TransCanada removes Energy East video after controversial appearance of North Bay fire chief

TransCanada has removed a promotional video showing the former fire chief in North Bay, Ont. touting the safety of the oil company.

Online ad showed Grant Love touting safety record of oil and gas company

Former North Bay fire chief Grant Love appears in a promotional video from TransCanada titled "Energy East Pipeline-Committed to Safety." Grant has since retired, but was fire chief when the video was filmed in July. (YouTube)

TransCanada has removed a promotional video showing the former fire chief in North Bay, Ont. touting the safety of the oil company.

Grant Love, who was still in charge of North Bay's fire services when the footage was shot earlier this year, appears in a promotional video posted in October titled "Energy East Pipeline- Committed to Safety."

The video was taken down this afternoon, following a complaint from the city's mayor Al McDonald.

TransCanada plans to convert a portion of pipeline in North Bay from a gas to oil line as part of its Energy East project, a proposed pipeline that would move oil from western Canada eastward.

That pipeline runs through North Bay's watershed and directly underneath Trout Lake, which is the city's drinking water source. The city has taken a stance against the proposal.

In the video, chief Love is seen talking about TransCanada's safety record, with upbeat music playing in the background.

"I would say that TransCanada Energy East are definitely committed to safety," former Fire chief Grant Love says in the video. "They've gone above and beyond in trying to show us exactly what it is they want to do and how they plan on doing it." (YouTube)

"One of the things that sets TransCanada apart ... is they have open dialogue with us. From my perspective, they haven't hidden anything from us," he says in the video.

"My experience with TransCanada, from my perspective, has gone from good to excellent," he says, pointing out that the fire service has used some of TransCanada facilities for water supply in the past.

"What I've noticed is their commitment to community, as far as safety goes."

Love could not be reached for comment.

The TransCanada Energy East video shows close-ups of the chief's medals. (YouTube)

Fire chief 'hawking' for Energy East, critic says

Nicole Peltier, who heads up the Green Party in Nipissing-Temiskaming, said she was shocked when she saw the city's fire chief vouching for the safety record of TransCanada.

"It's one thing to have our fire chief work with businesses that have risky activities," she said.

"But it's completely a whole different ball game when you have a senior official for the city in an advertisement promoting the Energy East pipeline."

"You can see public resources like our fire trucks [and] firemen in the video. It's a misuse of public resources," she continued.

"We have our fire chief ... hawking for TransCanada's Energy East pipeline."

"You can see public resources like our fire trucks [and] firemen in the video," says local Green Party CEO Nicole Peltier. "It's a misuse of public resources." (YouTube)

TransCanada says ad is about safety

In an email, TransCanada spokesperson Tim Duboyce told CBC News that Love was not paid or compensated for his appearance in the film.

"It was certainly never our intention to surprise or offend anyone with this video," Duboyce wrote.

"The video was simply posted to share the perspective of an emergency responder who has had a long-term relationship with our company regarding our commitment to safety," he continued.

"We always strive toward positive relationships with municipalities, including the mayor and council in North Bay."

North Bay mayor unaware of ad

McDonald said he wasn't aware the film was being made.

While Love never explicitly states support for the pipeline, McDonald told CBC News he asked to have the video taken down because he was concerned it could imply North Bay's support for the project.

"That just goes to show you how sophisticated TransCanada is when it comes to these types of videos," McDonald said.

Other chiefs, other videos

Love isn't the first fire chief to appear in a promotional video touting the safety of TransCanada.

Englehart's Fire Chief Tom Henderson, Cochrane's Fire Chief Richard Vallée, and Kapuskasing's Fire Chief Gerry Demeules all appear in promotional videos for TransCanada posted to YouTube in October 2015.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?