No words: Social enterprise told to remove wall mural with positive message
Highjinx co-owner says mural has made neighbours feel welcome, but someone complained
"We can't help everyone. But everyone can help someone."
Painted in black and red letters on a white background, those words are part of a mural on the side wall of a Kent Street building in Ottawa's Centretown area that houses social enterprise Highjinx.
The second-hand store sells vintage and antique products and doubles as a hub for people who are homeless or living on a low income.
A group of Carleton University students and alumni painted the mural during Ramadan as a gift.
- Get the story behind Centretown's murals, while you still can
- Young artists envision a world without COVID-19
"Having that wall with the slogan has made our neighbours in the community feel very welcome," Karen Nielsen, co-owner of Highjinx, said in an interview on CBC Radio's All In A Day.
"We are seeing, you know, all different kinds of people that are entering our backyard and feeling welcome and able to receive some help or some food or just hang out in a place where they feel safe."
Complaint leads to violation notice
Not everyone approved of the mural. The City of Ottawa says it received a complaint, then discovered no permit was sought and ordered the mural be taken down.
The city gave the property owner, who is renting to Highjinx, a deadline of July 14 to remove it or apply for a residential mural permit. The deadline was extended to give the Highjinx team more time to find a solution.
"We're good neighbours. We're not rule breakers, so we will do what's necessary," said Nielsen.
"We do think it's ridiculous and offensive to remove a gift because one person is offended by it."
Nielsen admits the students who painted the mural didn't apply for a permit, although they did get permission from the building's owner and the neighbouring landlord.
LISTEN: City of Ottawa tells social enterprise to remove mural
Artist to paint new mural
The city's intervention prompted Nielsen to team up with House of PainT, an urban arts festival that celebrates hip hop and graffiti, in a bid to salvage the art.
Veronica Roy, the festival's executive director, said they will need to paint a new mural because the current one doesn't meet bylaw requirements that prevent residential murals from having "lettering, messaging or slogans," except for an artist's signature, logos, or the name of a business.
"I understand why the city has those rules," Roy said.
"But I think there needs to be some nuance on a case-by-case basis when it's a positive message like Highjinx has on its building."
Roy said the plan is to hire an artist who will work with the original painters to develop a design that includes visual representation of the mural's current message, given words aren't allowed.
"That's probably the best we can do within the system that we have," said Roy.
- Festival hopes burst of colour opens eyes to graffiti's potential
- House of PainT adapts during the pandemic, creates interactive street art map
Roy said the city's existing rules around residential murals are too strict and property owners should be able to paint their own buildings as they see fit, provided they aren't offensive.
"I hope it happens soon so it can be resolved, we can put it behind us, so we can go back to just being good neighbours," Nielsen said.
With files from CBC Radio's All In A Day