PEI

Residents threaten legal action in bid to halt wind farm development

A group of Eastern Kings residents opposed to an expansion of provincial wind farms in the area has incorporated and hired a lawyer in its efforts to stop the project from moving forward.

Eastern Kings residents incorporate, hire lawyer to oppose new Kings County wind farm

Eastern Kings resident Don Humphrey is one of 14 members of a newly-incorporated residents' association, which has hired a lawyer as part of its bid to halt expansion of a government wind farm in the community. (Randy McAndrew/CBC)

A group of Eastern Kings residents opposed to an expansion of a P.E.I. government wind farm in the area has incorporated and hired a lawyer in its efforts to stop the project from moving forward.

The P.E.I. Energy Corporation has proposed adding seven more wind turbines with a generation capacity of 30 megawatts at a government wind farm in the Elmira/ North Lake area.

The Eastern Kings Community Association Ltd., a newly-registered non-profit corporation has hired a lawyer, Peter Ghiz, who this week sent a letter to the Rural Municipality of Eastern Kings.

The letter calls on council to halt the current process, starting with the cancellation of a public meeting scheduled for Wednesday evening. 

The Eastern Kings Community Association "is concerned that the council has embarked upon a process that is deficient because it does not comply with the law and does not adequately address the merits of this project," according to the letter.

Some of the turbines from the P.E.I. government's wind development in Hermanville, completed in 2013. The P.E.I. Energy Corporation wants to add seven more turbines at a site just down the road in North Lake. (Angela Walker/CBC)

"Some people don't want windmills or wind turbines in their backyard. Some people are worried about their property values," said Don Humphrey, who identified himself as one of 14 members of the Eastern Kings Community Association. 

He said some residents feel the municipality wasn't fairly compensated in previous agreements to allow wind farms going back to 2007.

Request for variance

The P.E.I. Energy Corporation, which will be at the meeting to provide information to the public, has applied for a 10 per cent variance to the municipality's siting guidelines to allow the turbines to be placed closer to homes and businesses — within 900 metres instead of the 1,000 metres required under the municipal bylaw.

That would allow the turbines to be spaced further apart, increasing their capacity to generate power.

The province had also considered Skinners Pond and Irishtown as possible sites for wind farm expansion, but now says it's hoping to put seven new turbines in North Lake, which is located within the Rural Municipality of Eastern Kings. (CBC)

The letter alleges council has held closed meetings to discuss the proposal when those discussions should have taken place at public meetings, according to the Municipal Government Act.

The letter also alleges that the municipality's mayor, Grace Cameron, "has continued to participate in the process and has presented her views of the project" after she and another member of council declared themselves to be in conflicts-of-interest and recused themselves.

Cameron said she had no comment to offer on her own behalf regarding the allegations. Another spokesperson for Eastern Kings said the municipality had no comment on the letter, but that the meeting was scheduled to go ahead as planned.

Assessment 'ongoing'

The letter also argues that council can't consider the request for a variance before an environmental assessment has been completed on the project.

A spokesperson for the P.E.I. Department of Energy said environmental assessments are ongoing at three different potential sites, "but at this time, Eastern Kings has been identified as our focus" for the new wind farm.

We're not going to stand by and let a wind turbine farm be built without expressing our opposition.—  Don Humphrey, Eastern Kings Community Association

The other locations that were considered are Irishtown, northeast of Kensington, and Skinners Pond in West Prince.

Before the Eastern Kings development could move forward, the province said the energy corporation "must complete the environmental impact assessment and acquire any required environmental permits before the final development permit can be issued."

'Move forward on good faith'

According to a presentation by the energy corporation at a community meeting on May 14, government had, at that point, awarded a contract for project management services and issued a tender for wind turbine procurement.

"The corporation wishes to proceed with a 30 MW wind plant in 2020," the May 4 presentation noted, but added that the "project schedule is so tight we may need to move forward on good faith."

The energy corporation has offered 2.5 per cent of revenues — roughly a quarter of a million dollars per year — to local landowners, and anywhere from $100,000 to $150,000 per year to the municipality, with the larger amount kicking in if council agrees to the province's request for a variance.

Humphrey said his group has raised $7,000 so far and is prepared to take its fight to court if required.

But he said he hoped this debate wouldn't become as acrimonious as the one that started in 2012 when the province first proposed a wind farm down the road in Hermanville, which was completed in 2013.

"This is kind of 'tough love,'" he said of his association's threat of legal action. 

"We like our neighbours and we like our council and we appreciate what they do. But we're not going to stand by and let a wind turbine farm be built without expressing our opposition."

More P.E.I. news

Corrections

  • A previous version of this story stated the new wind turbines would be added to the wind farm in Hermanville. In fact, the turbines are proposed for the nearby communities of Elmira/North Lake.
    Jul 31, 2019 7:56 AM AT

About the Author

Kerry Campbell

Provincial Affairs Reporter

Kerry Campbell is the provincial affairs reporter for CBC P.E.I., covering politics and the provincial legislature. kerry.campbell@cbc.ca

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.