First Air says it followed boarding rules after flying passenger nearly 2,300 km in wrong direction

A northern airline that flew a Winnipeg man to Iqaluit instead of Inuvik says it followed all of its protocols to ensure passengers board the correct flight.

An air passenger rights advocate said the incident raises serious security concerns

Christopher Paetkau, left, thought when he boarded a plane in Yellowknife, N.W.T., he was heading to Inuvik. Instead, he ended up in Iqaluit. (Submitted by Christopher Paetkau)

A northern airline that flew a Winnipeg man nearly 2,300 kilometres in the wrong direction over the weekend says it followed all of its protocols to ensure passengers board the correct flight.

Christopher Paetkau was supposed to board a First Air flight from Yellowknife to Inuvik, N.W.T., on Sunday, but ended up on a flight to Iqaluit instead.

"We can confirm that all protocols and [standard operating procedures] were performed and completed on this specific flight," said Dan Valin, manager of marketing and communications with First Air.

However, the airline did not specify what exactly its protocols and procedures are, whether there was a headcount of passengers once they boarded the plane, or whether the airline checks a list of passengers at the gate.

In a statement from the airline, Valin said First Air was happy to have made Paetkau's "unexpected journey as pleasant as could be."

He said the airline provided Paetkau with a hotel and meal, and flew him to Inuvik the next day for free.

Advocate raises questions about security

Paetkau is lighthearted about the whole situation. He laughs when explaining the pilot told him he remembered this happening once before — to a dog.

"I, in fact, don't hold First Air responsible at all," said Paetkau. "I think that they did a phenomenal job with a very interesting situation."

Paetkau said the flight crew did everything they could to help him and made sure he had food and a place to stay after the mix-up. (Submitted by Christopher Paetkau)

Not everyone agrees.

Gabor Lukacs, a Canadian air passenger rights advocate, said the incident raises serious security concerns.

"It shows that the airline is unable to properly ensure that only passengers authorized to board a flight are on the flight," he said.

"This was a perfectly preventable issue."

Passenger rights advocate Gabor Lukacs says the mix-up raises questions about the security of the flight Paetkau was on. (CBC)

Yukon airline weighs in on boarding procedures

A representative from Air North said there are a number of procedures northern airlines typically follow to ensure people don't get on the wrong flight.

However, operating in the North can come with challenges, said Benjamin Ryan, chief commercial officer with Air North.

For flights where passengers aren't required to go through security, there isn't always the technology to scan boarding passes at the gate, he explained, so passes are checked manually.

"It creates some possibility that you could have a passenger get on the wrong plane," Ryan said. "However, there are a bunch of checks and balances that should remedy that."

Those include announcements to let passengers know which flights are boarding, although Ryan admits they aren't always clear in unsecured parts of airports.

Agents should also be checking names against the list of passengers on the flight when people are at the gate, he said.

"In addition to that, the flight attendant is comparing the total number of people to the manifest number," said Ryan. "And if there's any discrepancies, they'll work with the check-in team to try to identify what the error is."

First Air said it is taking the mix-up on its flight seriously and is conducting an investigation into what happened.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?