University accused of discrimination for requiring dyslexic student to take course in French
Critics say human rights law trumps University of Ottawa's tradition of bilingualism
A French vs. English language battle is unfolding at the University of Ottawa.
Student James Lewicki says he's being discriminated against in the name of bilingualism.
Lewicki's application for the master of political science program wasn't accepted, because he's not able to take one course in French, which is a program requirement.
Lewicki has been diagnosed as gifted, but with a type of dyslexia that's so severe he can't learn another language.
"English as a language in itself was incredibly difficult," says Lewicki. "I spent years with a tutor, in a special classroom learning the language."
Students taking the master's program in French are not required to take one course in English.
Human rights complaint filed
Lewicki would like to take the one course required in French in English instead, or have the university provide a translator, but he says "they're insistent that they will not support any form of accommodation."
He says a university official suggested that he apply to another program that is "less stringent on bilingualism."
"They can say, 'Go somewhere else,'" says Lewicki. "But turning someone away because of a disability and saying, 'There are other options,' is still discrimination. If you turn someone away from your store because of the colour of their skin, or their gender, or identity, that's still discrimination, even if there's a store next door that would take them."
The University of Ottawa declined several Go Public requests for an interview, but in an email said that the purpose of the university was "to further bilingualism and biculturalism and to preserve and develop French culture in Ontario."
The spokesperson for the University of Ottawa says its admission requirements do respect the Ontario Human Rights Code.
"The University of Ottawa does not see this as an accommodation issue," says the email. "Mr. Lewicki was not admitted … because he did not meet the essential admission requirements for the program."
The requirement on the university's website states that students must have "an active knowledge of French" and take at least one course in French.
'Human rights law trumps tradition'
"What we see … time and time again is rigid requirements that unnecessarily exclude people," says Renu Mandhane, chief commissioner of the Ontario Human Rights Commission.
Go Public contacted Mandhane before Lewicki filed a formal complaint.
"Quite honestly, human rights law trumps tradition," says Mandhane. "You have to articulate something that goes beyond, 'This is how we've always done it.'"
Mandhane says institutions like universities have a duty to try hard to accommodate people with disabilities.
Under the law, a university can only discriminate against someone if it can prove that making accommodations would cause undue financial hardship or safety concerns.
"Things that we hold to be untouchable, are not," says Anne Levesque, chair of the Human Rights Committee of the Council of Canadians with Disabilities.
"Admission standards are not exempt to human rights legislation," says Levesque. "We always need to consider the impact that they will have on persons with disabilities, and to explore the way to eliminate those barriers."
University called inflexible
Lewicki says he faced discrimination at the University of Ottawa several months ago — ironically, while taking a course on human rights.
"I write with a computer, because I can't write by hand," says Lewicki, due to a physical disability called graphomotor disorder. "I'm allowed a laptop in classroom and during exams, as long as it's not connected to the internet."
But a professor said he would not allow anyone in his class to use a laptop.
The Student Federation of the University of Ottawa says it's tried "continuously" to talk with the university about better accommodations for students with disabilities, but that the university is not "flexible."
"We've seen many cases where the university has failed to provide adequate accommodations, and we will extend our support to James Lewicki so that the proper accommodations are given to him," says vice-president of communications Romeo Ahimakin.
"Students like James are suffering," says Ahimakin.
Other students fight discrimination
Cases where universities are accused of discrimination are rare, but not unheard of.
In January, a student at York University won a two-year challenge to have universities accommodate students with mental disabilities, without students having to disclose their diagnosis when trying to get academic support.
Last fall, a professor at St. John's Memorial University came under fire for refusing to wear a small transmitter that would allow a hearing-impaired student to hear her lectures.
In Lewicki's case, Mandhane says students who have struggled and worked hard to pursue graduate education should be academically encouraged, not discouraged.
"It would be a shame for a student like that … not to be able to succeed because of very rigid interpretation of requirements."
"I think there is, anecdotally, a bit of a backlash within universities about the request for accommodation," says Mandhane. "Feeling that everyone's diagnosed with a disability, everyone comes with requests for accommodation."
But Mandhane says this case could be an opportunity to show leadership.
"This is a moment to accommodate a student who has a disability. To address a thorny issue in a thoughtful way that really takes to heart not only the letter of the [human rights] code but the spirit and intent of the code."
Lewicki says that whatever happens now, the University of Ottawa's refusal to consider his application will cost him a year of his life, because he has missed the deadline to apply to other universities for the fall semester.
"To have them turn their back on me like this," says Lewicki, "to point at me and say, 'You're different and we won't let you in because of it' — that's an emotional blow."
Submit your story ideas
Go Public is an investigative news segment on CBC-TV, radio and the web.
We tell your stories and hold the powers that be accountable.
We want to hear from people across the country with stories they want to make public.
Submit your story ideas at Go Public.
Follow @CBCGoPublic on Twitter.
With files from Enza Uda
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?