Nova Scotia

Naturalists comb N.S. woods for birds in bid to halt loggers

Advocates hope to show logging in Annapolis Valley will disturb habitat for nesting migratory birds.

Advocates hope to show logging will disturb habitat for nesting migratory birds

Chimney swifts are listed as an endangered species in Nova Scotia. (Ron d’Entremont)

Naturalists are listening for and spotting migratory songbirds — including an endangered species — in an effort to halt logging of a Nova Scotia forest containing old hardwoods.

A sign went up this week from WestFor Management Inc. saying cutting would resume as early as Monday in an area between two pristine Annapolis Valley lakes known for canoe routes.

Scott Leslie, the author of seven books on natural history, said Friday evening he spotted or heard over a dozen species in the area that faces harvesting, including chimney swifts, which are listed as an endangered species in Nova Scotia.

The 56-year-old naturalist said, "in three hours I generated a list of 13 migratory songbirds that are breeding in the area."

Gregory Heming, a municipal councillor for the area, said other biologists and naturalists are headed into the woods over the weekend with the goal of showing that the logging will disturb habitat for nesting migratory birds.

Gregory Heming is a councillor with the Municipality of the County of Annapolis. (CBC)

In addition, letters were sent to federal Environment Minister Catherine McKenna, urging her department to investigate the impact of the logging on bird species under the Migratory Birds Convention Act, he said.

"I've never seen such a well-orchestrated, knowledgeable group of citizen scientists that's went after the facts on what is happening," said Heming.

"When they came back to us with all the information it became clear to us it should not be cut."

The province's Forestry Department says the approval for the logging has taken the bird habitat concerns into account, and that a partial cut is a good example of selective forestry.

Bob Bancroft is a wildlife biologist and the president of Nature Nova Scotia. (CBC)

However, wildlife biologist Bob Bancroft, a former provincial government employee, said he called the RCMP and Environment Canada on Friday to ask them to enforce provisions of the Migratory Birds Convention Act.

The president of Nature Nova Scotia said his coalition of nature groups has asked him to reach out to federal authorities.

"What we've got is reckless disregard with the other animals with whom we share this province," he said.

"There's an easy answer, which is to stop this activity during the time while … they're doing their breeding."

Environment Canada didn't respond immediately with comment on whether its migratory bird legislation would be considered applicable.

Cutting will continue, province says

However, Iain Rankin, the provincial minister of Lands and Forestry, said Friday he hasn't changed his mind on allowing cutting to continue.

"It's been approved and there hasn't been any areas of specific concern to warrant any action from the department," he said.

Rankin said the partial harvest of the Crown land, which isn't a formally protected area, was deemed acceptable by the reviewers in his department.

"There are old trees in some of these stands, which there are all over western Nova Scotia," he said.

Rankin said the harvest is in line with last year's landmark study on forestry in the province by University of King's College president Bill Lahey, which called for a greater focus on biodiversity and ecological forestry.

Lands and Forestry Minister Iain Rankin said a partial harvest on the land was deemed acceptable by the reviewers in the department. (Craig Paisley/CBC)

He said it leaves longer-lived, shade-tolerant species like red spruce, yellow birch and sugar maple, while taking out some of the shorter-lived species like balsam fir.

He also said there are measures taken to attempt to protect birds and their habitat in the trees. "We do have regulations around retention of large legacy trees, cavity trees … may be kept in place during the harvesting," he said.

The company was not immediately available for comment, but said it was working on a response to a written list of questions to be provided next week.

Bancroft said much of the forest has already been cut, but he intends to continue to battle the harvest. He said he's found downed trees in the stand that were over 130 years old.

"I've been in there. I've heard them [the birds] call. It's a very unusual forest, though it's going to take the usual demise," he said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?