Why Nova Scotia should look to the U.K. for its sick-note policies
'We might actually see a huge spike in employee morale,' says health-care consultant Mary Jane Hampton
This is part of a series from CBC's Information Morning where Halifax health-care consultant Mary Jane Hampton discusses her "health hacks" - ways to make your experience with the health-care system better.
A Halifax health-care consultant says there needs to be a culture shift around the use of sick notes in Nova Scotia, and a good model can already be found in the United Kingdom.
"Doctors notes for explaining absenteeism is an absolute waste of time, and it's a waste of not only the patient's time, but the doctor's time," Mary Jane Hampton told CBC's Information Morning.
Her view matches that of Dr. Gary Ernest, the president of Doctors Nova Scotia, who recently said they're a waste of time for minor illnesses.
"What offends me about sick notes is that, really, they are companies using the publicly funded health-care system and the precious resource of doctors to manage absenteeism for them, or to police their employees," said Hampton.
While people may have no way of avoiding getting sick notes, Hampton said there's an opportunity to better manage limited health resources.
"It's a hack about how we can sometimes do things to reduce demand on the health-care system by not using it for things that have nothing to do with making people better," she said.
What the U.K. health-care system does
Hampton pointed to the United Kingdom's National Health Service, where sick notes aren't required for absences less than seven consecutive days.
"The interesting twist is, you're not required to get a sick note to confirm that you had something that caused you to stay away from work. You need the sick note to confirm that you're fit to come back, which is a really profound culture shift and changes the narrative completely," she said.
The return-to-work doc is known as a fit note.
Hampton said the U.K. model flips the paradigm, creating a more supportive employer/employee relationship.
"It says that the sick note isn't to monitor employees to verify that they actually had the sniffles. It's rather a tool for going forward to say, 'This is the help that I need to make sure that I continue getting better,'" she said.
Other companies have progressive policies that allow employees to draw from a bank of personal days over the course of the year. If the employee needs more, they can have that conversation with a supervisor.
"Again, it takes the doctor out of the picture in trying to help manage absenteeism," said Hampton.
She said Nova Scotia companies that currently require sick notes should review their policy, thinking through the logic of what they're asking employees to do.
"We might actually see a huge spike in employee morale, with their employers and supervisors saying, 'You know what, we trust you, and if you are sick, we want to help you get better,'" said Hampton.
With files from CBC's Information Morning
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?