Ottawa

Cheap but unregulated: Why illegal carpooling is a growing problem

It's illegal in both Ontario and Quebec to engage in 'commercial carpooling,' but that hasn't stopped drivers from trying to skirt the rules.

Radio-Canada investigation finds drivers willing to skirt the rules

When Samantha Feder arrived at her departure point, what she expected would be a small sedan turned out to be a shuttle-style van with about a dozen riders. (Samantha Feder)

Samantha Feder just wanted to get to Toronto.

In September, the Ottawa woman booked a trip with Amigo Express, a company that connects drivers with passengers looking to share the costs of long-distance trips, in what she expected would be a four-seat sedan.

But when she showed up on her day of departure, a shuttle-style van with an unfamiliar licence plate and more than a dozen random strangers inside was waiting for her.

"It was clear to me that there were people who maybe had booked from other services [like] Kijiji or Craigslist," Feder said.

"I decided I was not going to get into the car."

'I decided I was not going to get into the car,' Feder said. (Yasmine Mehdi/Radio-Canada)

Kijiji, Craigslist and other such sites are filled with requests from drivers seeking passengers to share the cost of one-off trips, such as chipping in for gas, a practice that's completely above board.

But there are also posts offering multiple trips a day in state-of-the-art vans equipped with the internet and other amenities — and that sort of unlicensed carpooling is prohibited in both Ontario and Quebec.

Strict rules

In Ontario, transportation services that take passengers across municipal boundaries for a fee — aside from taxis and personal carpools — must have a proper operating licence through the Ontario Highway Transport Board.

Under the Public Vehicles Act, carpooling vehicles cannot carry more than 10 people. 

They can only make a single, one-way or round trip per day, drivers can only charge to cover the costs of operating the vehicle, and the presence of passengers must be "incidental" to the driver's purpose for the trip, according to transportation ministry spokesperson Kristine Bunker.

"Drivers offering intercity rideshare services for compensation above and beyond reimbursement for expenses incurred to operate the vehicle are in contravention of these requirements," wrote Bunker in an email.

The regulations are also clear in Quebec: According to a statement on the transportation's ministry website, there is "no such thing as commercial carpooling."

A quick scan of sites like Kijiji and Craigslist turns up a number of drivers offering passengers rides for a fee. There are strict rules around paying for an intercity carpool, and a Radio-Canada investigation has found a number of drivers are willing to skirt them. (Radio-Canada)

As part of an investigation into the scope of illegal carpooling, Radio-Canada reserved a trip from Ottawa to Montreal with a driver who was offering six trips — three there and three back — each day. 

Using hidden cameras, Radio-Canada reporters showed up at the meeting point twice to find the same driver in the same vehicle.

When asked if he had a special Ontario permit for this type of trip, the driver said he didn't and then told the reporters to "take a Greyhound" instead. 

Contacted by Radio-Canada a few days later, the driver said he had ended this sort of activity. As of Friday, however, his advertisement was still online.

No licensing, no oversight

Radio-Canada also spoke to a group of people waiting for a similar carpooling pickup in the ByWard Market. Many said they weren't worried about safety risks, calling it a more affordable option than taking either the bus or the train.

"It is a problem," said Kristine D'Arbelles, a spokesperson with the Canadian Automobile Association (CAA).

D'Arbelles said the internet has made illegal carpooling much easier, with risks to passengers. There's no way of knowing if the driver has a valid driver's licence, if they're insured, or what condition their vehicle is in, she said.

"There is no licensing and there is no oversight," she said.

CAA spokesperson Kristine D'Arbelles says illegal carpooling is concerning because drivers may be unlicensed and therefore not subject to oversight. (Yasmine Mehdi/Radio-Canada)

Amigo Express, also known as Kangaride, declined an interview with Radio-Canada.

The company's director, Marc-Olivier Vachon, wrote in an email the company was taking all steps to stem the improper use of sites like Kijiji.

A spokesperson with Kijiji said the site is taking measures to counter illegal carpooling, and has a "dedicated commitment" to comply with the law.

"We commit significant resources toward the detection and prevention of activities that infringe our policies — this includes industry-leading technology and a dedicated community support team, in addition to help from our community of Kijiji users who flag inappropriate postings," wrote Marie-Philippe Busque in an email.

As for Feder, while she was able to get her booking refunded, she ended up having to take an expensive last-minute train to Toronto.

"Although they did give me credits, I haven't used the service since," she said.

With files from Radio-Canada's Yasmine Mehdi and Dominique Degré

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.