Ottawa

National Holocaust Monument 'desecrated' by use as photo and video backdrop

Members of the Jewish community say more needs to be done to educate the public about the Holocaust as a national memorial continues to be used as a backdrop in photo shoots, fashion campaigns and music videos.

Monument commemorates 6 million Jews who died in the Holocaust

Using Holocaust monument for photo shoots ‘completely inappropriate,’ community members say

3 months ago
Duration 2:18
Members of several local organizations say the purpose of the National Holocaust Monument is sombre reflection and education, not as a backdrop for photo shoots.

Members of the Jewish community say more needs to be done to educate the public about the Holocaust as a national memorial continues to be used as a backdrop in photo shoots, fashion campaigns and music videos.

The National Holocaust Monument in Ottawa, inaugurated in 2017, is located in the city's downtown on the corner of Wellington and Booth streets.

The monument is meant to ensure "the lessons of the Holocaust, as well as the remarkable contribution Holocaust survivors have made to Canada, remain within the national consciousness for generations to come," according to the National Capital Commission's website, which is responsible for maintaining it.

The Holocaust is one of the worst genocides in human history, with more than six million Jews murdered during the Second World War.

Andrea Freedman, CEO of the Jewish Federation of Ottawa, says photo shoots and music videos have no place at the Holocaust Monument. (Nicole Williams/CBC)

The monument's design features tall, sombre, concrete slabs with several murals inside depicting scenes of the Holocaust. There are also signs inside with facts about what happened. Large signs on either side of the site's entrances read "National Holocaust Monument."

Despite this, numerous people have flocked to the site to use it as a backdrop for photos and videos that have nothing to do with honouring victims and survivors. Several people have tagged themselves on Instagram, posing at the monument.

Local clothing company V Kentay recently faced criticism both on and offline for doing just that.

A video it posted to its social media platforms and website last year — which has been getting attention recently — features a model wearing pieces of a new swimsuit collection, posing around the monument. At least two other videos from the company had been filmed there.

Screenshots from a company's fashion campaign videos where a model walks through the monument wearing designs from a local clothing company. The company apologized and removed the videos after backlash online. (V Kentay/YouTube)

"To know that this place has been desecrated, that their memory has been desecrated, and that a place of sombre reflection and education was used in a fashion shoot, not for the first time, is incredibly frustrating and disheartening," said Andrea Freedman, president and CEO of the Jewish Federation of Ottawa.

While the space itself is public with no official rules in place about photography and videography, Freedman said people should understand its intended use. 

WATCH | Fashion shoots at the Holocaust memorial: 

Photo shoot at National Holocaust Monument draws criticism

3 months ago
Duration 1:01
Ottawa clothing company V Kentay posted several videos of a model posing at the National Holocaust Monument last year, sparking criticism both on and offline.

She welcomes people to take pictures for themselves and to even post photos or selfies with the monument online. However, that should always be done respectfully with the intention of educating people about the Holocaust.

When contacted by CBC, V Kentay co-founder Phoebe Genus issued an apology. 

"It has come to our attention that V Kentay has offended the Jewish and Ottawa community," wrote Genus in an email statement.

"From a creative perspective, the artistry of the memorial seemed to be a perfect fit for what my team and I were looking for aesthetically for that particular campaign," she wrote.

    "I erred to consider any political or emotional implications this decision could have caused. I offer my deepest apologies and regret making this decision. I made an honest and immature mistake as a new business owner."

    The videos have since been removed from the company's website and social media platforms.

    Other members of the Jewish community said it serves as a good reminder about the need for education about the Holocaust.

    Mina Cohn, left, and Judy Young are both with the Centre for Holocaust Education and Scholarship in Ottawa. They say there needs to be more education about the monument and what it means to both the Jewish community and Canadians. (Nicole Williams/CBC)

    Since the monument was unveiled five years ago, the chair of the Centre for Holocaust Education and Scholarship (CHES), said she's seen a number of photographers and videographers at the site shooting Instagram ads, fashion campaigns and music videos.

    "It's very upsetting that it's reoccurring and it's not the first time that it's happened," said Mina Cohn.

    Judy Young, another member of CHES and a Holocaust survivor herself, said she's not interested in seeing those people punished but that more needs to be done to inform the public.

    "I think there ought to be more information, not just on the monument itself, but information out about what the significance of this place is," she said, whether that be on the NCC, the federal Department of Heritage or the CHES as a community organization.

    Members of the Jewish community say more needs to be done to educate the public about the Holocaust as a national memorial continues to be used as a backdrop in photo shoots, fashion campaigns and music videos.

    ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Nicole Williams is a journalist for CBC News based in Ottawa. She has also worked in P.E.I. and Toronto. She is part of the team that won a 2021 Canadian Association of Journalists national award for investigative journalism. Write in confidence to Nicole.Williams@cbc.ca.

    now