Nfld. & Labrador

Deputy minister ordered The Rooms staff member to delete email, says CEO's assistant

An assistant to The Rooms CEO Dean Brinton says she was told to delete an email containing information about firing a new marketing director.

Investigation found no grounds to prove Mitchelmore was involved

Ted Lomond is now the deputy minister of natural resources. He worked under Chris Mitchelmore in the Department of Tourism, Culture, Industry and Innovation before that. (Terry Roberts/CBC)

A deputy minister under Chris Mitchelmore is accused of ordering a staff member at The Rooms to delete an email containing a controversial firing letter.

Ted Lomond took heat in the House of Assembly last week as Opposition members questioned why the former deputy minister would be telling people to delete public records in the midst of the Carla Foote hiring.

You knew this was going to get ATIPP'd.- Ted Lomond

The questions were directed to Mitchelmore, but it was Premier Dwight Ball who stood and answered after the embattled cabinet minister declined to speak.

Contained within The Mitchelmore Report are five allegations, the fourth of which says Mitchelmore's office directed staff at The Rooms to delete emails.

The accusation

What we know for sure is that on June 15, 2018, Lomond called The Rooms CEO Dean Brinton and told him they were hiring Carla Foote to be executive director of marketing at the musuem, gallery and archive.

Brinton told Lomond he'd already hired someone for a marketing job — they are referred to as "A.B." in the pages of the report.


This letter was sent to Dean Brinton for him to sign and forward to the person he'd hired as marketing director of The Rooms. (The Mitchelmore Report)

Lomond's assistant then sent a form letter to Brinton's office, informing A.B. her contract had been terminated.

It had Brinton's name at the bottom, even though he didn't write it.

The allegation is that Lomond's assistant followed up that email with a phone call to Brinton's assistant, telling her to delete the email.

Government officials and staff are required to keep their emails, since they are accessible to the public upon request. Only "transitory records" — insignificant notes — can be deleted.

Deputy wanted records 'neat and tidy'

In his interview with the citizens' representative for the Mitchelmore Report, Lomond said the firing letter was a transitory record.

"I talked to Mr. Brinton a number of times and I said to him that in light of everything that is happening, I would suggest you delete your transitory records," Lomond told the Office of the Citizens' Representative.

Brinton said he knew their conversation would be subject to requests under the Access to Information and Privacy Protection Act [ATIPPA], and said he wanted to make sure his emails were in order.

"You knew this was going to get ATIPP'd," he told the citizen's rep. "So I would like to have my records neat and tidy, final versions lined up."

The citizens' representative did not find any wrongdoing on the part of Mitchelmore for the emails being deleted, but did not rule whether or not Lomond did anything wrong.

Lomond is now a deputy minister in the Department of Natural Resources.

In the House of Assembly, PC MHA Barry Petten asked if the deputy minister would be fired.

"There was no deliberate attempt here to be hiding key information from the people of the province," Ball said.

PC MHA Helen Conway Ottenheimer asked if deleting emails is a common practice, who ordered the deletion, and what other information has been deleted.

Ball stood for Mitchelmore each time, and said they were just "transitory records."

Read more from CBC Newfoundland and Labrador

About the Author

Ryan Cooke works for CBC out of its bureau in St. John's.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.