Nova Scotia

Cutting down trees in old hardwood forest 'scandalous'

Naturalists are pushing back against a plan for a forestry consortium to cut down trees in one of Nova Scotia’s oldest forests.

Wildlife biologist Bob Bancroft says there are few old hardwood forests remaining

Wildlife biologist Bob Bancroft is shown next to an old beech tree cut down by WestFor last fall. (Phlis McGregor/CBC)

A well-known wildlife biologist is calling on the provincial government to stop an "outrageous" move to continue harvesting wood from an old forest in Annapolis County.

WestFor Management Inc., a sawmill consortium, has the right to harvest wood from a parcel of Crown land — a mixed-age, multi-species old forest. Some of its trees are estimated to be up to 200 years old.

While WestFor said its harvest will promote the growth of hardwood trees, Bob Bancroft isn't convinced, saying the diversity of the forest allows a range of different animals to thrive.

"This is public land, and it's outrageous that people are gonna be able to tear this apart, 'scientifically,' they say," said Bancroft, who's been studying forests since the 1960s.

"It's actually forest mining is what they're doing: to take this and tear it apart when there's so little of it left in the province. It's scandalous."

The parcel of land measures 21.46 hectares and is located about 10 kilometres south of Bridgetown, between Corbett and Dalhousie lakes.

Forest an important habitat for wildlife

"It's a vibrant, beautiful forest," said Bancroft.

"We're surrounded by old yellow birch, and red maple, and sugar maple, and there's a bit of striped maple and beech. So it's mostly hardwoods."

Bancroft said the parcel is home to a number of mammals and birds. Fishers, owls, woodpeckers, flying squirrels, black-throated warblers, even some moose, have been noted.

Wildlife biologist Bob Bancroft points at a section of land where WestFor is expected to log. (Phlis McGregor/CBC)

He said the forest is one of the few he's seen that hasn't been compromised by human activity, describing it as a forest in a sea of clearcuts.

The forest needs to stay to allow the animals to flourish, he said.

"There's an illusion about the kind of cutting that's done that the animals just wander off," said Bancroft.

"Well, if there's ground somewhere else that's got the right habitat for them, it's usually occupied by those species. And the other thing they do is die. They just wither away and die."

WestFor began its operations in the forest last fall and is expected to resume any day.

Response from WestFor

Marcus Zwicker, general manager of WestFor, said the company plans to cut about 35 per cent of the trees on the site on an individual basis.

"We're trying to maintain and create old forest attributes," he told CBC's Information Morning.

"We're removing the [shade] intolerant species like balsam fir, white birch, some of the red spruce that's dying, and trying to promote the growth of the hardwood forest."

He said the forest's older trees like the yellow birches, which could be up to 200 old, will be left alone. Instead, the company will focus on trees age 60-80.

Images from Global Forest Watch show tree cover loss between 2001 and 2018. Tree forest loss can happen for a number of reasons, including fire and logging. The "X" indicates where the parcel of land is. (Global Forest Watch)

Zwicker said the harvested wood would go to hardwood sawlog mills, before going to other sawmills to be made into everyday hardwood products.

A "very, very, very small percentage" will go to the Northern Pulp mill, he said.

When asked how much sympathy he had for those who wanted to see the forest remain intact, Zwicker said he didn't know how to answer the question.

"We're doing our best to maintain the characteristics of the forest. That's part of our standard operating procedures," he said.

Older trees must be preserved, says naturalist

Despite Zwicker's explanation that WestFor will be selecting trees on an individual basis, a Crown land harvest plan map tells a different story.

A map from the Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources indicates the cutting prescription for the parcel is "uniform shelterwood" — which is similar to clearcutting, except it's done in stages and leaves some established trees to allow new seedlings to grow.

The parcel was only visible on the map for just a few days between late December 2018 and early January 2019.

This is a late 2018 screenshot of the Nova Scotia Department of Natural Resources harvest plan map viewer taken by the Healthy Forest Coalition. Naturalist Bev Wigney outlined the site she wants to protect in red. (Department of Natural Resources/Healthy Forest Coalition)

Naturalist Bev Wigney said the cutting system does little to protect the mature trees that may have been around before Canada's confederation.

She has two favourite trees in the forest. They are towering yellow birches she estimates to be two centuries old.

She's tied caution tape around them, along with some other trees, to indicate that they should be preserved.

"I'm hoping that that'll make the logging crew actually look at that tree a little bit more," said Wigney, a member of the Annapolis Royal and Area Environmental and Ecology group.

"I mean, we don't want them to cut, but if they do, there's what I think are important trees that should be left alone."

Naturalist Bev Wigney poses next to one of her favourite trees. She tied caution tape around it in an effort to keep it from being cut down. (Phlis McGregor/CBC)

'Every tree matters'

During the last round of cutting, logging crews felled a 138-year-old beech tree, said Wigney, who counted the rings.

"It becomes a personal thing," she said. "Are we gonna just let these guys cut it down? Because once it's gone, it's gone."

A councillor for the area said the provincial government, WestFor, and the municipality needs to "hit the pause button" on logging in this area.

"In the last five-to-10 years, everything has changed dramatically on what we know about ecosystem services, what we know about climate change, what we know about species diversity and extinction," said Gregory Heming.

"We're in a period now where every tree matters."

CBC News has reached out to the province for comment.

With files from Information Morning

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.