Nova Scotia

Mackerel trap approved for St. Margarets Bay

Fisheries and Oceans Canada has approved a commercial mackerel trap in a popular recreational area of St. Margarets Bay, N.S.

The Micou's Island trap will fish from mid-May to July with a harvest goal of 45,000 kilograms

Gary Burchell's effort to bring a commercial mackerel trap to the St. Margarets Bay area has been approved. (Robert Short/CBC)

Fisheries and Oceans Canada has approved a commercial mackerel trap in a popular recreational area of St. Margarets Bay, N.S., outside Halifax. 

The case prompted a community debate about whether the historical fishery still fit in the increasingly urban area.

"Obviously, I'm pleased with it because that's what we applied for and it finally came through," said fisherman Gary Burchell.

Burchell has been given a two-year licence to install a large mackerel trap at the tip of Micou's Island, a protected nine-hectare island on the eastern side of St. Margarets Bay.

Opponents said the cumbersome trap is not compatible with recreational uses like boating and swimming.

There were also concerns about nets and gear washing up on the shores of the island.

Resident Anna Hall said it would increase the risk of shark attacks because the trap would attract seals. Burchell denied the claim.

The mackerel trap is a long fence extended from shore that directs fish into a a large netted bowl anchored to the ocean floor. The fish are trapped and later harvested.

The trap leader will run 183 metres from shore into the bay, and the bowl where the fish are trapped is more than 120 metres wide.

"Well I hope we don't cause any great inconvenience," Burchell said.

"Hopefully, they'll appreciate what we're doing when it's all said and done. We plan on having that very well marked and … with a little bit of time in there hopefully we can coexist."

Stewardship group stays neutral

The St. Margarets Bay Stewardship Association declined to take a position on Burchell's trap when asked for its opinion by the federal government.

"The St. Margarets Bay Stewardship has chosen to remain neutral on the matter of the mackerel trap application," chair Nick Horne wrote DFO on Jan. 2 this year.

"I would like to say, however, that the stewardship association strongly supports sustainable fishery and recognizes that this mackerel trap is much more sustainable than other methods."

Burchell currently fishes from Cape Breton, but has deep family roots in the area.

He hopes to revive a trap fishery carried on by his grandfather and other relatives.

The Micou's Island trap will fish from mid-May to July, with a harvest goal of 45,000 kilograms.

Burchell also holds a licence for another mackerel trap in nearby French Village. He said that will not be fished until August, if at all.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.