PEI

Historic Sea View home brought back from the brink

The 160-year-old Sutherland House in Sea View on P.E.I.'s North Shore is halfway to being restored to its former glory.

'I think it's really one of the finest old farm homes on Prince Edward Island'

Sutherland House in Sea View, P.E.I., is being lovingly restored to its former glory. Above, the house in 2015, and below, the house in January 2019. (Michele Lawlor)

The 160-year-old Sutherland House in Sea View on P.E.I.'s North Shore is halfway to being restored to its former glory. 

The 16-room house, also called Melrose Cottage, was built in 1860 for John St. Clair Sutherland, who moved with his wife Marion from Scotland in the early 1840s. It was owned by five generations of Sutherlands until the last family member Barbara Sutherland eventually moved out.

"I just felt that I definitely wanted to save this house," said current owner Phillip Gallant. "I think it's really one of the finest old farm homes on Prince Edward Island."

'Really bad shape'

The house was put up for sale — the asking price was a mere $42,000 — and it was purchased in 2010 by the Schurman family of Summerside, who gave it a new foundation and roof, he said.

'I'm pretty much firm that it must stay basically in the same styling that it is,' says current owner Phillip Gallant of the home's exterior. (Sara Fraser/CBC)

But the work stopped and the house was left unoccupied. It deteriorated badly until it was on the brink of being unsalvageable. 

"It was vacant for seven years after they did that work and there was a lot of roof damage, so that let a lot of water into the house. That pretty much destroyed all of the interior — plaster, trims and floors fell into the basement," Gallant said. 

Gallant has spent hundreds of hours stripping the interior, saving what he can including the staircase. (Sara Fraser/CBC)

"I appreciate the architecture of old and the handwork that carpenters did in those days," said Gallant. "I've driven by this house for years and seen it falling and falling and I wasn't in a position in all those times to even think about buying it." 

When he was finally in a position to buy it, the experienced builder hesitated at its condition — "really bad shape."

"It was almost at a point where you'd say do I or don't I?" he said.

Said yes to the house

After carefully inspecting the home's framework of hand-hewn beams and square-headed nails, Gallant decided to go for it.

The Meacham's 1880 Atlas of P.E.I. contains this illustration of Sutherland House. (Carter Jeffery)

"I could see that the lines were quite straight still and I felt that I could do it — it was a big, big job and a little scary by times actually," he said. "I wasn't sure if I could put my feet on a certain area on the floor or not!" 

I've saved it, but it's got a long way to go to being able to be lived in.— Phillip Gallant

He stripped the interior back to the framing — he was able to save the hardwood flooring in only one room. 

He also repaired the home's original windows, removing the panes of hand-blown glass and replacing some of the wood. He replaced the verandah and carefully replicated decorative trim on the eaves. 

An August 2015 photo of Sutherland House. (Michele Lawlor)

"I wanted to see it saved, and I think I did that," he said.

Gallant is no stranger to old properties. He has done restoration work on some notable Island homes including Hazeldean in Springfield, P.E.I., designed by famed architect William Critchlow Harris. 

House is for sale

"I've saved it, but it's got a long way to go to being able to be lived in," he said. 

'I wanted to see it saved, and I think I did that,' says Gallant, showing off one of the lovely old doors he was able to save. (Sara Fraser/CBC)

But Gallant wants someone else to take on the wiring, plumbing, insulation and drywall, as well as flooring. There's still more work to do on the outside too, he said, and the windows would need to be replaced with modern, energy-efficient ones if the house were to be lived in year-round.

"I would like to work with them, that's for sure," he said. "I think there's someone out there who wants this house, who will see what I see and will want to finish it properly, and that's the person I want to meet." 

He estimates finishing the interior will cost $250,000 to $300,000 depending on whether it will be finished as a single-family home, or a bed and breakfast with half a dozen suites. 

Don't mess with the style

The asking price is $242,600. 

"I know that sounds like a lot for a house that needs that much more, but if you were to go out today, buy the piece of land, put the septic in, the well in, the foundation, build a shell of that size ...  you'd be spending more than that, I assure you," Gallant said. 

The Sutherland family left behind some antique furniture which is now stored in the attic. (Sara Fraser/CBC)

If he doesn't find the right buyer, Gallant said he will continue to pick away at renovations. But since everyone has their own vision and taste, he'd prefer most of it be done by new owners. 

The exterior must stay the same, however.

"I'm pretty much firm that it must stay basically in the same styling that it is," he said. 

'Going to want to do it right'

How can he be sure they'll abide by his stipulation? "You talk to people, you get the feel," he said. "And it's a large amount of money, they're going to want to do it right, I think." 

Anne of Green Gables author Lucy Maud Montgomery's aunt married Robert Sutherland and lived here, where Montgomery often visited and took this photo in 1896. (University of Guelph)

The house has a famous connection, too — Lucy Maud Montgomery's aunt Margaret Montgomery married Robert Sutherland, whose father had built the house. Montgomery spent time at the house visiting with family. Her photos of it are included in her extensive collection at the University of Guelph. 

"What I've learned from stripping the house is that the original house was likely a much smaller house," Gallant said. The house may have in fact been added on to over the years, judging from the interior beams and floor heights, he said. 

He also discovered an old violin under the attic floorboards, and a letter from the late 1800s. The things he found will go to the home's new owners, he said.

More P.E.I. news

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Sara Fraser

Web Journalist

Sara has worked with CBC News in P.E.I. since 1988, starting with television and radio before moving to the digital news team. She grew up on the Island and has a journalism degree from the University of King's College in Halifax. Reach her by email at sara.fraser@cbc.ca.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now