Study documents tree species' decline due to climate warming

Yellow cedar, which thrives in soggy soil from Alaska to Northern California and is valued for its commercial and cultural uses, could become a noticeable casualty of climate warming over the next 50 years, an independent study has concluded.

Yellow cedar could become a noticeable casualty of climate warming over the next 50 years, study says

This undated photo provided by the U.S. Forest Service shows yellow-cedar trees growing along Sheep Lake east of the Cascade crest in Washington State. A study documenting mortality of yellow cedar trees in Alaska and B.C. concludes that the future is gloomy for the iconic species valued for its commercial and cultural values. Researchers say additional mortality is likely over the next 50 years as the climate warms and rain replaces snow. (U.S. Forest Service/Associated Press)

A type of tree that thrives in soggy soil from Alaska to Northern California and is valued for its commercial and cultural uses could become a noticeable casualty of climate warming over the next 50 years, an independent study has concluded.

Yellow cedar, named for its distinctive yellow wood, already is under consideration for federal listing in the U.S. as a threatened or endangered species.

The study published in the journal Global Change Biology found death due to root freeze on seven per cent of the tree's range, including areas where it's most prolific. It cited snow-cover loss that led to colder soil.

More than 4,000 square kilometres containing yellow cedar — mostly north of Vancouver Island — have experienced upward of 70 per cent mortality. (U.S. Forest Service/The Associated Press)

Additional mortality is likely as the climate warms, researchers said.

"Lack of snow is only going to become more and more prevalent," said lead author Brian Buma, a University of Alaska Southeast assistant professor of forest ecosystem ecology.

By 2070, winter temperatures in about 50 per cent of the areas now suitable for yellow cedar are expected to rise and transition from snow to more rain, according to the study.

Yellow cedar began to decline in about 1880, according to the U.S. Forest Service, and its vulnerability is viewed as one of the best-documented examples of climate change's effect on a forest tree.

The trees are in the cypress family and are not true cedars, which are part of the pine family. They have grown to 60 metres and can live more than 1,200 years.

70 per cent mortality in some areas

Tlingit, Haida and Tsimshian people used yellow cedar for canoe paddles, tool handles and totem poles. They can harvest a lengthwise strip of bark from a living tree for weaving baskets and hats, and as backing in blankets. The tree can compartmentalize the injury and continue growing.

A 10-foot-tall yellow cedar sculpture, carved by Algonquin artist David Robinson, was installed at the University of British Columbia last fall. (Rafferty Baker/CBC)

The slow-growing trees historically found a niche near bogs. Those wetlands provided openings in the forest canopy but poor soil rejected by other trees.

"Elsewhere, it (yellow cedar) generally gets out-competed by spruce, which grows faster, or hemlock, which can grow in lower light conditions," Buma said.

The study by Alaska, Washington, California and British Columbia researchers documented the magnitude and location of yellow cedar mortality in Canada and the United States.

More than 4,000 square kilometres containing yellow cedar — mostly north of Vancouver Island, B.C. — have experienced upward of 70 per cent mortality. Another 52,000 square kilometres remain, but many of the trees will be vulnerable if projected warming occurs.

Researchers found little mortality in trees at higher elevations in Washington and Oregon where snow level has not diminished and roots have not been exposed to freezing temperatures. Conversely, in some areas, such as parts of Vancouver Island, there's no snow where yellow cedar grows, but temperatures never drop sufficiently to freeze their roots, Buma said.

Effects on other tree species

The effect of climate change on yellow cedar has led to research on other shallow-rooted trees that could be vulnerable, such as sugar maple and yellow birch, said Paul Schaberg, a Forest Service research plant physiologist from Burlington, Vermont. No climate change effects on U.S. trees have been as well-documented as research on yellow cedar, he said.

"Projections are that other species could be negatively impacted, but other species, at least in some places, could be
positively impacted," he said.

The agency has begun a tree atlas, currently listing 134 species, that documents their current and possible future distribution under climate change projections.

A U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service decision on listing yellow cedar as threatened or endangered is scheduled for September 2019, spokeswoman Andrea Medeiros said.

Owen Graham, executive director of the Alaska Forest Association, a timber industry trade group, remains opposed to a listing. Yellow cedar die-off in the last century has been intermittent and natural, he said. Trees that died were replaced by new trees.

"The whole thing is just a stupid effort to try to tangle up the timber supply some more," he said. "It's ludicrous."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?