Worry intensifies over delays in moving bumper crop

Concern about the ability of farmers to realize the dividends of a bumper crop because railways can not move grain to customers fast enough continue to mount.

Rail companies say weather a factor in ability to respond to record crop

Grain bins on Roland Poirier's farm in southeastern Saskatchewan are full of product waiting to get to a customer. (CBC)

Concern about the ability of farmers to realize the dividends of a bumper crop because railways can not move grain to customers fast enough continue to mount.

"It makes it a little bit nerve-wracking," Roland Poirier, a farmer in southeastern Saskatchewan, told CBC News this week as he surveyed bins on his farm that are filled to the brim.

Poirier said until he can get his product to a customer, he can not capitalize on his bumper crop.

"When we have that grain in the bin, that grain is cash," Poirier said. "But the only way we can get our cash out of that grain, to be able to pay our bills, is it's got to move."

Roland Poirier says he may be out an estimated $50,000 due to a delay in getting a sale. (CBC)

Poirier estimates he may be out $50,000 simply because grain prices have taken a tumble lately and he was not able to move his product before that happened.

Federal and provincial politicians have been pointing accusatory fingers at Canada's railways, suggesting the companies — CN and CP — have not done everything they can to meet the demand for rail cars.

“If we're going to be a food power, if we're going to be an energy power, an export power, we have to make sure we have the logistics in this country,” Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall said Friday at a conference in Ottawa. Wall also said, earlier in the week, that it might be time to look at shipping grain south through the U.S. instead of east and west to Canadian ports.

They are a service industry that does not care much about service.- Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz

In Regina, where federal and provincial officials announced a highways infrastructure project, federal Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz repeated his criticism that the rail companies have fallen short and noted Wall’s suggestion may be a non-starter.

"The railways have arbitrarily decided they're not going to run cars that direction [south]," Ritz said. "That's part of the problem. They are a service industry that does not care much about service."

Federal Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz, speaking in Regina Friday, said he wants to see some immediate action on improving rail service to move a bumper crop. (CBC)

Officials from the railways have said winter weather has posed problems when it comes to adding capacity, noting they have to use shorter trains during cold weather to ensure brakes can be used properly.

Ritz said he wants to see some immediate solutions to the existing backlog and did not rule out some form of federal action.

"It is a duopoly," Ritz said of the Canadian rail industry. "I think there's a role for government to play in incentives and disincentives to make sure that the service they offer is what customers are asking for."

Ritz said some meetings have already taken place, chaired by him, between grain companies and the railways. He said more meetings, with officials from the upper echelons of the companies, may yet be needed to achieve results.

"Everything's on the table, all options are being discussed," he added, when asked about what measures could be taken to improve the rail service.

Ritz said he has heard from farmers, and other industries, about the impact the rail bottleneck is having.

"If we can't supply the product, or get it to [buyers] ... in a timely way, they are going to look somewhere else," Ritz said, insisting he believes the railways are the key problem right now. "It's a matter of the railways moving product seriously."

Railways respond

Spokesmen for CN and CP told CBC News Friday they are doing what they can to handle a very large crop in a very short amount of time.

“CN is doing it level-best to move this 100-year grain crop to export position and world markets,” that company’s Mark Hallman said. “This huge crop is close to 20 million tons more than an average crop, and it carries an export potential by rail that is at least 50 per cent larger than any other program in our history.”

A CP official offered similar comments.

“This is a complex supply chain issue involving not just the railways, but all participants,” CP's Ed Greenberg said. “CP continues to collaborate with all levels of government and stakeholders in the supply chain to ensure maximum efficiency is achieved in the transportation of grain.”

With files from The Canadian Press and CBC's Bonnie Allen


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?