Thunder Bay·Ontario Votes 2022

This Ontario election is about many things. Indigenous issues aren't among them, observers say

The Ontario election campaign has largely ignored Indigenous people and issues, according to several current and former political leaders and analysts who hope that will change soon ahead of the June 2 vote.

'I am very disappointed. I thought we were getting somewhere

The leaders of the four major political parties in Ontario discussed a wide range of topics during the leaders' debate on May 16. Missing from the conversation, several observers told CBC News, was any substantive conversation about Indigenous issues. (Frank Gunn/The Canadian Press)

Over the last three weeks, Ontario election campaign leaders and candidates have addressed a range of issues — including affordability, housing and health care — and offered promises leading up to the vote next month. 

But there has yet to be substantive conversation about Indigenous people and issues, say several current and former political leaders and analysts who spoke with CBC News.

The Chiefs of Ontario hosted a forum toward the end of April for the 133 First Nation chiefs to hear from and share their priorities with the four major party leaders (the Progressive Conservatives' Doug Ford had to postpone his meeting until next week).

But since then, Glen Hare, Assembly of First Nations regional chief for Ontario, said he's heard nothing from the parties.

"I am very disappointed. I thought we were getting somewhere," said Hare.

Glen Hare, Assembly of First Nations regional chief for Ontario, says he's disappointed by the lack of conversation around Indigenous issues during the Ontario election campaign. (Anishinabek Nation)

"As we move forward, year after year after year, it just seems like it's less and less about anything about First Nations during the campaigns."

There hasn't been a major policy announcement related to Indigenous people, and none of the leaders of the main parties have visited an Indigenous community. NDP Leader Andrea Horwath did have a trip planned to a remote First Nation before it was announced she had tested positive for COVID-19.

During two 90-minute leaders' debates, the heads of the PC, NDP, Liberal and Green parties mentioned Indigenous people just four times, a stark contrast to the federal leaders' debate eight months ago in Ottawa, where one of the five debate topics focused on Indigenous people, culture and reconciliation.

Statements provided to CBC News from the Ontario Liberal, PC and New Democrat parties each said their leaders are talking to Indigenous people on the campaign trail, and listed a number of the commitments made in their platforms. The Green Party didn't respond to a media request, but its platform includes a number of commitments on Indigenous issues.

Still, Isadore Day, a former Ontario regional chief, said that similar to the 2018 Ontario campaign, Indigenous issues have largely been missing from the 2022 conversation.

Isadore Day, a former Ontario regional chief, says Indigenous issues have been largely absent from the 2022 provincial election campaign, and shows 'just how broken the parliamentary system is when it comes to representing Indigenous issues.' (CBC)

"There doesn't appear to be a whole lot of enthusiasm or targeted efforts," he said, adding it comes as a surprise given the recent media attention on children in residential schools and the search for unmarked graves in various parts of Canada.

All six Indigenous commenters who spoke to CBC News shared a long list of priorities they'd like to see addressed this Ontario election campaign, including housing, mental health, climate change, boil-water advisories, economic development, and implementing the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

Platforms have 'massive gaps' on Indigenous issues

The four main party platforms do include a range of commitments to Indigenous communities that touch on those issues to varying degrees.

But even then, the platforms have "massive gaps," according to Riley Yesno, an Anishinaabe writer and research fellow with the Yellowhead Institute, a First Nations-led research centre at Toronto Metropolitan University.

One of the biggest issues, Yesno said, relates to mining and the Ring of Fire, a proposed mega project in the far north that all parties say contain the critical minerals necessary to build greener batteries and cars.

"They're [all] pledging to making access roads 24/7 to get into the Ring of Fire," she said.

Yellowhead Institute research fellow Riley Yesno says her biggest concern with the four major political party platforms is they all make huge commitments about mining in the far north without clear consent from First Nations that exclusively occupy the land. (Submitted by Riley Yesno)

"You need consent beforehand to be able to promise that you are going to do something, which they do not [have]," said Yesno, adding there are some remote First Nations whose homelands will be affected by development in the area that still oppose it.

Travis Boissoneau, a regional deputy grand council chief with the Anishinabek Nation, which represents 39 First Nations in Ontario, said the platforms all have the same promises from previous elections.

"There's nothing really profound that's coming out of the parties and their platforms. They make mention of some potentially really good work, but I think we need to work in a more structured fashion," Boissoneau said.

Need to focus on longer-term priorities

All three levels of government work on different electoral cycles with sometimes competing priorities, Boissoneau said.

"Without structured, formal and meaningful processes to talk collectively, I don't know how we're supposed to move forward and address the issues that really affect our community."

He added there have been no commitments by parties to have those longer-term conversations that would help Indigenous communities build their independence.

"We're effectively taken out of the decision-making process, and therefore the consequences ultimately lie on the government of the day."

Travis Boissoneau, a regional deputy grand council chief with the Anishinabek Nation, says there must be commitments to more structured dialogue between Indigenous, federal and provincial leaders if real change is to happen. (Amy Hadley/CBC)

John Beaucage, a former grand council chief of the Anishinabek Nation, said that in the past four years, there hasn't been much progress on major files important to Indigenous communities. 

"There hasn't been a lot of movement in many aspects to First Nation economies, poverty levels, housing, water — the whole gamut."

Part of the problem is issues on First Nation reserves are often seen to be under federal jurisdiction, Beaucage said. But many of those issues — like health care, climate and natural resources — need attention from all levels of government.

"How do we make sure that First Nations are part of the economic benefit, with mines, with forests, with building up transmission lines, with the production of electricity and all these things that can help the First Nation economy and allow First Nations to move from dependency to independence?" Beaucage said. 

Some Indigenous issues are being discussed by some local candidates during this election, Beaucage said.

"I was pleasantly surprised last week when the local candidate from my riding gave me a call on my cellphone and said, 'I'd like to have a chat about some of the issues that I should know about.'"

Debates featuring local candidates and media interviews across northern Ontario have also touched on Indigenous issues.

Little engagement could mean lower turnout

The relative "quiet" when it comes to Indigenous issues could result in lower turnout from the population, worries Tania Cameron, a self-described First Nations voting advocate living in Kenora.

First Nations electors historically have a low voter turnout for a range of reasons, including lower satisfaction and trust with the democratic process, barriers to voter registration, and the fact the Canadian government only granted "status Indians" the right to vote in 1960, according to an Elections Canada report from 2019. 

During the last election, the newly formed majority-Indigenous riding of Kiiwetinoong saw the second-lowest voter turnout in the province. Cameron worries that will happen again.

"If a First Nations citizen is sitting back in their home thinking about what are issues that matter to me, what are issues that would motivate me to get up and go to the local community hall to vote, I don't see any party really engaging the First Nations vote at this time," she said, adding she hopes that will change in the remaining two weeks of the campaign.

But even once the campaign ends, Yesno said, the party that forms the next provincial government cannot forget the promises they made.

"That's something I hope people remember. That their commitment to Indigenous issues can't end with a vote."

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Logan Turner

Journalist

Logan Turner has been working as a journalist for CBC News, based in Thunder Bay, since graduating from journalism school at UBC in 2020. Born and raised along the north shore of Lake Superior in Robinson-Superior Treaty Territory, Logan covers a range of stories focused on health, crime, Indigenous communities, racism and the environment. You can reach him at logan.turner@cbc.ca.

now