Nova Scotia

N.S. woman's move to adult facility required ministerial approval, inquiry told

A human rights board of inquiry heard more testimony today about the difficult life of Beth MacLean, who has an intellectual disability and was first placed in locked-unit, institutionalized care at age 14.

Beth MacLean has testified she asked to live in home-based environment rather than institution

Beth MacLean testified that she told her caregivers at the Nova Scotia Hospital that she'd been told she could shift into a community setting one year after her admission in the fall of 2000. (Robert Short/CBC)

A human rights board of inquiry heard more testimony Monday about the difficult life of Beth MacLean.

MacLean, who has an intellectual disability, was first housed in a locked unit at an institution when she was 14.

Her move into the unit at the Kings Regional Rehabilitation Centre in Waterville, N.S., in 1986 required ministerial approval because it was an adult facility. She later spent 16 years living in a locked unit of the Nova Scotia hospital.

"It was very inappropriate to be put in an environment where people are much older," said Jim Fagan, director of resident services at the Regional Residential Services Society.

Fagan is the latest to offer testimony at the Nova Scotia human rights board of inquiry.

Lawyers for MacLean and two other complainants allege the province is violating their basic human rights by forcing them to live in institutionalized care instead a smaller, community-based support home.   

In his testimony Monday, Fagan said MacLean was assessed in 2014 to determine whether it was appropriate to move her out of the Nova Scotia Hospital's Emerald Hall into a community-based support home.

'We could have supported Beth'

Fagan said in spite of her bouts of aggression, she would have been accepted in a community-based home.

"We could have supported Beth even if she was a risk to herself or others," Fagan said. "And there are people living in the community who would present a risk for herself or others that are still living in the community very well, that at time to time need a lot of support."   

Fagan described MacLean's life at Emerald Hall as fraught with loneliness and isolation, and said there is very little opportunity there for residents to learn new skills.

Fagan also said the two other complainants named in the case, Joseph Delaney and Sheila Livingstone, who is now deceased, would have also qualified to live in a community-based home.

The lawyer for the complainants, Vince Calderhead, said if their cases succeed, it could open the door to others who want to leave institutionalized care and move into community housing.