Nfld. & Labrador

'It's gonna be ugly': N.L.'s billion-dollar elephant in the room

The financial problems of early '90s Saskatchewan are playing out in this province today, but experts say the issue is not getting enough attention during the election campaign, which is almost halfway over.

Experts say province's fiscal situation not getting enough attention this election

Newfoundland and Labrador’s finances often get compared to Saskatchewan's in the early 1990s, but there are stark differences between the two provinces’ situations, say economists. (CBC)

When Saskatchewan nearly went bankrupt in the 1990s, there was a joke told repeatedly in the province, according to economist Jason Childs: "What do you get your kids for graduation? Luggage."

The past financial problems of the prairie province are playing out today in Newfoundland and Labrador, but experts say the issue is not getting enough attention during the election campaign, which is almost halfway done.

Ottawa eventually bailed out Saskatchewan — after that province dropped an austerity budget that included rural hospital closures and service cuts, leading to some small towns emptying out and disappearing. Newfoundland and Labrador will likely have to take similar measures, Childs, a professor at the University of Regina, said in an interview Monday.

Newfoundland and Labrador is on the brink of insolvency, with a net debt of $16.4 billion. The province spends more on debt servicing than on any government service other than health care.

"It is going to hurt a lot," Childs said, about the sacrifices the province will have to make to course correct. "Is it doable? Yes. Is it pleasant? Absolutely not." The government should begin by shoring up mental health services because people are going to need them, Childs added.

Jason Childs, a professor of economics at the University of Regina, says with the pandemic in mind, Ottawa won't be as able to bail out Newfoundland and Labrador as it did Saskatchewan in the 1990s. (CBC)

Lenders hold the real power

Saskatchewan's brush with insolvency comes up frequently in discussions about N.L.'s finances, but there are stark differences between the two provinces' situations, say both Childs and Russell Williams, a political scientist at Memorial University.

Saskatchewan's economy began to rebound shortly after Ottawa stepped in. Newfoundland and Labrador's economy, by contrast, shows no signs of rebounding, Williams said in an interview Monday. The province's offshore oil industry is still in trouble, he added, despite recent cash injections from the federal government.

Any decision to further support the oil and gas industry would need Ottawa's backing because Newfoundland and Labrador doesn't have any more money to distribute. "We don't have the ability to make direct policy interventions without help from the federal government on a case-by-case basis," he said.

Williams said he likens Newfoundland and Labrador's situation to a kind of receivership, where the lenders are the ones with the real power to make decisions. And with voting day on Feb. 13, only Progressive Conservative Leader Ches Crosbie has brought up in any significant way the possibility the province is going bankrupt, he added.

Though Williams doesn't agree with Crosbie's claims he'd be able to strong-arm Ottawa into an arrangement that suits the province, he said he's glad at least someone is talking about it.

Williams said he doesn't think Ottawa would let the province go bankrupt. Instead, he said, the province will have to ask the federal government to pay off its creditors. "What kind of system is going to be in place to help give Newfoundland and Labrador some debt relief? What requirements is the federal government going to attach to that debt relief? And how much debt relief is coming?"

Russell Williams, a political science professor at Memorial University, worries about the implications of keeping financial discussions behind closed doors. (Terry Roberts/CBC)

Williams said he worries that discussion and answers to those questions will be kept behind closed doors. Andrew Furey, the Liberal leader and incumbent premier, assembled an economic recovery team in the fall, but after a dramatic resignation by a provincial labour leader, it was revealed that members had to sign a non-disclosure agreement. Voters will not see a first draft of the team's findings or its recommendations before the election.

COVID-19 complications

As for Ottawa, Childs said there's likely not much appetite to provide the same type of relief given to Saskatchewan.

There are a few provinces in trouble because of the COVID-19 pandemic, Childs said, noting that Ontario's debt-to-GDP ratio is only slightly lower than Newfoundland and Labrador's. "Is there going to be a lot of support for bailing out Newfoundland [and Labrador] at the federal level, when Ontario is in arguably as much trouble?" he asked.

That reality leaves Newfoundland and Labrador in a difficult place, Childs said, adding, "It's gonna be ugly." But there are
some lessons to take from Saskatchewan's experience, he said.

Childs said that In 1993, then Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow identified a few key services government wanted to protect: kindergarten to Grade 12 education as well as health care and social services. Romanow put everything else on the chopping block and did his best to communicate with citizens, Childs said.

"He said, 'Here are the books. What do we do?' and had that conversation in a meaningful way," Childs said. "And he got re-elected."

Read more from CBC Newfoundland and Labrador

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?

now