Algonquin bands end alliance in Sharbot Lake uranium protest
One will obey court order, the other will continue defying it
Two eastern Ontario First Nations communities are no longer united in defying a court order concerning a prospective uranium mining site near Sharbot Lake.
Chief Doreen Davis and another senior official from the Shabot Obaadjiwan First Nation told an Ontario court Tuesday that they plan to honour the order, which gives the mining exploration company Frontenac Ventures Corp. unfettered access to the site about 60 kilometres north of Kingston, Ont.
Both the Shabot Obaadjiwan First Nation and the neighbouring Ardoch Algonquin First Nation defied that order last fall, and some of the protesters, including Davis and Ardoch leaders, were in court to face charges of contempt of court.
After the hearing attended by least 70 people, Davis told reporters she and her community struggled over the decision.
"This is my community's direction. This came from many meetings over the last couple of weeks," she said.
Algonquin protesters resumed blocking access to the site on Feb. 4 after mediation talks with the Ontario government broke down, but Davis said members of her community are not participating.
"In fact, we have not been at the site," she said. "We have kept a low observation at the site, which we were allowed to under the injunction."
Disappointed by decision: lawyer
Ardoch leaders have not indicated that they plan to obey the order.
Their lawyer, Christopher Reid, said he is disappointed by Davis's decision.
"But there's more and more allies popping up for Ardoch every day so they're confident they're going to win this fight with or without Shabot's assistance," he said.
Neil Smitheman, a lawyer for Frontenac Ventures, hailed Davis's decision.
"We think it's an excellent opportunity for the healing to commence. The differences that may have existed in the past between the company and the Shabot, we're hoping that they can be mended and this is the first step," he said.
"The issue that has to be dealt with before the court is how to deal with the position the Ardoch seems to be maintaining."
The disputed site includes both private property and Crown land that is the subject of ongoing land claim negotiations.
The Algonquin protesters have argued the site is on their land and they fear that uranium drilling could lead to environmental contamination.
They occupied the site from late June to mid-October despite injunctions granted in response to requests from the company. The injunctions ordered the Algonquins off the site and gave police the authority to arrest them.
The occupation ended after the Ontario government agreed to mediation talks, but began again after those talks failed.