N.S. nurses say pandemic in care homes a 'tragic reminder' of staffing shortages
'I implore government to take action so we do not fail these citizens,' nurses union president says
The Nova Scotia Nurses' Union says COVID-19 infections and deaths in the province's nursing homes have been a tragic reminder of the province's failure to bring in higher staffing levels the union recommended four years ago.
The preface to a study paper released Friday argues the lack of nurses to assess residents and monitor those with severe dementia is "highly relevant" to the control of infectious disease.
"The COVID-19 tragedy in our long-term care facilities has brought to light how imperative it is to address staffing shortages in our long-term care sooner rather than later," union president Janet Hazelton said during a news conference.
"I implore government to take action so we do not fail these citizens."
The union — which represents about 1,400 nurses — hired Charlene Harrington, an expert on long-term care staffing who served on the U.S. Institute of Medicine Committee on Nursing Home Regulation, to prepare the 27-page paper.
Her review confirms recommendations from the union's 2015-16 Broken Homes study, calling for an average of 4.1 hours of care per resident per day, including 1.3 hours of nursing care.
According to the union, that would mean adding about 600 nurses and 1,400 continuing care assistants.
Harrington's work was completed prior to the pandemic, but a preface has been added to the report that said her findings are given added urgency by the COVID-19 deaths and infections of the past three months.
The preface notes the tragedy at the Northwood care homes in Halifax, where 246 people were infected and 53 people died during the last three months.
It said the province needs an independent review to determine the factors that led to the outbreak and to recommend solutions.
However, the union said improved staffing levels, along with measures such as more single rooms and greater access to infectious disease experts, are factors in preventing the spread of infectious diseases.
The preface said Northwood lacked staff after many care workers and nurses became ill in the pandemic, swiftly putting the home in a crisis situation that required it to call in nurses from local hospitals.
"If long-term care facilities in Nova Scotia had higher staffing levels, they would be better positioned to handle these crisis situations," it said.
"More licensed staff means better, more regular assessments and earlier detection of problems."
Premier Stephen McNeil said during a news conference Friday that his Liberal government will be considering a review of what occurred in Northwood during the pandemic.
"We are looking at what transpired at Northwood and what changes are required and what protocols need to be in place. We'll look at all of that and I look forward to hearing the results," he said.
Asked about the nursing union's call for increased hiring provincewide, McNeil said the province is assessing that.
He then noted a 2018 expert advisory panel on long-term care, created to provide recommendations to Health Minister Randy Delorey, didn't make a recommendation for higher staffing ratios.
Registered nurse requirement not met last year
The union report also reveals that inspection reports last year and so far this year show 16 facilities were cited for not meeting the requirement that a registered nurse be available for 24-hour coverage.
"Well-trained staff in sufficient numbers is an important bulwark against a threat like COVID-19," said the report's preface.
Harrington said in her report that it's reasonable for her to recommend that Nova Scotia's 7,000 long-term care residents benefit from staffing levels that meet minimum professional standards established in research literature.
She said existing studies suggest 1.3 hours per resident per day of nursing care and at least 2.8 hours per day of personal service worker care daily, for a total of 4.1 hours. The expert noted the figures should be higher for patients with more serious medical conditions.
Hazelton said the current level of care is an average of about 3.45 hours per day.
The union president said there are many nursing graduates looking for work in the province, but the long-term care homes don't have the budgets to hire them.