Politics

Transport Canada suspends six employees without pay over racist email

Transport Canada has suspended six employees without pay for spreading a racist email at work more than a decade ago, following a CBC News story last year that triggered an internal investigation.

‘Distributing these emails was an act of systemic racism,' deputy ministers tells department staff

Transport Canada has suspended six current employees without pay over a racist email distributed between 2006 and 2010. (Frank Gunn/The Canadian Press)

Transport Canada has suspended six employees without pay for spreading a racist email at work more than a decade ago, following a CBC News story last year that triggered an internal investigation.

The department's probe found 10 workers using employee work accounts shared an offensive parody song called "Strangers on my Flight," set to the tune of a Frank Sinatra number, between 2006 and 2010. The spoof song features derogatory lyrics based on racial stereotypes about travellers wearing turbans and mentions harming travellers with baseball bats.

In a memo sent to all staff on Tuesday, the department's deputy minister Michael Keenan and associate deputy minister Arun Thangaraj said that while the email was sent years ago, its distribution amounted to an act of "systemic racism that had a negative impact on our workplace and the public's confidence in Transport Canada's ability to operate without bias."

Of the 10 employees who shared the email, only six still work for the department. The emails were sent on Transport Canada's network, which is considered a breach of the code of conduct and an "unacceptable use of Government of Canada electronic networks and devices," according to a summary report of the investigation.

"The department carefully assessed the appropriate discipline required in response to these actions which reflects the gravity of the issues at play regarding racism and discrimination in our workplace," Keenan and Thangaraj wrote. "Accordingly, the six employees have received unpaid suspensions."

'Unconscious bias and systemic racism'

The 10 Transport Canada employees who shared the email worked in aviation safety at the time — the section of Transport Canada that oversees the enforcement of Canada's "no-fly list" with airlines.

The no-fly list program has been criticized for mistakenly flagging some Canadians as security risks because of their names. A group of parents whose children are on the list complained to the department about the racist email in 2018, but action wasn't taken until CBC's report.

Keenan and Thangaraj said in his memo that the department has "seized on this incident, along with the Black Lives Matter movement" to address "unconscious bias and systemic racism in our organization."

Transport Canada has assigned a pair of senior executives to advocate for diversity and inclusion in the workplace. They're responsible for engaging employees to identify problems and come up with management changes, according to the minister's office.

Sarah Willson with her son Amin Karim and husband Faizal Karam. Her five-year-old son has been on Canada's 'no-fly list' since he was a baby. (Submitted by Sarah Willson )

Sarah Willson's five-year-old son, Amin Karim, has been on the no-fly list since he was a baby. She was among those taking part in a virtual meeting with Keenan this week to explain the disciplinary action being taken against the employees.

"That was quite surprising to us," she said. "It sounds like they have actually put a lot of thought into this and have taken some meaningful action, including suspensions." 

She said the families worked with Transport Canada on the new redress system and have now asked the Deputy Minister to start collecting data on who is being chosen for secondary screenings at airports to determine whether discrimination is taking place.

Ruby Alvi said she was "relieved" Transport Canada "finally took [the email] seriously." Her three sons have been on the no-fly list for as long as it's been around. 

"I think this is really the beginning," said Alvi. "Six unpaid leaves is huge. The fact they are now incorporating education training, anti-bias training and even executive leads in this area was reassuring to me."

Her 21-year-old son, Aadam Ahmed, said it took a while, but he hopes this sets a "precedent that no government agency should ever allow this in their environments."

'I think this sends a very strong message,' said parent Ruby Alvi

9 days agoVideo
0:40
Ruby Alvi's three sons including Aadam Ahmed are on Canada's no-fly list. They met with Transport Canada's deputy ministers about the disciplinary action taken after a racist email was spread around the office years ago. 0:40

Email reported to department twice before CBC report

Transport Canada said management first became aware of the email in 2017 when it was given a hard copy in the course of an investigation to resolve ongoing workplace problems, according to its third investigation report.  No further action into the email was taken at that time.

In 2018, another hard copy of the email was given to Transport Canada by Amnesty International on behalf of the families fighting to get their children off the no-fly list. The review that followed ended without disciplinary action.

After CBC News reported on the issue in December 2019, Transport Minister Marc Garneau launched a third probe.

"Our government does not tolerate racism, discrimination or harassment or any kind in the workplace and I am pleased to see that action has been taken against a number of individuals," said Garneau in a media statement.

It's not clear who the suspended employees are or how long their suspensions might last.

CBC News viewed a copy of the email in question, which states that it was sent by Mark Haynes on Sept. 3, 2008. Haynes is still employed with Transport Canada and, according to the government's online directory, is the manager of Transportation Security Operations in Ottawa.

Speaking to CBC News last year, Haynes referred to the email as "alleged" but didn't deny authoring it. He has not responded to CBC's latest request for comment.

Garneau's office said no further information about the remedial measures could be provided, citing privacy concerns. 

Whistleblower not surprised, not satisfied

Renee Soeterik, a former aviation security inspector in Toronto, said speaking up about the email ruined her career and was the primary reason for her departure in 2017. 

Soeterik said she received the email from Haynes in 2008, along with other employees and managers. She claims she spent years bringing it up at meetings and retreats, only to be labelled a troublemaker and ostracized.

Soeterik said the department promised her they would clean up the situation when she left, but did nothing until after the CBC report came out.

"Based on my experience with over a decade of them covering up this issue, I am surprised that finally they have done something about it," said Soeterik.

"The result is six suspensions, where I'm out of Transport Canada with an impacted pension for the rest of my life. The whistleblower will forever have a partial pension and the suspended employees will not."

She has concerns this story will prevent other whistleblowers from coming forward in the future, at a time when Transport Canada said it wants employees to speak up and report racism in the workplace.

"In upholding my sworn duty, I was harassed, gaslit, shown the door and made to make do with a truncated pension," she said. "That is the punishment for doing what I was supposed to do."

Transport Canada investigates ‘racist’ email 10 years after it was reported

News

12 months agoVideo
2:14
Transport Canada investigated allegations one of its workers sent a “racist” email to coworkers 10 years ago, while the woman who reported the email says it was covered up. 2:14

About the Author

Ashley Burke

Reporter

Ashley Burke is a senior reporter with CBC's Parliamentary Bureau. Have a story idea? Email her at ashley.burke@cbc.ca

now