Nova Scotia

Halifax to allow live streaming from its arenas, but only at discretion of renter

Minor hockey parents in the Halifax region who had no way to watch their sons and daughters play hockey will now be able watch their games on live streams, but only at the discretion of the renter of the arena.

City faced backlash from hockey parents after enforcing rule that meant games couldn't be live streamed

On Tuesday, HRM said it would enforce a rule that means games could no longer be live streamed from its arenas. (Lacy White)

Minor hockey parents in the Halifax region who had no way to watch their children play hockey will now be able watch their games on live streams, but only at the discretion of the renter of the arena.

"Following discussions with Hockey Nova Scotia and further examination of the privacy concerns, the municipality will permit live streaming for facility rentals at the discretion of the renter," a news release from the Halifax Regional Municipality said Wednesday.

"Signage will be placed in the facilities to indicate that renters in the facility may be live streaming or digitally recording their activities."

On Tuesday, the municipality said it would enforce a rule that means games could no longer be live streamed from its arenas — a rule that "has been in place for many years in order to protect the privacy of participants."

That statement and the enforcement of the policy drew the ire of hockey fans desperate to watch their kids play. They have been unable to play games for large chunks of the season due to COVID-19. As of Monday, games were back on, but no spectators are allowed.

"It's a shame that parents, family, friends and fans have been stripped of the pleasure to watch their favourite minor hockey players play hockey, even if only virtually," hockey parent Danny Cole of Porters Lake wrote in a letter sent to Halifax Mayor Mike Savage. "The joy of watching your child compete and have fun is something relished by parents."

In the letter, Cole is asking HRM to change its policy, or at the very least stop enforcing it, so live streaming of games can continue. The policy was never enforced before, even before Christmas when COVID restrictions were in place limiting the number of spectators in arenas for games.

The municipality's decision was updated on Wednesday.

"The municipality has received intense interest to record and live stream in our arenas," the news release said. "The municipality appreciates the interest and desire to be able to live stream games especially, in light of current circumstances."

'Where's the fairness in that?'

Cole, who has a son who plays U-13 hockey for the Eastern Shore Mariners, said that on Tuesday night rinks in East Hants and other areas of Nova Scotia were allowed to live stream games. 

"Where's the fairness in that?" he said.

Cole said the lack of live streaming also effects team fundraising.

His son's team sells advertising on their live streams to raise money to pay for ice time and other costs. If live streaming was banned, those financial arrangements made with businesses in their community couldn't be met, especially when traditional fundraising isn't feasible due to COVID restrictions.

"HRM started enforcing this policy unilaterally without consulting with stakeholders like minor hockey, which is typically the largest user of HRM rinks," said Cole. "In doing that they kind of set themselves up for failure. I can't fathom what they thought the fallout was going to be."

Adalyn Wallace plays for the Metro East Inferno U-9 hockey team. (Liddy Wallace)

Liddy Wallace was also upset with games not being allowed to be live streamed. Her eight-year-old daughter, Adalyn, plays for the Metro East Inferno U-9 girls team.

"No live streaming is just sad and it's really unfortunate it's come to this," said Wallace. "There are so many parents who can't watch the games and they just sit out in their cars waiting, and it's kind of heartbreaking they can't at least watch the live stream on their phones."

Wallace started a petition Tuesday morning asking for live streams to be allowed, and in 24 hours it had secured 1,200 signatures online.

The technology that allows live streaming of games on cellphones and computers has been around for a few years now. Cole points out HRM has a live stream feed set up at the Emera Oval on the Halifax Common.

Cole said the privacy argument makes no sense as live stream cameras are in the stands at games and are never inside dressing rooms. He said players would be hard to identify because they wear helmets with face masks when they are on the ice.

The municipality said on Wednesday that it will continue to work with Hockey Nova Scotia, hockey associations and other recreation partners to "balance personal privacy with the use of digital recording to record and broadcast activities that occur in municipal facilities."

now