Nova Scotia

CBRM councillor who clashed occasionally with mayor announces run for top job

Cape Breton Regional Municipality Coun. Amanda McDougall, executive director of environmental agency ACAP Cape Breton, announced her intention to run for mayor next to the Baille Ard Trail forest on Friday with a half-dozen supporters.

Coun. Amanda McDougall, longtime critic of Mayor Cecil Clark, says campaign will involve creativity, respect

Cape Breton Regional Municipality Coun. Amanda McDougall announced her intention to run for the mayor's seat in Sydney on Friday in front of a half-dozen supporters. (Tom Ayers/CBC)

The race for Cape Breton Regional Municipality mayor is officially underway, with one CBRM councillor declaring her intention to seek the top seat.

District 8 Coun. Amanda McDougall, executive director of environmental agency ACAP Cape Breton, announced her plans next to the Baille Ard Trail forest in Sydney on Friday with a half-dozen supporters.

The first-term councillor and longtime critic of Mayor Cecil Clarke, said the volunteer-run trail system represents creativity and respect, which will be guiding principles for her mayoralty campaign.

"This space is powerful," she said. "The nature that surrounds the trails has the remarkable ability to adapt when waters rise and works to protect the community that surrounds it.

"It brings people together."

McDougall also said it was important to reassure people that she is "absolutely prepared" to do the job.

CBRM Coun. Amanda McDougall says she's due to have a baby in December, which will be a constant reminder that council decisions need to take into account future generations. (Tom Ayers/CBC)

"I also have a sneaking suspicion I may be the only mayoral candidate entering this race who is expecting," she said.

"My growing family was one of the reasons we all took the time to truly explore and ensure that this is in fact the right time for me to run."

McDougall said having a baby is a constant reminder that council decisions need to take into account future generations.

She wasn't ready yet to announce a platform, though. McDougall said that will come in the next few weeks.

Non-profit background

However, she said her longtime experience in the non-profit sector and working with grassroots organizations will bring a different flavour to her leadership on council.

McDougall did say she sees a need to rebuild or strengthen council, but would not directly criticize the current mayor.

She also would not point to any of his accomplishments.

"It comes down to votes, so no one person can take credit for anything that happens in that room, because everybody has a say, everybody has a vote," she said.

Private vs. public development

The closest she would come to criticism was to suggest the mayor should not be travelling on the municipality's dime to advocate for a private sector business.

Asked about the proposed container terminal for Sydney harbour, McDougall said the rules need to be clearer on who is working on the port file.

Clarke has travelled in Canada and China in support of the proposed container terminal development, which council has handed over exclusively to a private marketing firm.

"If you have a new shop coming up on Charlotte Street, CBRM council are not travelling on your behalf to go and advocate for your business on Charlotte Street to start up," McDougall said.

"I think there needs to be a bit more of a standard in terms of what constitutes CBRM's involvement in private affairs."

McDougall clashed with her council colleagues and with Mayor Cecil Clarke on occasion, especially early on in her first term. (Tom Ayers/CBC)

McDougall got embroiled in controversy very quickly after getting first elected in 2016.

In January 2017, council's nominating committee was recommending various committee appointments and McDougall, who has some experience in environmental matters, was selected to sit on the province's solid waste resource management committee.

Several older male councillors objected, saying Coun. Jim MacLeod usually got that appointment and had the most experience. They suggested the appointment could get quite "heavy" and required a big commitment.

McDougall took that as a slight and objected, and eventually got the appointment.

No apology

Later that year, in December, she clashed with Mayor Clarke over her decision to sign a letter to the editor along with a group seeking funding for an arts centre.

The letter said councillors were apparently resistant to the project and that was "tantamount to recklessness."

The mayor chastised McDougall during a public council meeting, saying she was disrespectful and unparliamentary by speaking for other councillors or questioning their motives or integrity.

McDougall welcomed the discussion, refusing to apologize and saying her job as councillor is to be a passionate advocate.

Clarke mum on future, for now

Clarke has not said yet whether he intends to run for a third term, but his spokesperson said he will be making an announcement next week.

McDougall said her accomplishments as a first-term councillor included being vocal and raising questions.

One of McDougall's supporters at the announcement was Erika Shea, vice-president of New Dawn Enterprises and a board member of ACAP Cape Breton.

Shea said she was there simply as a friend, but she said it's time CBRM had a new mayor.

"I think there is great energy in the municipality these days," she said.

"I think there are people, both young and old, who are ready for a change and I think that the support that has been articulated for Amanda ... really demonstrates that."

New Dawn Enterprises president Rankin MacSween, who ran twice unsuccessfully against Clarke, told CBC News he is delighted to back McDougall's bid for mayor. (Norma Jean MacPhee/CBC)

Shea said the next mayor needs to work on sustainability and social issues.

New Dawn president Rankin MacSween, who ran twice unsuccessfully against Clarke, told CBC News he is not running again and is delighted to back McDougall's bid for mayor.

"I think she's a symbol for the future," he said.

District 4 Coun. Steve Gillespie was also present as a supporter.

Nomination dates

He said he enjoyed working with McDougall on council and she would be a good mayor.

No one else has made official announcements in the CBRM mayoralty race, although Archie MacKinnon of Little Bras d'Or has said on Facebook that he intends to run and Chris Abbass of Sydney has posted an announcement on his Facebook page and signs are starting to go up for his candidacy.

Nominations in CBRM officially open Aug. 27 and close Sept. 4. Candidates will be officially declared on the ballot on Sept. 8.



Tom Ayers


Tom Ayers has been a reporter and editor for 36 years. He has spent half of them covering Cape Breton and Nova Scotia stories. You can reach him at


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?