Trucker's comment provokes Twitter anger after Ottawa cyclist's death
Nusrat Jahan, 23, died after being hit by dump truck while cycling along Laurier bike lane
Three days after a truck driver was charged in the death of an Ottawa cyclist, the head of the Greater Ottawa Truckers Association is defending truck drivers, saying bikes shouldn't have been made equal to trucks on the road.
Ron Barr, president of the Greater Ottawa Truckers Association, was a guest on CBC Radio's Ottawa Morning on Monday.
He told host Robyn Bresnahan he questions the severity of the charges laid against Steven Conley after a crash on Laurier Avenue in downtown Ottawa claimed the life of 23-year-old Nusrat Jahan on Sept. 1.
The charges against Conley include criminal negligence causing death, which carries a maximum sentence of life in prison, and dangerous driving causing death, which carries a maximum sentence of 14 years in prison.
"Any time we hear charges like that, it's pretty drastic for our industry. ... So just to make a mistake and do a right-hand turn, and to have those kind of charges levied, it's pretty heavy damage," Barr said.
"I believe it's devastating for our industry because one of our members made a mistake that day. I think it's devastating for the family of the dead girl, paramedics, just everybody. It was just a tragic, tragic day for everybody. And nobody wants to go to work, Robyn, and ... be the cause of somebody not going home. It's just one of those things."
Barr said he believes bikes should not have been made equal to trucks on the road, and bikes should not have the right of way over trucks turning right at every intersection.
"What amazes me is that the bikes have precedence over trucks or vehicles. They have those green boxes right at the front of the light. So what I would like to see is that whatever corners that are used to turn right are dealt with a little bit better," he said, adding he would like another stop sign for cyclists far back from the intersection.
- Truck driver charged after fatal bike lane collision
- Cyclist dies after fatal crash involving dump truck
"Because let's face it: I never believed that a bike should be equal to a truck. The tie goes to the truck every time, so we've got to use some provisions to make sure they're back, and that trucks have the right of way when they're going to turn right at certain designated corners."
After being told by Bresnahan that some people might find his comments "disturbing," Barr said, "so be it."
"If I'm not at the table discussing with the bikers, we cannot be relegated to second or third class on the road. There's no question about that. We need to move the city. Without a truck, nothing moves. That's all."
Barr also said some discussions he's had with cyclist advocates haven't gone the way he'd like them to.
"[They're] very aggressive to push their cause. I believe we need somebody at the table to say, 'Yes, we will work with you to do what we have to do.' ... But we seem not to get invited to these groups and they come out with these special rules for bikes and my goodness gracious," Barr said.
"We still have to move vehicles, there's a lot of construction going on downtown, everybody wants Ottawa built for 2017, there's a lot of traffic down there. ... And people have to realize, these trucks are big. When you're right beside a truck, it's very very difficult for the driver to see ... [you]."
Barr added that the trucking association will be doing some public service announcements on how trucks turn right and how to handle them.
Social media reaction
Cyclists responded swiftly to Barr's comments on Twitter.
To recap: Trucks are bigger, trucks do stuff, bikes get special treatment & the bikes are lower tier of vehicle. <a href="https://twitter.com/OttawaMorning">@OttawaMorning</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/ottbike?src=hash">#ottbike</a>—@teacherace
Trucking rep on <a href="https://twitter.com/OttawaMorning">@OttawaMorning</a> making me want to tear my hair out. "Without a truck, nothing moves at all." SMH. Bc <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/ottbike?src=hash">#ottbike</a>-rs aren't impt?—@jennifersalahub
<a href="https://twitter.com/OttawaMorning">@OttawaMorning</a> His attitude is the problem. Stops 100m back for <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/ottbike?src=hash">#ottbike</a>? Trucks always get right of way? Come on.—@dairpo
Mr. Barr should change his approach & consider the safety of all on the road and not just the 'rights' of truckers!! <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/Ottawa?src=hash">#Ottawa</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/OttawaMorning">@OttawaMorning</a>—@SmithSofia
<a href="https://twitter.com/OttawaMorning">@OttawaMorning</a> ask him a simple q, how many years has he driven a truck and has he killed anyone? It is possible to drive a truck safely.—@asselsm