DNA suggests ex-PM Diefenbaker had at least two affairs

Former Prime Minister John Diefenbaker, who was from Saskatchewan, may have several direct descendants across the country.

DNA findings suggest link with Goertzen brothers and Diefenbaker

Lawrence Goertzen (left) is seen with his brothers Stan (centre) and Darrell in this undated family handout. The Saskatchewan siblings believe they are grandsons of former prime minister John Diefenbaker. (The Canadian Press)

It's a stunning twist in an already strange story.

DNA tests now suggest that former Prime Minister John Diefenbaker fathered two sons out of wedlock. If true, then his grandchildren include Stan, Lawrence and Darrell Goertzen from Saskatchewan. 

The shocker is that the DNA test linked the Goertzen brothers with George Dryden — the Ontario man who is claiming that Diefenbaker was his father. Both the Goertzens and Dryden had mothers who had contact with the one-time prime minister.

Stan Goertzen is a retired Saskatoon city police officer. He says his natural police skepticism made him doubt that he may be related to the Prairie political icon.

"I laughed when I first heard the story, thinking somebody is playing a practical joke," he said.

But the closer he looked, the more possible it seemed.

DNA and a gold locket

About 10 years ago, the three Goertzen siblings began searching for their biological father, Ed Thorne, who had split from their mom four decades earlier.

Stan Goertzen found Thorne in Kamloops, B.C. He made a startling discovery.

"He says, 'Oh, and my biological family has found me, too'," Goertzen said of Thorne, who died soon after.

"That's the first time I found out he was adopted."

On Canadian Prime Minister John Diefenbaker: "He insisted on telling all these (Winston) Churchill stories in accent and calling him ‘Old Winston’ or ‘the old boy’ or something. You know, it was just painful." (Chuck Mitchell/CP)
Separately and coincidentally, Ruthann Malmgren, now of Rockyford, Alta., had also been looking for Thorne on behalf of her mother, Mary Rosa LaMarche, who years earlier had given him up for adoption.

LaMarche had been Diefenbaker's housekeeper in Prince Albert, Sask., in the late 1930s, Malmgren said.

At the time, Diefenbaker was having marital difficulties, according to Simma Holt's biography of his first wife, Edna Diefenbaker. His eye apparently rested on his housekeeper, whom Malmgren described as "free and easy."

In 1938, LaMarche fell pregnant and was promptly sent to Bethany Home in Saskatoon. Little John was born in February 1939. His birth certificate did not list a father.

I guess they had an affair.- Ruthann Malmgren

Malmgren, 70, remembers her parents were forever fighting. Her dad would say the baby was Diefenbaker's. He would be angry his wife wore a locket with photos of herself and the infant — a locket Stan Goertzen now has.

"I overheard my father, George Malmgren, when he and my mom were arguing, saying that John Diefenbaker was my mother's employer, and I guess they had an affair," Malmgren said.

The baby, John Eric LaMarche, was adopted and renamed Edward Thorne."I overheard my father, George Malmgren, when he and my mom were arguing, saying that John Diefenbaker was my mother's employer, and I guess they had an affair," Malmgren said.

Mary Rosa LaMarche, who died about 18 years ago, never did find her son again. Malmgren did.

She tracked Thorne down to Kamloops and, through him, connected with Stan Goertzen around 2003. She told him his biological father, Ed Thorne, was Diefenbaker's son.

"I talked to her for a good hour and a half," Goertzen said of the meeting.

"I did everything, I used every trick I could think of to try and get her to slip up. Everything that I saw, her story, her recollections, are all coming from memory. I didn't see or hear her editing anything out, so I was satisfied she believed what she was saying

The Dryden connection

Content with having found their dad, the Goertzens, who were raised largely on welfare in Prince Albert, didn't give the apparent connection to Canada's 13th prime minister much further thought.

One question, however, nagged at the youngest Goertzen brother, Lawrence, who long had doubts about whether Thorne really was his biological father.

(Colin Perkel/Canadian Press)
Enter George Dryden, 45, who grew up in a Toronto family of privilege only to discover a few years ago that the man who raised him — prominent federal Liberal Gordon Dryden — was not his father.

That revelation prompted Dryden to go on a well publicized quest to confirm long-time family whispers: that he was the product of an affair between his mother, Mary Lou Dryden, and Diefenbaker, a known confidante.

Dryden, who bears a strong resemblance to the former Conservative prime minister, believes previous genetic matching with a known Diefenbaker relative proved the family connection to his satisfaction.

I was really expecting the test to be negative. And that would be the end of it.- George Dryden

Back in Osler, Sask., Lawrence Goertzen saw a chance both to confirm whether Thorne was really his dad and to check on the link to Diefenbaker, who led the country from 1957 to 1963 and who died in 1979.

"I got hold of George Dryden and said, 'Can we kill two birds with one stone?"' said Lawrence Goertzen, 48, who does aircraft repairs at Saskatoon's John G. Diefenbaker airport.

Stan and Lawrence Goertzen sent body samples to a DNA lab. So did Dryden.

"I was really expecting the test to be negative," Dryden said, "And that would be the end of it."

The result this month stunned them all.

"We're talking about 99.99 per cent probability that they are related," said Kyle Tsui at Toronto-based Accu-Metrics, which did the tests.

"This is the expected result for an uncle-nephew relationship."

For Lawrence Goertzen, the DNA test confirmed that Stan and third sibling Darrell are his full brothers and ended doubts that Ed Thorne was his father.

Discovering the connection to Dryden halfway across the country — with Diefenbaker apparently the key link — was almost unbelievable.

"What are the chances?" he said. "It's incredible."

Dryden called the test a "very nice surprise, an early Christmas present."

"I got a feeling there might be Diefenbabies running around all over the place," Dryden said.

With files from The Canadian Press


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?