Ottawa

Are dead bats connected to high methane levels at Terrasses de la Chaudière?

Documents obtained by CBC News and Radio-Canada suggest tests will explore whether there's a connection between poor air quality at federal buildings in Gatineau, Que., and a bat infestation — including whether dead bats are responsible for elevated methane levels in the buildings.

Survey finds many workers report symptoms related to bad air quality

For years, workers at Terrasses de la Chaudière have complained about issues like bats, mould and poor air quality. Now the federal government has hired a private company to start tests. (Radio-Canada)

Air quality testing is underway at two federal office towers in Gatineau, Que., in the hopes of getting to the bottom of various symptoms and illnesses that workers there have reported.

Documents obtained by CBC News and Radio-Canada suggest the tests will explore whether there's a connection between poor air quality at the Terrasses de la Chaudière complex and a bat infestation — including whether dead bats are responsible for elevated methane levels in the Wellington and Eddy buildings.

Engineering firm WSP has been mandated to investigate a host of problems, from mould and insects to the bats flying around above the heads of workers, leaving in their wake a trail of droppings and raw nerves.

"All federal workers at Les Terrasses have the right to work in healthy buildings where the air doesn't make them sick, [where] they aren't packed in like sardines, and where bats are neither attracted to nor take up residence in that complex," wrote Kevin King, national president of the Union of National Employees (UNE), in a statement to CBC.

UNE is part of the Public Service Alliance of Canada, the largest union representing Canadian public servants.

Workers report respiratory, immune system illnesses

In January 2019, Public Services and Procurement Canada (PSPC) hired WSP to identify the source of the workers' symptoms, which included respiratory illnesses.

The documents show the preliminary results of WSP's study, as well as results from an August 2019 survey on the prevalence of problems at the Wellington and Eddy buildings. 

Fixing air quality in Terrasses de la Chaudiere a logistical challenge, professor says

CBC News Ottawa

12 months agoVideo
0:38
University of Ottawa business professor Gilles Levasseur says the logistics of moving workers out of Terrasses de la Chaudiere may be getting in the way of finding the source of air quality problems that have been plaguing the buildings. 0:38

In all, 261 workers responded to the survey: 70 per cent of workers in the Wellington building and 30 per cent from the Eddy building.

More than 10 per cent of the workers at the two buildings who responded said they were being treated for a chronic respiratory illness — and of those respondents, more than half also said they'd been treated for immune system illnesses.

Only 20 respondents reported no work-related symptoms.

One third of respondents also reported seeing insects or bats in the workplace, and a third also noted visible signs of water damage. 

Documents obtained by CBC and Radio-Canada show results of preliminary air quality testing at two Terrasses de la Chaudière buildings at 10 Wellington St. and 15 Eddy St. in Gatineau, Que. (CBC)

Methane levels up and down

The air quality tests, taken in September 2019, focused on both methane readings and the potential presence of the fungus Histoplasma capsulatum, which is sometimes present with bat droppings and can potentially be harmful to people exposed to it.

While there was no evidence of the fungus, the tests did show double the acceptable limit of methane in the library and on the fourth floor of the Eddy building.

However, those levels disappeared when the rooms were tested again the following day, the documents show.

This photo, taken by an employee at Terrasses de la Chaudière on the sixth floor of the Eddy building, purports to show bat droppings on a windowsill. (Submitted to Radio-Canada)

The documents also suggested there would be a need to "further discuss the risks to human health if bats have died inside buildings," and also "further discuss the correlation between methane concentrations and the possible presence of dead bats inside buildings."

In a statement to CBC, PSPC spokesperson Michèle LaRose wrote that any methane detected was at "levels significantly below those of concern for human health."

"It has been recommended to test the indoor air quality of certain parameters in winter, when the heating system is operating at full capacity," she wrote.

Larose said there will also be a thorough check of the heating, ventilation and air-conditioning systems, as well as inspections to identify the presence of mould. 

'Band-aid' solution

Workers at Terrasses de la Chaudière have also suffered through problems with insects and cockroaches.

PSPC has also hired pest control companies to resolve the issue.

Last October, the Public Service Alliance of Canada asked workers to sign a petition that would be sent to members of the House of Commons, demanding more urgent action to deal with problems at Terrasses de la Chaudière. (Radio-Canada)

"Our current management plan includes an annual program to seal building entry points on exterior surfaces and daily inspections of building spaces for the presence of bats. Measures are being taken to reduce their incidence in the complex," said Larose.

King said the union — which has been trying to pressure the federal government to tackle the problems at Terrasses de la Chaudière with urgency and transparency — was "encouraged" by PSPC's actions.

He also, however, called them "Band-aid" solutions.

"[We] would like to see the many departments at the buildings create a joint health and safety group to tackle the problems that have been reported for decades," King wrote.

A final report is expected in the spring.

Corrections

  • A previous version of this story said workers at Terrasses de la Chaudière have also suffered through problems with bedbugs and cockroaches. In fact, no bedbugs have been found at Terrasses de la Chaudière.
    Feb 10, 2020 2:23 PM ET

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now