Nova Scotia

Austrian family must leave Cape Breton home for at least a year

A family from Austria has been ordered out of Canada after running afoul of immigration rules. They hope to be back, but it'll be at least a year before they can return to Cape Breton.

The Fuggers bought property in Richmond County in 2015 with the promise of easy immigration

Reinhard and Romana Fugger are shown with their two sons in their kitchen in Grand River, Richmond County. They have been ordered to leave Canada after their visas ran out. (Tom Ayers/CBC)

A family from Austria has been ordered out of Canada, and must leave this week, after running afoul of immigration rules.

They hope to be back, but it'll be at least a year before they can return to Cape Breton, where they've sunk their life savings into a home and farm.

Reinhard and Romana Fugger have invested nearly $500,000 after buying and improving a rural property in Grand River, Richmond County, in 2015.

They say a local man, Frank Eckhardt and his company F.E. Property Sales, facilitated the property purchase and promised easy immigration to Canada.

The Fuggers say that help with the immigration process never came.

"We find this property and we think we can do this in an easy way, because we have the information before that it is not hard, maybe easy, to immigrate here," said Reinhard Fugger.

Eckhardt's company website, hosted in Germany and aimed at Europeans, advertises property sales and "new settler consultation."

A map of the property purchased in 2015 by the Fugger family. (CBC)

The Fuggers say they found out after they got here that they paid more than the property was worth.

They paid $160,000 for 4.5 hectares of land with a small summer cottage to a lawyer recommended by Eckhardt who handled the real estate transaction. The property value was assessed at $82,000 at the time.

Real estate records show that most properties in the area sell for 1.5 times the assessed value, but the Fuggers paid 1.95 times the value.

The couple say they assumed that was because Eckhardt and the lawyer were going to help them with immigration.

Meanwhile, the Fuggers spent most of the first year digging a well, adding a stove and chimney, clearing the land and planting a garden.

Reinhard Fugger said the couple was so busy making their new place livable that their six-month visitor visas expired before they could apply for permanent residency.

Family served with removal order

When they turned to Eckhardt and the lawyer for help, they were referred to an immigration specialist in Halifax.

The Fuggers kept working on their property, bought another in nearby L'Ardoise, and had a second son, who is a Canadian citizen.

At the same time, they continued to try to apply for permanent residency on their own.

The Fuggers say they spent all their money on their property and couldn't afford an immigration lawyer or consultant.

Canada Border Services Agency eventually investigated and the Fuggers have now been served with a removal order.

They must leave by Wednesday, or face deportation and the possibility of not being able to return.

The Fuggers said they were naive and foolish to believe immigration would be easy, but Reinhard said they know they have to follow the rules and are resigned to leaving.

"In this time, we have to go back," he said. "It is the only way. It is not allowed to do the paperwork inside Canada."

Frank Eckhardt is a German immigrant who's lived in Cape Breton for 19 years.

He calls himself a property developer and runs his company out of an office in St. Peter's.

The Fuggers have emails and documents they say they got from Eckhardt implying that he was acting on their behalf in the land purchase, and they say he told them over the phone that immigration would be easy once they got here.

Reinhard and Romana Fugger, shown with their two sons, came to Grand River, Richmond County, in 2015. (Tom Ayers/CBC)

In an interview at his office, Eckhardt would not consent to being recorded.

But he said he is neither a realtor nor a registered immigration consultant, despite his website offering property sales along with "new settler consultation."

Eckhardt said he only sells land he owns or maintains an interest, and is simply willing to tell people about his immigration experience if they ask.

He said settler consultations consist of offering suggestions about local services, such as who sells insurance in Cape Breton, or who drills wells or builds homes.

"If someone asks me, 'OK, the nice home over there, do you know the owner?' I can give them the phone number," Eckhardt said.

He said he got no money for helping the Fuggers buy their property.

The Fuggers said they have an email in which Eckhardt admits he expects a commission from the property seller.

But Eckhardt said he doesn't know anything about that.

Eckhardt said he offered considerable help to the Fuggers when they first arrived in Canada, including putting them up in his guest cottage for weeks, for just the cost of the power, and allowing them to store a shipping container on his property for as long as needed.

Eckhardt said Richmond County, like all of Cape Breton, needs immigrants, and he is attracting them from Europe and helping maintain and create jobs in the area.

However, he said, people need to take personal responsibility for the rules and the process.

Immigration lawyer Lee Cohen says the Fuggers are in a bad situation, as owning property doesn't open any doors to immigration. (CBC)

Halifax immigration lawyer Lee Cohen said owning property doesn't open any doors to immigration, despite that widespread belief.

The Fuggers are in a terrible situation, he said.

Depending on the type of removal order, the Fuggers may have difficulty getting back into Canada, Cohen said.

Second son born in Cape Breton

Fugger gets emotional talking about his youngest son, who was born in the house overlooking Grand River.

"He's a citizen and he have the passport and all the things," Fugger said. "Yeah, that's also a hard point for me."

Despite their immigration troubles, the Fuggers have fallen in love with Cape Breton and hope to return.

"We want to stay here and we want to come back," said Fugger.

"Yeah, it's really great, because there are a lot of potential here to start up business, and ... the thing is we own a second property in L'Ardoise and we want to start up a business in this building."

Michele MacPhee lives in the area and knows the Fuggers through their children's playgroup.

She said the Fuggers are hard workers with progressive ideas about food security and connecting children with nature.

"They're really good people," MacPhee said.

"They have done a lot to create a life for themselves here. I'm not familiar with the details of the process and the order ... (but) I'm comfortable with them staying."

MacPhee said Cape Breton needs immigrants, especially ones like the Fuggers.

"They have a lot of skills and a lot of knowledge to share and I think that that certainly would be an additional asset for our community."

Corrections

  • A previous version of this story stated Reinhard and Romana Fugger hired Frank Eckhardt's lawyer to handle a property purchase. This story has been corrected to reflect they hired a lawyer who was suggested by Eckhardt. This story has also been updated to include details about the assistance Eckhardt gave the Fugger family upon their arrival in Nova Scotia.
    May 16, 2019 10:32 AM AT

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.