Nova Scotia

N.S. Environment Department now posting fines, compliance orders online

Nova Scotia's Environment Department is now posting online the convictions it secures and the corresponding fines for all the laws it is responsible for enforcing.

During 9 months in 2018, the department won 52 convictions resulting in $66,000 in fines

The owner of a construction and demolition disposal yard that caught fire in the Annapolis Valley last year received a $30,000 fine for two Environment Act violations. (David Williamson)

Nova Scotia's Environment Department is now posting online a list of all the convictions it has been able to secure by taking people to court for breaking a whole host of Nova Scotia laws or regulations.

Adrian Fuller, executive director of the inspection, compliance and enforcement division at the department, said the decision to build a list and post it online was an attempt to be more transparent.

"It just provides some information to people," he told CBC. "We do get inquiries from people like yourselves, and from the public about what work Nova Scotia Environment is doing."

The department is responsible for enforcing the Environment Act as well as a number of other laws, including the:

  • Off-highway Vehicles Act
  • Fisheries and Coastal Resources Act
  • Crown Lands Act
  • Tobacco Access Act
  • Wildlife Act
  • Tanning Beds Act
  • Safe Body Art Act

For the first nine months of 2018, the department won 52 convictions against 39 individuals or companies. There is a single conviction against the Department of Transportation and Infrastructure Renewal for acting without proper approval. That conviction resulted in a $697.50 fine.

"Within Nova Scotia Environment it's our role to investigate or follow up on anything that may be a potential violation regardless of who the people doing the work are, which includes people up in government as well," said Fuller. 

Adrian Fuller is the Environment Department's executive director of enforcement and compliance. (CBC)

Most of the infractions relate to contravening an order, directive, regulation or the terms and conditions of an approval.

There are 10 convictions for breaking Nova Scotia's off-highway vehicles law, including five charges again Daniel Thibeault, who was caught operating an off-highway vehicle almost a year ago without a permit or proper insurance.

He was also fined for fleeing officers and crossing a highway in the process.

The owner of a construction and demolition disposal yard in the Annapolis Valley racked up the biggest fines. Derrick Shaffer and his company Shaffer Enterprises were fined a total of $30,000 for two Environment Act violations after a fire at the North River Road facility, near Kentville, on March 22, 2016. It took firefighters five days to extinguish it.

The owner of the Debert Mini-Mart in Truro, Habib Chater, paid the smallest fine — $95 for selling tobacco to a person under the age of 19.

Fuller said the list did not include charges laid and fines imposed on people who chose to face the consequences rather than fight the charges in court.

"There are a lot more summary offence tickets issued and really a majority of those are settled out of court where people may plead guilty and just decide to pay the fine," said Fuller.

The department is promising to update the list monthly.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.