North

Former Fort Smith Métis president says day school settlement forms 'misleading'

A former N.W.T. Metis president alleges that the day school settlement forms are “misleading” survivors away from the rightful money they deserve. 

Ken Hudson says many are settling for the lowest level of compensation when they deserve more

The Kanien’kehá:ka Onkwawén:na Raotitióhkwa Language and Cultural Center has several day school photos in its archives, but some photos, like this one have little information about when they were taken or who is pictured. (KORLCC)

A former N.W.T. Métis council president alleges that day school settlement forms are "misleading" survivors away from the rightful money they deserve. 

The 15-page Indian day school class action settlement form divides compensation into five levels that is based on the kind of harm that any one student faced. 

Ken Hudson, the former Fort Smith Métis Council local president, said everyone he knows is quickly filling out the form for the lowest amount of compensation owed — because the form does not explicitly spell out how much money should be compensated for common expressions of abuse, like belt strappings. 

"It's just rubbing salt in the wound," Hudson told CBC. "They harm you once, and then they harm you again because of the wording." 

The schools, also called federal day schools, operated separately from residential schools but were operated by many of the same groups that ran residential schools, from the 1860s to the 1990s. The nationwide class action settlement offers former students a range of compensation of up to $200,000, based on abuse suffered while attending the schools.

'Can't they simplify it?' 

The form asks former students at the first level of compensation if they were mocked for their Indigenous heritage, received threats or were the victims of "unreasonable or disproportionate acts of discipline or punishment." If they check 'yes,' the recipient gets $10,000 without having to provide any additional documentation. 

Survivors who check off any of the other levels of compensation, which range from $50,000 to $200,000, need to provide extensive documentation to support their claim, including proof of their attendance at a day school, a written narrative of what happened to them, the names of those who abused them, family testimonies, and any medical records with lists of injuries that happened at the school. 

If survivors don't have the necessary documents, they can fill out a sworn declaration, where they state that everything in the claims form is true to the best of their knowledge. This statement must be witnessed and signed by a guarantor as well.

Ken Hudson points to a class photo included in his day school settlement package. The former Fort Smith Métis president says the forms could be misleading people to settle for less money than they rightfully deserve. (Anna Desmarais/CBC)

The claims are then reviewed by the Canadian government and the claims administrator. 

Hudson said survivors who live in small towns like Fort Smith talk to each other about how much money they are applying for. 

When one person says they will be applying for the lowest level of $10,000, Hudson said, many others are likely to follow suit because they believe that's all they're owed. 

"They're working with all Indigenous people here," he said. "Can't they simplify it to say 'did you get strapped?'" 

More time to revise claims needed

Jeannie Marie-Jewell has helped over 300 survivors in her hometown of Fort Smith by hosting day school settlement information sessions and one-on-one appointments. 

She said the settlement process is difficult for many of her fellow survivors, who initially want to fill out the form for the $10,000 to get it over with, but then after reflecting on their experiences, decide to provide more information for a bigger settlement. 

Jeannie Marie-Jewell has worked with over 300 day school survivors to fill out their forms. She believes that they need to be able to have the option available to them to revise their claims. (Anna Desmarais/CBC)

On Thursday, the claims administrator said they would no longer be accepting revised claims — something that Marie-Jewell said needs to be reversed immediately. 

"When they sit down and they think and they talk to others, they come to recognize that they didn't claim properly and they want to claim properly ," Marie-Jewell said. "The deadline is not until July 2022, why didn't they leave it until at least a year? I just don't understand." 

In a statement to CBC North, the settlement class counsel from Gowling WLG reminded survivors that they can ask for free one-on-one support or join an online workshop to get help. They reminded survivors to take their time filling out the form, because all settlements are only due by July 13, 2022. 

"We know that, after waiting many years for justice and recognition, submitting a claim is a major milestone in many claimants' lives and we are available to provide legal support to all who require it," the statement reads. 

Hudson said he worries about the claimants in smaller communities like Fort Resolution that he went to school with. He wants to see the federal government get involved by providing the money to hire more people like Marie-Jewell to host in-person meetings in those smaller communities. 

"Why would we remember things that happened 50 years ago if they didn't affect us?" Hudson said. 

Clarifications

  • This article was updated from a previous version to clarify that survivors who don't have the necessary documents can fill out a sworn declaration, where they state that everything in the claims form is true to the best of their knowledge.
    Jun 15, 2020 1:55 PM CT

Corrections

  • A previous version of this story incorrectly stated the class counsel said they would no longer be accepting revised claims. In fact, it was the claims administrator who stated this.
    Jun 16, 2020 10:42 AM CT

now