Saskatoon

Photos of Scott Moe shopping while unmasked draw online ire, Sask. Party points to deleted Ryan Meili photo

Sask. Party Leader Scott Moe was appropriately distanced when the photos were taken at the Regina Cowtown store Tuesday, his campaign team says. The party also flagged a deleted photo showing an unmasked Ryan Meili at a Moose Jaw business.

Moe was appropriately distanced when photos at Regina Cowtown store were taken, campaign team says

Scott Moe's campaign team posted this photo of Moe's unmasked visit to a Regina store on his social media feeds Tuesday. (Scott Moe/Twitter)

The Saskatchewan Party is responding to criticism from online followers and experts after it posted photos of Leader Scott Moe shopping without a mask on Tuesday.

The photos show Moe browsing the coat racks at Regina's Cowtown store without any face covering.

"Just another one of our many great Saskatchewan small businesses!" the post says.   

While no one is near Moe in the photos and Saskatchewan's official COVID-19 guidelines only call for people to wear masks if they can't physically distance from others, the photo was posted about an hour and a half after the province's chief medical health officer, Dr. Saqib Shahab, strongly urged shoppers to don masks anyway.

"We have to focus again in a lot of situations where we may have popped in to get something not wearing a mask," Shahab said at a COVID-19 news conference Tuesday afternoon. "This is the time to really put on that mask, even for that brief visit to a retail location.

"Every little piece counts."

As of Wednesday morning, Moe's Twitter post had garnered more than 140 comments, largely negative.

 

A much larger number of people liked Moe's post, however.

The feedback on a similar Facebook post was more mixed. One person who said they are a committed Moe voter said he should have been wearing a mask.

(Jenn Elchuk/Facebook)

'Messaging and leadership matter' 

Shahab imploring shoppers to wear masks came as the province posted another day of double-digit case increases and a record high of 427 active cases. Shahab also cited several superspreader events. 

"Messaging and leadership matter, especially right now when Saskatchewan has had a surge in cases lasting two weeks," Kyle Anderson, a University of Saskatchewan biomedical professor, told CBC News.

Anderson was among the people who commented on Moe's Twitter post.

"Premier Moe shopping maskless was a deliberate choice and the message he is sending is one of COVID apathy," Anderson said. 

Nazeem Muhajarine, a professor of community health and epidemiology at the University of Saskatchewan's College of Medicine, noted that COVID-19 numbers are rising. 

"We need to be talking about COVID as well in this election and what kind of leadership we need to do in order to actually get our COVID numbers down," he said.

Moe maintained distance: Sask. Party

Jim Billington, a spokesperson for the Saskatchewan Party campaign, said Moe was maintaining an appropriate physical distance when the photo was taken.

"Throughout the campaign, the premier has worn a mask when physical distancing is not possible, including at campaign events, public appearances or visits to campaign offices or businesses," Billington said in an emailed statement.

"Just as Saskatchewan people have taken every effort to adjust their lives to public health guidance during the COVID-19 pandemic, Saskatchewan's main political parties, and the leaders of those parties, have taken painstaking efforts to adjust campaigns to fit with COVID-19 guidance from public health." 

Billington did not answer when asked how many people were in the Cowtown store besides Moe and the photographer.

At a news conference in Regina on Wednesday, Moe said he had been wearing a mask during other parts of his Cowtown visit, but that he took it off when he was far enough away from others.

"Could have I been wearing a mask the entire time? I suppose I could have," Moe said. "I didn't. And I suppose after the the media today, I probably will reconsider that. But the fact of the matter is, we've been very clear on our masking policy and I've been following that masking policy."

'Could have I been wearing a mask the entire time? I suppose I could have,' Moe said on Wednesday. (CBC)

Moe added that he kept his mask on during his entire visit to a grocery store later on Tuesday night. 

Billington likened Moe's actions at Cowtown to those of Saskatchewan NDP Leader Ryan Meili, "who, in accordance with public health guidance, has also not worn a mask while physically distancing in very similar settings," Billington said. 

Billington pointed to two campaign photos of an unmasked Meili taken during a tour of Moose Jaw businesses on Sept. 29. 

The Saskatchewan Party campaign team pointed out that Moe not wearing a mask while appropriately distanced echoed actions of Saskatchewan NDP Leader Ryan Meili, seen here meeting with a Moose Jaw shop worker on Sept. 29. (Ryan Meili/Twitter)

Billington also referenced a third photo from that same tour that has since been deleted from Meili's Twitter account. The photo shows Meili talking to someone at Moose Jaw's Prairie Bee Meadery "while not physically distancing," Billington said.

Dave Mitchell, a spokesperson for the Saskatchewan NDP Party campaign, said the photo was taken from an angle that appeared to show Meili to be closer than he appeared, but that he was appropriately distanced. 

The Saskatchewan NDP Party says it removed this photo from Ryan Meili's Twitter feed because while Meili was properly distanced, the angle of the photo suggested otherwise. (Ryan Meili/Twitter)

Mitchell said the photo was removed because the party "wanted to show leadership" and did not want to inadvertently encourage insufficient social distancing. 

"As a campaign we work to abide by the recommendations of public health officials in all of our activities," Mitchell said. "Everyone is doing their best to follow public health guidelines during a difficult year." 

At his own event Wednesday, Meili said he was less concerned with the photo of Moe than with the "mixed messaging" coming from the premier, "in particular the refusal to distance himself from the anti-mask protesters."

"We need a different message sent from the premier," Meili said. "We need a different message, sent from all the leaders in the province, encouraging people to use masks and setting clear guidelines on when they should be doing that." 

Ryan Meili accused Scott Moe of sending out mixed messaging on masks. (CBC)

Both Moe and Meili have hosted indoor campaign announcements where they took off their masks when they hit the podium.

On the night of the Oct. 14 leadership debate in Regina, Moe emerged from his vehicle wearing a mask. Meili was not wearing a mask.

About the Author

Guy Quenneville

Reporter at CBC Saskatoon

Story tips? guy.quenneville@cbc.ca

with files from Stefani Langenegger, Emily Pasiuk and Adam Hunter

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now