Nfld. & Labrador

Wabana councillor opens up about rift that's tearing Bell Island apart

What's at the root of all the bickering in Wabana? Around town, it all depends on whom you ask, reports Ryan Cooke.

What is at the middle of all the Wabana woes? That depends on whom you ask

Henry Crane is a town councillor and volunteer in Wabana, on Bell Island. (Eddy Kennedy/CBC)

Henry Crane wanted to accomplish a lot of things when he ran for town council in Wabana. Turning citizens against each other over a political divide was never one of them.

But there he stands, in his first term as a town councillor, on one side of a council kneecapped by infighting between two rival factions.

Not usually one to give interviews, Crane has a habit of posing his own questions before giving answers.

"What's at the root? If you're talking to me or talking to somebody else, you're going to get a difference of opinion from different people."

Depending on who you ask, Crane is either a dedicated volunteer willing to do whatever it takes to better his community, or the architect behind a group of crony councillors constructing Gary Gosine's demise after 24 years as mayor.

They stripped me of everything.- Gary Gosine

If you ask Crane himself, he'll say he is a man trying to keep things on track.

"Gary, our mayor, has been there a long, long time. Is he the root of the problem? I don't know if he is, or if he isn't. But there's no co-operation. There's an animosity there that's between the council and the mayor."

It's been a month since council voted 4-2 to rein in Gosine, ordering him to get their approval and supervision before doing any mayoral business. He had to return his cellphone and give up his office at the town building.

Gary Gosine has been the mayor of Wabana for 24 years. (Eddy Kennedy/CBC)

Gosine told CBC News it was an attempt to take power from his hands. Weeks later, he's still shocked by what transpired when Deputy Mayor Bill Peddle sprang the surprise motion.

"I should not have let the acting deputy mayor speak that night because he was out of order. I did allow him. But I was shocked," he said. 

"They stripped me of everything."

Gosine has returned his phone, which the councillors said he was using for his trucking business. He will also return his mayoral chain, which they said he was not allowed to bring home from the town office.

"But I'm not doing much else," Gosine said.

Like most things on Bell Island, the meaning behind the motion depends on who you ask.

"We've been accused of stripping the mayor of his powers," Crane said. 

"Under the Municipalities Act, the mayor acts under the direction of council. That's all we're saying. We want you to act under our direction. Tell us what's going on. A lot of times, we don't know what's going on, and that's frustrating."

What is at the root?

Gosine believes the beef with Crane began after a report was released on failed mediation attempts between Tourism Bell Island and Radio Bell Island.

The radio station existed inside St. Michael's Regional High School and began making big profits from a local bingo game. It was controlled by a three-way partnership between the school, the station and Tourism Bell Island, the last of which was chaired by Henry Crane.

The Radio Bell Island radio station is located at St. Michael's Regional High School in Wabana, but the school no longer receives a one-third share of the profits. (Bruce Tilley/CBC)

A power struggle that ensued was well documented. The station manager quit, accusing Crane and his Tourism Bell Island friends of trying to bully the station out of the school and shift the split of profits in their favour.

The mediator's report, completed by retired provincial court judge Robert Smith, was not kind to Crane — one section was titled "The Cost of Doing Business With Henry Crane."

It was released to members of the town council, for their eyes only, but it wasn't long before a heavily redacted version was released to the public and media. Gosine believes Crane holds a grudge over how the report was handled.

A section of the mediator's report was titled 'The Cost of Doing Business with Henry Crane.'

An unredacted version of the report is now making the rounds on the island again through social media, showing the names and detailed complaints of those who spoke out against Crane during the mediation process.

"It is a personal attack and it was a personal attack from Day 1," Crane said of the report and its release. "Just because you don't like me? Well, post what you want. It's irrelevant to me."

Payback for Peddle?

After the motion passed and the monthly council meeting came to a close, Gosine said he noticed Peddle waiting at the back of the room as everybody else left.

"He was still waiting by the door and I'm saying to myself, 'What's up?' And I get these two words when I passed him and he started pointing at me: 'Payback.'"

From 2014: Watch CBC's interview with Bill Peddle after he was fired

In a contentious meeting, Wabana council voted to fire the town's tax collector. William Peddle had already left the meeting, but returned when he heard about the decision. He was escorted out by the RCMP 4:08

Before he was deputy mayor, Peddle was a tax collector for the Town of Wabana. He stormed a public meeting in 2014, making conflict of interest allegations against Gosine. After he left the building, another councillor put forward a motion to terminate Peddle's job.

He learned of his firing through a tweet by a CBC reporter.

CBC has made several attempts to reach Peddle since December. Finally reached by phone late last week, he became agitated and said he would never speak to a CBC reporter again.

The next meeting

On Thursday, council will hold its first public meeting of 2019, and the first since the motion against Gosine on Dec. 13.

Both Crane and Gosine said they'll do their part to be civil, despite their disagreements.

How much they really disagree on — again — depends on who you ask.

I'm not interested in going up to a meeting once a month and for a battle  royal .- Henry Crane

In separate interviews, both men happened to cite the same reasons for why they want to be on Wabana's council — improving things like the water supply and garbage collection, and bringing business back to Bell Island.

But when they come together in council chambers, nothing is accomplished.

"I'm not interested in going up to a meeting once a month and for a battle royal," Crane said. 

"It is quite a distraction and it is annoying to sit down, give three or four hours of your time sometimes, and accomplish nothing."

Gosine said the island is divided, but believes most people back him in his fight against council.

He is not a healthy man. After three heart attacks and three strokes, he said this fight could be his last as mayor.

Gosine takes a call from his wife before an interview with CBC, on a phone he was forced to buy at his own expense. Council voted to take back his town-issued phone, along with his access to the town building after hours. (Eddy Kennedy/CBC)

"I want to be able to go out on a nice note," he said. "I tell ya, I could flip … but I'm taking the high road. I'm trying to be orderly, I'm trying to be mannerly, I'm trying to be respectful."

Crane said the council will be united — whether Gosine plays ball, or they have to continue using motions to shape his behaviour.

He would prefer the former, but has shown he's not above the latter.

"If the mayor were to follow the rules, his heart is there, too," Crane said. "Everybody's gotta back up and use common sense. This community was once great and it will be great again."

Read more from CBC Newfoundland and Labrador 

About the Author

Ryan Cooke works for CBC out of its bureau in St. John's.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.