Ottawa supports heavy fuel ban for Arctic; northerners seek compensation

The federal government says it will support an international ban on environmentally damaging heavy fuel oils in Arctic shipping. A Nunavut government spokeswoman says the territory will push for measures to help offset the cost to residents and industry.

Nunavut government says territory will push for measures to offset cost for residents

A cargo ship sits near Cambridge Bay, Nunavut, in 2017. The federal government has announced it will support an international ban on the use of environmentally damaging heavy fuel oils in Arctic shipping. (Jason Franson/The Canadian Press)

The federal government has announced it will support an international ban on environmentally damaging heavy fuel oils in Arctic shipping.

The backing, released during meetings on the issue in London, England, comes with a hint that compensation might be coming to ease concerns that forcing shippers to use more expensive fuels will raise costs for northern families.

"Canada is proud to play a leadership role at the International Maritime Organization by supporting this ban and is committed to continue working with other countries, northern residents and marine stakeholders to help reduce economic impacts on northern communities," a release from Transport Minister Marc Garneau said Tuesday.

The ban is supported by two major Inuit organizations — Nunavut Tunngavik Inc., which oversees the Nunavut land claim, and the international group, Inuit Circumpolar Conference.

Banning the use ... shouldn't further add to everyday expenses.- Catriona MacLeod, Nunavut premier's press secretary

"Transport Canada's recent announcement to support an HFO ban in the Arctic demonstrates vision and leadership and is very encouraging," they said in a joint release. 

The International Maritime Organization is considering how to eliminate heavy oil to fuel ships sailing Arctic waters. Arctic countries have already agreed to a ban in principle. The meeting is to set terms for the fuel's phaseout.

Heavy fuel oil is considered a major spill risk because it's so thick it persists in the environment for years. A moderate spill in Russia in 2003 had big impacts still visible more than a decade later in marine mammals.

The fuel is also a major source of black carbon, soot-like particles that darken sea ice and hasten its melting.

It has been banned in the Antarctic for years. The Arctic ban is now supported by seven out of eight countries in the region. Russia is the only holdout.

Arctic communities depend on ocean transport for supplies ranging from dry goods to construction materials.

Transport Canada says the average Nunavut household will see an increase of up to $649 a year due to more expensive replacement fuels. Sealifts used by families to bring in bulk supplies of non-perishable commodities from the South would cost an extra $1,000 for a six-metre shipping container.

A barge from the Desgagnés summer sealift. Inuit groups suggest issuing refunds, tax credits or subsidies to ease the impact of the ban on the cost of shipping to northern communities. (CBC/High Arctic Haulers )

More than half of Eastern Arctic households are already considered severely food insecure, meaning they can't always count on having enough food for their next meal.

Higher fuel prices will also affect mining companies and governments.

The government of Nunavut said it will seek compensation.

"The cost of banning the use and carriage of heavy fuel oil in Arctic waters shouldn't further add to everyday expenses like food, household items and materials," Catriona MacLeod, press secretary for Premier Joe Savikataaq, said in an email.

"The government of Nunavut will advocate that any ban include measures to help offset the cost to Nunavummiut and industry."

The Inuit groups suggest refunds, tax credits or subsidies to ease the impact on northerners.

"Leaving our marine environment unprotected is not an option, nor is offloading costs for environmental protection to the communities," they said.

In a release, Transport Canada said changes will be gradual.

"Ministers also announced they will be seeking a phased-in approach to the ban as Canada discusses with IMO countries ways to help balance the environmental benefits with the economic realities of northern, Indigenous and Inuit communities," the release said.

Consultations with Indigenous and Inuit communities, industry, environmental groups and other governments will continue to be held, it said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.