Ottawa

'Grotesque' Château Laurier addition clears final hurdle

The hugely controversial addition to the historic Château Laurier hotel can go ahead, Ottawa's planning committee voted Thursday.

Planning committee approves site plan in 8-3 vote

The view of the latest Château Laurier addition design from the Ottawa Locks. (Larco Investments)

The hugely controversial addition to the historic Château Laurier hotel can go ahead, Ottawa's planning committee voted Thursday.

Several city councillors said they dislike the hotel addition's modernist design, and said their inboxes are full of emails from frustrated residents who also detest it. Nevertheless, the committee approved the site plan by a vote of 8-3.

"It is their property, no matter how much you dislike [the design]," said Coun. Rick Chiarelli, who questioned why the National Capital Commission, Parks Canada or other federal agencies hadn't stepped in.

The design has been modified five times in the three years since it was first proposed, and has been reduced in height from 11 storeys to seven.

City council had already approved the more critical heritage permit last June. At the time, council told the architect to include more limestone and better reflect the shape of the existing Château Laurier's windows. The city's chief planner, Steve Willis, has said those conditions have been met.

On Wednesday, Coun. Mathieu Fleury tried to convince city council to revisit the heritage permit, but council refused. Fleury said he'll try again in the coming weeks.

Ottawa's head planning lawyer, Tim Marc, said going down that road would land the city in court with Larco.

With its site plan now approved, all that's left for owner Larco Investments to do is to obtain a couple of minor approvals from the NCC and the city's committee of adjustment.

Despite a chorus of opposition from residents, Ottawa's planning committee approved the proposed addition to the Château Laurier in an 8-3 vote. 1:38

Addition a 'desecration'

Speakers at Thursday's meeting didn't mince words.

Former cabinet minister David Collenette called the addition a "desecration" and a "travesty which vandalizes a national historic site."

The Château is fire. The addition is water. The two are locked in a struggle to cancel each other out.- Peter Coffman, architectural historian

Architectural historian Peter Coffman said the design is completely  incompatible with the historic hotel.

"In place of romance and playfulness, we have straight lines, right angles and mathematical precision. The Château is fire. The addition is water. The two are locked in a struggle to cancel each other out," said Coffman, who also called the design "grotesque."

Council had already approved the design last June, with some conditions. 5:11

Shawn Barber of the Centretown Citizens Community Association said the public intuitively understands that disconnect, too.

"Listen to the radio call-in shows, look at social media, read letters to the editor," he said. "Rarely will you find the public so united on an issue as opposition to this proposal."

Former cabinet minister David Collenette appealed to planning committee to reject the hotel addition, calling it a 'travesty which vandalizes a national historic site.' (Kate Porter/CBC)

The architects for Larco Investments called the addition an essential project that needs to move ahead so the hotel can compete with others in the city.

Larco Investments' architect called the new terrace between the existing hotel and a planned addition an 'exquisite space' that will form the new heart of the Château Laurier. (City of Ottawa)

About the Author

Kate Porter

Reporter

Kate Porter covers municipal affairs for CBC Ottawa. Over the past 15 years, she has also produced in-depth reports for radio, web and TV, regularly presented the radio news, and covered the arts beat.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.