Nova Scotia

This N.S. historian spent years researching the Spanish flu. Now she's living in a pandemic

When Ruth Holmes Whitehead started research in 2017 for a book looking at the Spanish flu pandemic in Nova Scotia, she had no idea she'd end up living in one.

'It's awful because you sort of automatically have this [bad] feeling ... how this is going to turn out'

Historian Ruth Holmes Whitehead is the author of Nova Scotia and the Great Influenza Pandemic: 1918-1920. There are many similarities between the Spanish flu and the COVID-19 pandemic. (SRH Whitehead)

When historian Ruth Holmes Whitehead started research in 2017 for a book looking at the Spanish flu outbreak in Nova Scotia a century prior, she had no idea she'd end up living in a pandemic.

"It's awful because you sort of automatically have this [bad] feeling ... how this is going to turn out," said the author of Nova Scotia and the Great Influenza Pandemic, 1918-1920, which was published last November.

An estimated 50-100 million people died from the Spanish flu around the world, while in Nova Scotia, there were an estimated 2,200 deaths.

To date, there have been 65 deaths due to COVID-19 in Nova Scotia and more than 1.8 million globally.

Much like COVID-19 today, the Spanish flu originally found its way into the province through travel and then spread from there. This included troops returning overseas from the First World War, Massachusetts fishermen who landed here to sell fish and gear, and even American military ships headed to Europe who unloaded their sick before they trekked across the Atlantic for the Great War.

Men in Alberta wear masks, likely made of cheesecloth and twine, during the Spanish influenza epidemic. Masks have long been worn to help prevent transmission of viruses. (Library and Archives Canada / PA-025025)

Spread was also fuelled by gathering in crowds. One such instance was a church service in Goshen, Guysborough County. The word didn't exist then, but it would be called a superspreader event today.

Holmes Whitehead said the Goshen Baptist Church burned down in August 1918 after it was struck by lightning, so parishioners started meeting in a tiny schoolroom in neighbouring Eight Island Lake. A minister from Antigonish, N.S., conducted one of the services in the packed room.

"Before he left, he had infected the whole congregation of about 50 people and he'd also infected everybody in the house that was hosting him ... the death records say only three people died — a young farmer, an older married woman and a baby — but that doesn't tell us anything about the number of people in that general area that got sick from this one person and this one crowded situation," said Holmes Whitehead, who has worked for the Nova Scotia Museum for almost 50 years.

Her research on the Spanish flu was used for an online museum exhibit to mark the pandemic's 100th anniversary, but there was so much additional information she had gathered that a book was a better fit for all of it.

Some of the symptoms of Spanish flu could be particularly gruesome.

"It presents with a high fever and a feeling of terrible pain in all your joints and what was described as having a wedge hammered into your head, right behind your eyes, and people began bleeding from their noses, ears and eyes," said Holmes Whitehead.

U.S. soldiers are shown in Liverpool, England, on Aug. 11, 1918. Troops heading overseas from the U.S. to fight in the First World War helped bring the Spanish flu to Nova Scotia as ships with infected people were diverted to the province to get medical care. (NAID 86697765/National Archives and Records Administration)

"They were basically just out of their minds with pain and the lungs filled up and they drowned in their own bodily fluids and their bodies were so reduced in oxygen that often their hands and feet would turn blue," she said.

"And some people turned blue all over, a really dark blue, just because all the blood in their body was empty of oxygen."

In the 100 years that separate both the Spanish flu and COVID-19, little has changed in terms of how society responds to them, such as wearing masks to help prevent transmission.

Nurses care for victims of a Spanish influenza epidemic outdoors amid canvas tents in Lawrence, Mass., in this undated photo from 1918. Fishermen from Massachusetts were one of the sources of Nova Scotia's Spanish flu outbreak. (Getty Images)

"Our tools are not that much different," said Dr. Robert Strang, Nova Scotia's chief medical officer of health.

"We close things down. We restrict public activities. We tell people to stay home. We may have lots more fancy, modern medical tools, but at the end of the day when it comes to something like a pandemic, it's basic core public health, which hasn't changed for 100 years and probably won't change for the next 100 years, which is somewhat humbling."

Holmes Whitehead said that besides being able to test for COVID-19, one other difference today is there are so many platforms to communicate to people about what's happening and what they should do.

"And if you keep drilling it into their heads, maybe some of it will sink in," she said.

Two men in Paris wear flu masks on March 1, 1919, and carry signs advocating for the use of the mask as a means of prevention from the Spanish flu epidemic. (Getty Images)

In the midst of the second wave, Holmes Whitehead continues to hunker down at her Halifax apartment to ride out the coronavirus pandemic — and she has a message for people.

"Stay inside and wear your mask and wash your hands and don't be stupid," said Holmes Whitehead. "You know, this is not a picnic, it's not like the flu, it's really horrible. It can have lasting physiological, neurological effects that you really don't want to go there.

"Please stay safe."

MORE TOP STORIES

With files from Kayla Hounsell

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?

now