'd be able to participate in."

Bradica added that there are some low-cost internet and mobile plans available through the federal government's Connecting Families program and through various telecommunications companies in the province, but they aren't widely available to all people with low incomes.

While many agencies are concerned about individuals not being able to reach out and connect with services or support programs, Anita Jean from the NorWest Community Health Centres is also worried about her organization's inability to reach its clients to provide health services.

In new data provided to CBC News, Jean said that one-third of all people served by the centre do not have a phone number listed. That amounts to 4500 clients, including those accessing walk-in and harm reduction services.

"We have no way to get in touch with them. You can imagine that as a primary care provider, we're not going to be using electronic means like Facebook to reach out to folks. It's not compliant with privacy laws. It would be a phone call. So the client is very much isolated, and we're very much reliant upon them coming to our site."

Anita Jean from the NorWest Community Health Centres is working on a funding proposal to develop a "prescription for IT" (supplied by Anita Jean)

As part of their work with the coalition, NorWest is developing a funding proposal it will submit to the Red Cross this month to create a "prescription for IT"

The funding would allow the organization to "equip individuals that are most likely to succeed in their ability to benefit from a computer if we can provide the initial set-up and supplying of equipment, provide some training and support, and subsidize the internet access for a few months," said Jean.

For Lynch, all of this work is really about achieving "economic and social justice, so that everybody has equal access to what they need to live a good life."

Zoom meetings, online doctors appointments, going to work in pajamas - for many people in Canada, this has become the new norm. Everything seems to be online. But not everyone can access the programs and services that have moved to the Internet. Now a growing coalition of agencies across Ontario are calling for the provincial and federal governments to recognize digital access as a human right. The CBC's Logan Turner discusses the growing digital divide. 8:58

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now